Raptor Tarantula Vs. Saitek Eclipse II

spincut

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jan 19, 2005
Messages
1,191
Well no one seems to want to make good stand alone keyboards these days and i cant find any of the good ones to try out in stores (since all i really care about is tight keys with smooth easy on the finger tops).

So anyway, how does the Razr Tarantula keyboard compare to Saitek Eclipse II?

Both are gaming keyboards but they seem very sleek and streamlined, not clunky looking like the logitech g series.
 

Nice answer... and really original...

OP.. If by "tight keys with smooth... uh.. you know.. " then perhaps you should have a look at a laptop type board.. the Dinovo Edge .. or maybe a Deck would suit you better...

I don't really have any experience with the Razr or Saitek... can't help you there but at least there are a few more options for you to consider....
 
i think i'd like to get desktop style though and not notebook, although you seem to mildly understand what i mean. Tight pressing, a smooth cushion (but not mushy) and soft tops (you know how some keyboards have a textured rough top and curled cheapy keys? well my fingers get all worn out pressing those junky types of keys).

to see what i mean i think the logitech MX5000 has very good keys and response, but again isnt exactly what i'm looking for still.

oh and also the Dinovo is like, even more expensive than even most of the keyboards i liked in stores that were hampered because they were wireless and came with a mouse.

anyway those two keyboards from Razr and Saitek at least seem to emphasize typing comfort and arent too "xtreme gamer" types.
 
Like I said, I have never used either of the boards you are looking at, but it seems that there are a lot of people here that really like the Saitek... I have considered picking one up myself..

They aren't really all that expensive, in my opinion... maybe just get one and see?
 
I own both boards, and the tarantula is much better buy if you can afford it.

Better keys
Cooler lightning but no backlight :(
much more customization
more features
sleeeeek looks
 
Like I said, I have never used either of the boards you are looking at, but it seems that there are a lot of people here that really like the Saitek... I have considered picking one up myself..

They aren't really all that expensive, in my opinion... maybe just get one and see?

as important as keyboards are to me (since i do alot of typing) they arent to retailers, if i try it and dont like it i am kind of stuck with it, and in these two specific cases they are a bit pricey, so i want to make sure i make the best choice before i buy.

I own both boards, and the tarantula is much better buy if you can afford it.

Better keys
Cooler lightning but no backlight :(
much more customization
more features
sleeeeek looks

I dont really care about "features" (if anything the only extra buttons i've really appreciated are email and internet quickbuttons and stuff), and i almost dont even like the idea of lighting, unless it's indeed REALLY cool or not distracting (otherwise i may just turn it off).

the keys, what i care most about, i would like to verify.

So i assume you've used both keyboards to claim the razors keys are better? what specifically makes you say they're better in your mind?
 
Had an Eclipse I that wore out pretty fast, can't say if that translates to the Eclipse II at all.

If you're after quality keys, have you looked into mechanical keys at all? Significant price increase (well, compared to standard keyboards, not the more excessively gaudy ones) but way better keys that last much longer.
 
I have the Razer and so far it's the best keyboard I have ever had. I can't say much for the Eclipse because I have never had one but I do recommend you get the Razer. You won't be disapointed.
 
Had an Eclipse I that wore out pretty fast, can't say if that translates to the Eclipse II at all.

If you're after quality keys, have you looked into mechanical keys at all? Significant price increase (well, compared to standard keyboards, not the more excessively gaudy ones) but way better keys that last much longer.

mechanical keys? i'm not sure what you mean.

I have the Razer and so far it's the best keyboard I have ever had. I can't say much for the Eclipse because I have never had one but I do recommend you get the Razer. You won't be disapointed.

Could you at least elaborate a little more?
 
mechanical keys? i'm not sure what you mean.

Most keyboards have a sensor membrane inside, and the keys have some sort of levering mechanism. Mechanical keys refers to an arrangement where each key is a discrete switch. The parts overhead is higher, so they cost on the order of $50-100. However, they last many times longer, and have a much nicer feel to them (my opinion, at least...even on good membrane keyboards, the "wiggly" feeling to the keys bothers me).
 
well unfortunately i've had a hard enough time just finding a good standalone regular keyboard that i could try, i dont think i've seen any mechanical ones.
 
also take a look at the microsoft reclusa - cheaper than the tarantula but also made by razer and supposedly is of similar quality
 
I have an Eclipse II and love it (The three colours are awesome), replaced my Eclipse I that's now on the family computer. Great keyboards however I've never tried a Tarantula yet but have a Razer Diamond back mouse and it rocks.
 
I'm gonna review the Saitek II in this post, just because it's so awesome.

I had the first Saitek for a while. Unfortunately, the thing broke on me. I don't know how, I don't know why, but it just did. I would be typing and the thing would go out of control, launching windows applications, opening the start menu, pretty much the equivalent of randomly smashing keys with your fists. But I did love the keyboard despite the backlight ALWAYS defaulting to on when you start your computer. I hated that. I wanted it to default to off.

I was in a hurry to replace it, so I researched a bit and found the Ideazon Merc was supposed to be a good keyboard, for a very decent price. http://www.ideazon.com/us/products/mercgamingkeyboard.asp

Quick Merc Review:
So I went to Best Buy and bought it. Started using it, and I wasn't too thrilled. The keys felt nice, everything worked as it should... HOWEVER, because lf the gaming buttons, everything on the keyboard is offset to the right. It's tough to go from a normal keyboard to this because you have to shift your hands a couple of inches to the right to type. And the gaming keys, while they worked well, were just hard to get used to after years and years of normal WASD usage. Lastly, the arrow keys and the home/pgup/pgdn section were integrated into the numpad. I hated that! Absolutely despised it. When editing text I always use my pinky finger on the arrow pad to navigate through the lines. It was impossible to get used to on the Merc because of how it was integrated into the num pad. It just wasn't for me.

Fast forward a few days later and I was obsessing over the Tarantula. It just looked really cool but the price was ridiculous. I read a lot of newegg reviews and quite a few users were experiencing issues with the keys not registering sometimes. Some said that you had to MAKE SURE to push them all the way down to get them to register. Others said that they weren't for fast typers because of the same problem. I can't comment about the truth of these statements but when more than one person experiences the same issue, it scares me off.

So I found the beatiful alternative known as the Eclipse II. Saitek knows how to make a keyboard, despite my first one breaking. They don't throw in useless keys and functions such as that Logitech keyboard that looks like a transformer with a friggin LCD. Give me a break! So I did some research, read some reviews and placed the order on newegg. Received it a few days later and I couldn't be happier. The thing looks even better in person with a glossy black finish surrounding the keys. The letter font they use is great. But the best part, besides the backlighting (which can now be set to default to off via the dimmer knob!) is the feel of the keys. It's pretty much the best tactile feedback I've ever had on a keyboard. No effort is required and they confidently "snap" down as you are typing, even if you are a REALLY light typer. It's great, even better than the first Eclipse. I feel like I can type at a million miles per hour with this thing. And lastly, the wrist rest is improved as well. Despite not being curvy like the first one, it feels very comfortable and supportive.

So that's my recommendation. While I have no experience with the tarantula, the reviews scared me off and it just didn't seem worth the hefty price tag. It's very gimmicky as well. Ultra low latency keys? Are you even being serious? No human will EVER be able to tell the difference between a normal keyboard response time and the Tarantula. It's retarded to even advertise that. So I say go for the Eclipse. You will be very happy. :)
 
I have two original Saitek keyboards (one red and one blue) and the new Saitek II. The original keyboard is nice and I loved it. Now the Saitek II is even nicer IMHO. The keys are a little more firm which I like and I love the three colors to choose from. I really dig that violet/purple color and this coming from someone who thought having red color was the best. The colors themselves look more vibrant. Easier to see the keys in the dark.

The impression I get from the Saitek II is that it'll take alot more punishment than the original. It just feels like it can take a better pounding. I never had a problem with my original Saiteks but some people complained that it didnt stand up over time to heavy gaming pounding. Especially concerning the space bar. The Saitek II space bar is more firm than the original so people shouldnt have a problem there. I'm a gamer so I do give it a good workout on a daily basis playing a variety of games like FPS, MMOs, and Strategy games. Its fine for office work too IMO. I dont get any crampness from normal typing.

A buddy here at work has a Saitek II as well and he says its the best keyboard he has had and he's a gamer too. He prefers the red color though. I would definately reccomend the Saitek II to anyone who wants a keyboard that lights up. The Saitek II is definately a improvement over the original.

Sorry,I cant comment on the Raptor. Never have used one before.
 
Jaguax, i understand that the Eclipse is a nice keyboard, i wouldnt be comparing it and the Razr if i didnt at least observe that from user reviews (still not as good as TRYING them though :( ) but i cant definitvely go with the Eclipse and trust all the negative stuff you said based on that, which of course is why it would be nice if someone has actually used both and would either echoe such a sentiment....or would say otherwise.
 
I HAVE USED BOTH FOR MONTHS EACH IN ALL TYPES OF ENVIROEMENTS (LAN's, HOME, ETC.) SO I KNOW WHAT IM TALKING ABOUT.

I personally like the razer better. the keys feel different than any keyboard out. They have an almost aluminum, cold plastic, grippy feel to them. They are 1/2 size of standers keys, and are great keys. The razer does not feature backlightning, only some lightning. I have noticed my razer is dirtier than my eclipse, but not by much. I do like both, but i personally like the razer better.
 
i think i'd like to get desktop style though and not notebook, although you seem to mildly understand what i mean. Tight pressing, a smooth cushion (but not mushy) and soft tops (you know how some keyboards have a textured rough top and curled cheapy keys? well my fingers get all worn out pressing those junky types of keys).
I've tried both keyboards and i prefer the saitek's keys by far. The Tarantula's keys feel mushy to me.
 
I HAVE USED BOTH FOR MONTHS EACH IN ALL TYPES OF ENVIROEMENTS (LAN's, HOME, ETC.) SO I KNOW WHAT IM TALKING ABOUT.

I personally like the razer better. the keys feel different than any keyboard out. They have an almost aluminum, cold plastic, grippy feel to them. They are 1/2 size of standers keys, and are great keys. The razer does not feature backlightning, only some lightning. I have noticed my razer is dirtier than my eclipse, but not by much. I do like both, but i personally like the razer better.

it's dirtier?? and what do you mean the keys are 1/2 the size? that actually sounds too small.

i would indeed like to hear more about how they differ in keywork,surface and typing though.
 
if you really wanna get a feel for the tarantula keys, go to best buy or circuit city and try out the keys on the logitech cordless desktop s510. it has keys that are very similar to that of the tarantula's :)

hehe of course i already have been there anyway, but neither had that specific keybaord on display.

i'll say this though i was somewhat fond the the key feel from the Logitech MX5000, which one is THAT most similar to? (the MX5000 specifcally, the somewhat similar MX3200 felt a little squishier).
 
I had a g15 that got some mt dew spilled on it and needed a keyboard asap so I picked up a Saitek Eclipse II as the g15 wasnt in stock at the local store. It was not as responsive in FPS games as the g15 was, nor was it as stable on the desk (saitek is light).. it kept moving around. A few month later I ended up trading the saitek to a friend for a g15 and man am I happy again :D
 
You should try a DAS keyboard. The keys are mechanical, so they are very responsive. Also, DAS keyboard can help you type faster by forcing you to not look at the keyboard. This can also probably help you become a better gamer :p (I aways catch myself looking at the number buttons for weapons :) )
 
You should try a DAS keyboard. The keys are mechanical, so they are very responsive. Also, DAS keyboard can help you type faster by forcing you to not look at the keyboard. This can also probably help you become a better gamer :p (I aways catch myself looking at the number buttons for weapons :) )

That's one, Steelkeys 6G is another without the weird gimmick (or for those of us that already touchtype but maybe still want to look for the symbols we only use rarely). There are others that aren't hard to google up. There are more utilitarian ones around for cheaper; Das & 6G are marked up further because they figure their target markets are already used to being easily separated from their cash. Even with those two, you can probably save a bit just by shopping around...I've seen the 6G ranging from $80 to $120. Steep, but you see ones by Logitech and so forth in that range just because they have media buttons or a LCD...here you get better keys and a significantly longer-lasting part.
 
I'm yet another person who had the Saitek Eclipse I and currently, the II.

I cannot add more to what has already been posted, responsive keys, no crazy off-the-wall key layout so you have to learn to type all over again, such as some gaming keyboards out there, and the laser etched keys with the back light are sweet for low to no level lighting enviros. as for added features, there are a couple of additional media buttons, (volume control, play/pause, stop, and next/previous track).


Only odd thing are the function keys, which are 1/3 smaller than the rest of the keys,
Sturdy board nonetheless.

Jer...
 
i dont know if from the sound of it that the DAS keyboard and the like would be my thing.

Although i want nice smooth keys that also have good feedback (but not TOO hard, a little softness is good too), it just sounds a little too IBM-clackety to me.

I also have preused reviews from Amazon and Newegg, as well as evaluations from extremetech and techage and all, while positive about both do seem to prefer to the eclipse II from the sound of it.
 
So i did something a little off kilter and when i was at Best Buy i opened an Eclipse II and played with it for a sec (yeah yeah yell at me, but they had all their other keyboards on display, why not the Eclipse and Razer?? Oh they didnt have any Razers in anyway).

Anyhow i found one thing that really bothered me about it, the keys are kind of spaced far apart and they "plateu" a little bit, meaning the tops seem rather smaller than on other keyboards (making hitting them accurately a little more of a challenge it would seem).

this kind of annoys me, because i like rather flat filling keys (again referencing the Logitech MX5000).

I dunno, i still dont think i want to put down all that money for a Razer.

I might make a different thread about it, but i really still liked best out of all the keyboards i actually tried the Logitech MX5000, but it was wireless and came with a useless mouse.

for those that have used the MX5000 what would you say is the closest wired stand alone keyboard to it, in terms of key surface, size, and response???
 
Back
Top