Raid Questions...regarding OS and asking some suggestions...

tel1jag

Limp Gawd
2FA
Joined
Apr 29, 2002
Messages
138
I will apologize in advance if this has been spelled out here already...but I have done a quick search or two of this forum and on google, and I can't find anything to help with specific questions or that I found detailed enough.

I just built a new system at home...Intel Quad (Core 2 Quad Q9550) and an ASUS Maximus II Formula Intel P45. I have 3 drives...SEAGATE Barracuda 7200.11 ST3500320AS 500GB. Also, if it matters, I have 8GB of Corsair memory and I am running Windows Vista 64bit, to take advantage of the memory.


I was hoping to make the machine fairly resilient and decided to RAID 5 the drives...I built one big partition and installed the OS in it was just about to use it. However, I was discussing this with a collegue and he mentioned I should NOT put the OS on the RAID 5. He suggested making a mirror (RAID 0) for the OS and getting a few more drives and doing RAID 5 for the data.

However, my response was that although that did sound wiser, the reason I have the OS as part of the RAID 5 is that Windows installs most everything under the OS directories (I know you can change it, but it still puts stuff under \Windows) and that things like my music in iTunes and my Pictuers in MY DOCUMENTS was what I was most worried about....again, I know that you can change it, but my experience with Windows is that when you screw around with default locations you eventually come to poor results...or you install something and forget to change it....etc.)

So (if I haven't bored you to tears yet)...I have 2 main questions, with a couple of minor ones...


1. Is RAID 5 including the OS....bad? (The motherboard supports it via hardware and I am using the Intel drivers) Will it be bad performance? If a disk goes what happens?



2. I am also making my oldest machine into a backup area...probably running FreeNAS on it and just making it a network share...then imaging this new computer and one other to it via Acronis to have a machine with some images on it for me....Will I be able to image via this RAID with no problems?


Anyway, hats off to whomever is still reading and I very much appreciate any advice or thoughts you would have for me.


Thank you.

--Jeff
 
First of all, mirror is Raid 1.

As far as putting everything on one Raid 5 volume, versus the OS on a separate Raid 1, that really depends on your circumstances. Putting everything on a Raid 5 may be an option if you're limited in the number of drives you can use due to cost or physical space in the server. However, putting the OS on a separate mirrored or stripped (Raid 1) volume is usually better for performance since the data volume disk writes and reads don't interfere with the OS volume reads and writes, especially if they're on separate controllers. So there are arguments for both sides.

In your case, since it sounds like you'll be using this as a desktop and just want reliability, Raid 5 should be good enough. As you observed, Windows tends to like having things its own way as far as file location, so this is another argument for Raid 5.
 
What you have setup isn't *bad*
But most people running big arrays either use them as a NAS setup (on a seperate computer, running as just a fileserver, not a workstation), and/or set the OS on a different drive (may or may not be raid at all).
The benefit of using a seperate drive for user data (pictures, videos, music, etc) is that wiping the OS drive (say something crashes out of the blue and takes down the OS, requiring a format) doesnt wipe your data. And backups are simpler, just drag the whole drive's data, no seperating out windows.

Id never use my OS drive/partition as anything BUT the OS and apps/games. The server in my sig has a 30GB OS drive, but its 60% empty (server2k8 takes a lot of space :/ ). If the drive dies, drop in a spare drive (almost anything will do) and boom, right back up and running. The laptop is just one drive, but it has a 60GB OS partition and a 100GB data partition setup. Its as close as I can get to the same effect.
 
Back
Top