RAID Failure due to Power Outage?

DudeItsMe

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Aug 10, 2004
Messages
15,720
I'm relatively new to using RAID so I am not quite sure what the best solution is here.

I built a computer for a friend who seems to suffer from frequent power outages. After he had a hard drive failure, I decided to put him on RAID 1.

The other day the computer would not boot up, saying it had a system disk error. I am thinking that a power outage caused the RAID controller to think the RAID needed a rebuild. After a rebuild, it was up and running again.

What steps should I take to keep this from happening to him often? He seems to have frequent power problems. Would a UPS do anything? I would think that it would still eventually go offline while he was out of the house. Is this normal behavior for a RAID?
 
Yes a UPS would help. I have this happen on my primary PC from time to time. It was really annoying because the power at my place could be flaky at times and my UPS for it was out for repair for a while. But yes just put a UPS on the pc and use the included software to turn off the computer in a clean manner when it loses power. Most UPS'es come with software and a USB cable to connect to the computer. The software can be set to turn off the computer when it sees the UPS at a certain battery level and things like that. You wont be able to (or wont want to) buy a UPS big enough to keep the computer online for hours on end all you need is something to turn it off cleanly. If the computer does not have a high end video card in it you can get away with a pretty small ups (500-750VA) that should give enough time for the computer to shut down. You can find deals on off brand UPS in the 1000VA range as well so might as well go with those if you can. expect to spend 100-200 regardless.
 
Also server grade APC refurbished units with new batteries can be had in this price range.

Oh that's very true. You can certainly get some very good UPS if you go that route. I wish I could find ones similar to what I just installed at a center. Dell model 1920s. Up time for a Poweredge 710 was 3 and a half hours lol.
 
Okay, that answers my question. I did not know that the UPS had the capability to shut down the computer, but it makes sense that it should. I just did not know how it would go about doing it.

Computer specs are:

ABIT IP35P LGA 775 Mobo
C2D E8400
PC Power & Cooling 420W PSU
4 GB of RAM
EVGA 9600Gt 512 MB DDR3
Windows 7 x64

Based on that what do you think I should get to run the computer? I don't think the customer will have a problem paying for the UPS. I imagine 5 mins or so to shut down the computer would be more than enough.

Would it matter if the computer is in sleep mode when the power outage occurs? Will the UPS wake the computer then shut it down?
 
If it is a customer I would get an APC 750VA or so. The UPS would have to wake the machine out of sleep to shutdown. I have never tried that so I am not sure. The software probably provides this as long as you have the ability for USB devices to wake the machine enabled.
 
He's kinda a customer, kinda a friend of my dad's. I built the computer and he calls me for tech support. However he has no problem paying for any sort of work if I say it's needed. That being said, I don't want to drive out there every time power outages cause him a problem, and he won't want to wait for a RAID rebuild every time the power goes out :D

I have no idea why his power is such shit. It's new construction, a very wealthy neighborhood. The entire neighborhood is very new.
 
You really want a UPS on any RAID system even if you have a BBU on a dedicated RAID controller and are using RAID 1. $100-$200 for data loss protection is a pretty good deal. Not to mention that losing power, then getting power, then losing power, then getting power is generally considered bad for components.
 
Yeah, I think that may be what killed his hard drive. It was maybe two years old, Seagate 7200.11. That said, I've only had Seagates fail and am strictly WD now. However, this one failed in a way unlike any others, where it would not spin up at all (it tried to). Of course, all the other ones I had fail I recognized the warning signs and backed them up. He may not have seen the warning signs.
 
Back
Top