raptors w/16m cache, how soon?

I don't think anybody knows. Anyways, adding 16 MB of cache is a surprisingly difficult design challenge. It requires complex algorithms to accurately guess what data to cache, because otherwise the additional cache is going to reduce performance. For faster rotational speeds and transfer speeds, it gets that much harder. It shouldn't be much of a surprise that the first hard drive with 16 MB of cache was a Toshiba 5400 RPM drive for laptops. That's because this is a difficult thing to do.
 
xonik said:
I don't think anybody knows. Anyways, adding 16 MB of cache is a surprisingly difficult design challenge. It requires complex algorithms to accurately guess what data to cache, because otherwise the additional cache is going to reduce performance. For faster rotational speeds and transfer speeds, it gets that much harder. It shouldn't be much of a surprise that the first hard drive with 16 MB of cache was a Toshiba 5400 RPM drive for laptops. That's because this is a difficult thing to do.

Indeed, the 8MB are minimally faster than the 2MB cache ones so you can only guess the 16MB ones will be even less effective. You would see an improvement in synthetic benchmarks like Sandra but there would be little or no real world improvement. I would be much more interested in a 146GB Raptor with 8MB.
 
killerD said:
Indeed, the 8MB are minimally faster than the 2MB cache ones so you can only guess the 16MB ones will be even less effective. You would see an improvement in synthetic benchmarks like Sandra but there would be little or no real world improvement. I would be much more interested in a 146GB Raptor with 8MB.


i'll second the bigger drive versus bigger cache...
 
mjz_5 said:
i'll like all hard drives to be 15000 rpm!
Personally I'd like a a 20k drive, but thats just me :D Solid State = even better.
 
killerD said:
Indeed, the 8MB are minimally faster than the 2MB cache ones so you can only guess the 16MB ones will be even less effective. You would see an improvement in synthetic benchmarks like Sandra but there would be little or no real world improvement. I would be much more interested in a 146GB Raptor with 8MB.
I believe Andntech did a review of the 16mb Maxtor drive and showed that in most cases it competed with or beat the Raptors, had much more drive space, and were much cheaper (per gig). As for me, nothing this high end until either the prices go way down, or the performance goes way up.
 
That may be true, but the performance delta has everything to do with the quality of the caching prediction algorithm. You can't just look at one company's execution and extrapolate that to other hard drive families.
 
obyj34 said:
I believe Andntech did a review of the 16mb Maxtor drive and showed that in most cases it competed with or beat the Raptors, had much more drive space, and were much cheaper (per gig). As for me, nothing this high end until either the prices go way down, or the performance goes way up.
But that Maxtor has NCQ. Big difference. ;)
 
The WD740GD has tagged command queuing, at least. Oh well, I guess all's fair in love and war...
 
saturnine2 said:
Personally I'd like a a 20k drive, but thats just me :D Solid State = even better.

Isn't there a solid state drive on the market? I remember there used to be a 2GB SS drive for $2000, but that was a couple of years ago. I also remember reading someone had come out with a higher GB model for less money, but I haven't looked into it recently.

-MrD
 
Word on the street is $500 for the 512 MB drive, $20,000+ for drives above, say, 40 GB.

Of course, many of these drives are designed for mil-spec compliance or industrial work.
 
Back
Top