Justintoxicated
[H]F Junkie
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2002
- Messages
- 14,522
Hi I have a 500GB WD RE annd 500Gb WD SE drive. I was thinking about raiding them together with Raid-1 for my dad's PC.
Is this a bad idea?
Is this a bad idea?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Speed wise I think they are the same but one is SE and one is RE. The RE drive does not have error checking enabled (TLER). But does it matter for raid-1?
is using one SE and 1 RE going to kill my performance?
I wanted to raid-1 my dad's C but I already have the SE drive and I just got my 500GB RE drive for $6 off hoopstick.
The chart from the article under the heading "Stand-Alone vs RAID Hard Disk Usage Considerations," makes it pretty easy.
In stand alone, disable TLER, but in a RAID enable it. It doesn't really have anything to do with performance, it just keeps a drive in a RAID array from spending too much time on error correcting when the array can accomplish the same task quicker. You definitely do not want TLER on a stand alone drive. That could cause problems if you limit the onboard error recovery without the RAID array to handle those chores.At least that's what I got from the article.
Don
Well, if you have a really good drive that does not get alot of bad sectors, you will run fine with TLER on. If you have a not so good drive, then all bets are off. It may work flawlessly for years, but it is not the PREFERRED application for that drive. Your chances for data corruption with that drive are higher than with a drive with TLER off.
I believe the RE drives do have a higher MTBF than the SE drives. They may even have a better warranty. Enterprise class drives tend to have better warranties than consumer class drives. But functionally, yes, it would turn your SE into an RE.
Don
Yea I'm loading the newest drivers, extracted them from teh EXE and put them on an external USb USB drive. It loads the drivers but it can not find the array. Maybe it is because I'm using an SE and RE hard drive?
Is this a bad idea?
Did you change the TLER settings on the 2 drives to match? Other than that, there should be little difference between the 2 drives as far as a RAID controller could tell.
Don
Yea, that's the problem with running Vista 64 (or XP 64 for that matter.) They sometimes require separate drivers from the 32 bit version. I can definitely see the Raid controller being one of those instances.
Does the controller manufacturer specifically mention 64 bit support?
Don
Personally I would not raid an SE and an RE togehter, not only is TLER an issue, but they are to very diffrent drives. I would either get another RE or use them both in a non-raid but mirrored enviroment.