Raid1 RE and SE hard drives?

Justintoxicated

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Apr 10, 2002
Messages
14,522
Hi I have a 500GB WD RE annd 500Gb WD SE drive. I was thinking about raiding them together with Raid-1 for my dad's PC.

Is this a bad idea?
 
Early RAID controllers required exact matches with the drives involved. The current ones are not picky. The Array will simply default to the smallest and slowest drive.

Don
 
Speed wise I think they are the same but one is SE and one is RE. The RE drive does not have error checking enabled (TLER). But does it matter for raid-1?

is using one SE and 1 RE going to kill my performance?

I wanted to raid-1 my dad's C but I already have the SE drive and I just got my 500GB RE drive for $6 off hoopstick.
 
Speed wise I think they are the same but one is SE and one is RE. The RE drive does not have error checking enabled (TLER). But does it matter for raid-1?

is using one SE and 1 RE going to kill my performance?

I wanted to raid-1 my dad's C but I already have the SE drive and I just got my 500GB RE drive for $6 off hoopstick.

Good read here. Should answer all your questions.

Don
 
Wow that article is kind of confusing.

it sounds to me like I should disable the TLER on my raptor drive to increase performance.

And enable TLER Write on the 500GB SE drive to raid with the RE2 drive?

Can someone confirm this?
 
The chart from the article under the heading "Stand-Alone vs RAID Hard Disk Usage Considerations," makes it pretty easy.

In stand alone, disable TLER, but in a RAID enable it. It doesn't really have anything to do with performance, it just keeps a drive in a RAID array from spending too much time on error correcting when the array can accomplish the same task quicker. You definitely do not want TLER on a stand alone drive. That could cause problems if you limit the onboard error recovery without the RAID array to handle those chores. :confused: At least that's what I got from the article.

Don
 
The chart from the article under the heading "Stand-Alone vs RAID Hard Disk Usage Considerations," makes it pretty easy.

In stand alone, disable TLER, but in a RAID enable it. It doesn't really have anything to do with performance, it just keeps a drive in a RAID array from spending too much time on error correcting when the array can accomplish the same task quicker. You definitely do not want TLER on a stand alone drive. That could cause problems if you limit the onboard error recovery without the RAID array to handle those chores. :confused: At least that's what I got from the article.

Don

Well I have an old RE 400 GB drive that has had TLER enabled for years (or it should anyways being an RE drive). I have never had a problem and in facvt is seems to be one of my most reliable drives so I'm nor sure.

But what I want to do is Raid 1 a 500GB SE with 500GB RE, so if you canin fact enable TLER on the SE It would then become the same drive as the RE and I should have no problems raiding them together for raid-1 right?
 
Well, if you have a really good drive that does not get alot of bad sectors, you will run fine with TLER on. If you have a not so good drive, then all bets are off. It may work flawlessly for years, but it is not the PREFERRED application for that drive. Your chances for data corruption with that drive are higher than with a drive with TLER off.

I believe the RE drives do have a higher MTBF than the SE drives. They may even have a better warranty. Enterprise class drives tend to have better warranties than consumer class drives. But functionally, yes, it would turn your SE into an RE.

Don
 
Well, if you have a really good drive that does not get alot of bad sectors, you will run fine with TLER on. If you have a not so good drive, then all bets are off. It may work flawlessly for years, but it is not the PREFERRED application for that drive. Your chances for data corruption with that drive are higher than with a drive with TLER off.

I believe the RE drives do have a higher MTBF than the SE drives. They may even have a better warranty. Enterprise class drives tend to have better warranties than consumer class drives. But functionally, yes, it would turn your SE into an RE.

Don

I think they do have a higher MTBF, however I think WD lists them the same but provides a different warranty ;)
I'll try to turn TLER on for the SE drive.

I think your confusing me, for the raid1 setup why would I want TLER off?
 
I have not been able to raid these drives successfully.

Using DFI Ultra-D after creating the raid array Vista fails to see the arrary and only detects the drives as individual drives. I have tried lloading drivers, and the drivers do load, but vista once again, fails to see the array. It does however say that vista can not be installed to one of the drives so I went ahead and installed to the other one.

Vista installs and Ic an boot vista, but from inside windows I see the drives independently. The bio sstill says I have a healthy raid array WTF!
So I go in and try to repair one of the drives. Controller hangs. Every time I get into the controllet it just hangs :(

Should I give up on the idea of a Raid-1 setup? Is this because one of the drives is an SE and the other is an RE?
 
Are you loading Vista drivers for the array during the install process?

Don
 
Yea I'm loading the newest drivers, extracted them from teh EXE and put them on an external USb USB drive. It loads the drivers but it can not find the array. Maybe it is because I'm using an SE and RE hard drive?

Is this a bad idea?
 
Yea I'm loading the newest drivers, extracted them from teh EXE and put them on an external USb USB drive. It loads the drivers but it can not find the array. Maybe it is because I'm using an SE and RE hard drive?

Is this a bad idea?

Did you change the TLER settings on the 2 drives to match? Other than that, there should be little difference between the 2 drives as far as a RAID controller could tell.

Don
 
Did you change the TLER settings on the 2 drives to match? Other than that, there should be little difference between the 2 drives as far as a RAID controller could tell.

Don

Not yet, cause you have to do that from command prompt and I have no OS. I plan on doing this as soon as I get windows installed I found a copy of the program on linked on this forum while googling.

I just flashed the Bios on the MB so I have my fingers crossed!
 
No luck, Vista continues to detect both drives as independent drives rather than being part of a raid array. I have tried 3 versions of drivers v15, 10, and 9. No matter what when it returns tot he part asking me where to install I see 2 500GB drives and no raid array.

This is Vista 64 BTW not 32bit version.

I have been using this tutorial but it does not work. I haven't tried the legacy version yet, cause its probably not worth setting up Raid-1 if it is going to make me go to this length to get it working.
 
Yea, that's the problem with running Vista 64 (or XP 64 for that matter.) They sometimes require separate drivers from the 32 bit version. I can definitely see the Raid controller being one of those instances.

Does the controller manufacturer specifically mention 64 bit support?

Don
 
Yea, that's the problem with running Vista 64 (or XP 64 for that matter.) They sometimes require separate drivers from the 32 bit version. I can definitely see the Raid controller being one of those instances.

Does the controller manufacturer specifically mention 64 bit support?

Don

Yes I have tried 3 version of the 64 Bit Drivers. Windows refuses to see the drives as a raid array, but rather lists them as independent devices :(.

Its an Nforce4 MB so the drivers should already be included in the Vista CD anyways.

My slipstreamed SP1 copy of vista failed as well. It refused to detect the raid array. The array is visable i the bios and set to #1 for boot priority. I guess Vista can't be installed on this PC because it insists they are not raided :( I'll jstu tell my dad it is impossible to raid the hard drives. I can't believe I wasted so much of my life on something so basic and simple.
 
Well, if they have written V64 drivers, it may just be bad hardware that is causing your problem. Is the board new, can it be exchanged or RMA'd.

I can't believe the drives would cause a problem like that. But anything is possible I guess.

Don
 
The board is used I just got it to repalce my DFI-Expert because it died on me.

I followed this tutorial some more.
http://www.nforcershq.com/forum/vista-and-nvraid-installation-guide-and-troubleshooting-vt66299.html

Created that Legacy ISO image.

Booted into vista and it seems to see teh raid array as one drive.

"Great Success!"

but wait, now that it seems the raid array, it will not let me install to it! I guess theres no Vista 64 drivers for legacy NF4 raid systems. Geez, i think Nvidia has had long enough to make these. So no raid for Vista 64 on this MB, only 32 bit.

So, now the question is: do I ditch a Gig of Ram, or my Raid-1 Array?

Will a software raid solution work on the primary boot drive? I have never used software Raid. If software Raid-1 is a solution, should I have TLER enabled or disabled on both drives? From what I read it should be disabled for software raid.
 
Personally I would not raid an SE and an RE togehter, not only is TLER an issue, but they are to very diffrent drives. I would either get another RE or use them both in a non-raid but mirrored enviroment.
 
Did you change the hard drive settings in the BIOS from IDE to RAID?

Don't change it to AHCI ---- that takes away your raid option.


Don't install any OS until you have your raid set up first in the BIOS.
 
Personally I would not raid an SE and an RE togehter, not only is TLER an issue, but they are to very diffrent drives. I would either get another RE or use them both in a non-raid but mirrored enviroment.

They are? I thought they were pretty much the same?

Anyways there are no proper nvidia drivers for my Nforce4 Raid and Vist x64. I guess it is a legacy Nforce4 raid system even though it is Nforce4 Ultra chipset.

What about setting up a software raid? Can I raid the OS drive visa software inside of vista? I have never tried it before.

TLER isnt an issue cause I can convert the 2 drives but is there other differences? Last time I checked SE vs RE all specs were identicle other than TLER and longer warranty for the RE. I have to admit I like RE drives better for some reason....They seem to last longer,
 
Back
Top