R520 ready for production!!!

The high end enthusiast boat has sailed, ATi missed it by 3 months. You snooze you lose.
 
5150Joker said:
The high end enthusiast boat has sailed, ATi missed it by 3 months. You snooze you lose.


what are you talking about they lose >? nVidia finally took over ATI with their 7800GTX, while ATI's X850 was top dog up till now. Then the R520 will come out soon and nVidia will be 2nd place again. So no, the 7800GTX lose in a couple of weeks :)
 
You could paint it a1000 times clearer than that Lab, and they still wouldn't get it. :D
 
F a n n y b o y s, you done yet? Nvidia layed the smackdown on ATI before the 9700 pro. I mean you never WANTED to buy an ATi card during any time before the 9700. Saying you had an ATi inside during a LAN party got you a spit on. Then Nvidia quite simply fucked up, ATi took the performance crown and a many consumers. Then the 6 series came along with a shit load of new features, but ATi road the same one trick R300 core into the next generation with more pipes and insane clock speeds. Why would people buy a 225 hp BMW for the same price as a 400 hp Pontiac. That BMW with a shit load of technology and optimizations can still out run and out corner brute force. That's what Nvidia did and kudos to them, ATi just kept pushing the clock speeds and uber low yields to hold the performance crown. Nvidia got their groove back and introduced many features that ATi still hasn't integrated. Oh and SLi, has anyone seen a Crossfire board yet?

Fast forward to the present, Nvidia holds the performance crown, kept clock speeds low, introduced new features and the only thing in the ATi boat is the X800GT LOL.

Nvidia will always be the #1 graphics company for the high-end because they always innovate and introduce new features each product line, and their Quadros sweep the floor with FireGL cards. Also, except the FX series, Nvidia always introduced their product lines first while ATi followed.

I hope ATi proves me wrong and kicks the shit out of the 7800 but I hope they do it properly with an optimized architecture instead of ramping some shitty core up to 700mhz and consuming 400w of power.
 
Labrador said:
what are you talking about they lose >? nVidia finally took over ATI with their 7800GTX, while ATI's X850 was top dog up till now. Then the R520 will come out soon and nVidia will be 2nd place again. So no, the 7800GTX lose in a couple of weeks :)


Sorry to disappoint you there is a good chance the r520 isn't going to clean house, it might be 5% faster at most if its a 16 pipe card.
 
Labrador said:
what are you talking about they lose >? nVidia finally took over ATI with their 7800GTX, while ATI's X850 was top dog up till now. Then the R520 will come out soon and nVidia will be 2nd place again. So no, the 7800GTX lose in a couple of weeks :)

Do you have any facts to back that up? Or is that just wishful thinking? I can point out forums full of enthusiasts that bought a 7800 GTX, can you say the same for R520? Oh that's right it's not available! Like I said, they missed the boat because a lot of people who were going to get the R520 (myself included) got tired of waiting and went with a 7800 GTX instead. With the latest and most reliable info. putting the R520 at a highly clocked 16-1-1-1 part, I doubt it will outrun the 7800 GTX by much if at all -- and even if it does somehow manage to beat the 7800 GTX by >15% you can bet nVidia will have an answer quickly. ATi just hasn't been able to keep up with nVidia lately, those are the glaring facts, even I realized that.

BTW I'm an ATi fan, have been since I bought the 9700 pro up until I sold my X800XT PE and I like their image quality better but sadly they just can't seem to keep up with nVidia anymore. It's as if nVidia keeps innovating and then ATi plays follow the leader 6 months to a year later. If they want to regain their old position, they need to start leading the industry with new features and more advanced cores rather than waiting on nVidia to innovate; thanks to nVidia we have SLI/HDR/SM 3.0/TMSAA/TSSAA and who knows what else in the future. I remember ATi outright dismissing SLI and now they're embracing it with Crossfire.
 
that is not entirely correct, remember when there was the ORIGINAL RADEON 64MB, if i recall it PWNED the hell out of the vooDoo 5xxx?, and whatever the contemporary nVidia offering was.

edit : It seems many of the people who bought the 7800gtx feel they have to bark on and on that it is the best, and they didn't jump the gun. The others don't care whether they could've got better performance down the line, but it still remains that those willing to wait often are rewarded for their patience.
 
furocious said:
that is not entirely correct, remember when there was the ORIGINAL RADEON 64MB, if i recall it PWNED the hell out of the vooDoo 5xxx?, and whatever the contemporary nVidia offering was.

edit : It seems many of the people who bought the 7800gtx feel they have to bark on and on that it is the best, and they didn't jump the gun. The others don't care whether they could've got better performance down the line, but it still remains that those willing to wait often are rewarded for their patience.
No. The Geforce 2 beat the original Radeon 256 in gaming benchmarks. Beating the Voodoo 5 was an easy task for both nVidia and ATI.
 
5150Joker said:
Do you have any facts to back that up? Or is that just wishful thinking? I can point out forums full of enthusiasts that bought a 7800 GTX, can you say the same for R520? Oh that's right it's not available! Like I said, they missed the boat because a lot of people who were going to get the R520 (myself included) got tired of waiting and went with a 7800 GTX instead. With the latest and most reliable info. putting the R520 at a highly clocked 16-1-1-1 part, I doubt it will outrun the 7800 GTX by much if at all -- and even if it does somehow manage to beat the 7800 GTX by >15% you can bet nVidia will have an answer quickly. ATi just hasn't been able to keep up with nVidia lately, those are the glaring facts, even I realized that.

BTW I'm an ATi fan, have been since I bought the 9700 pro up until I sold my X800XT PE and I like their image quality better but sadly they just can't seem to keep up with nVidia anymore. It's as if nVidia keeps innovating and then ATi plays follow the leader 6 months to a year later. If they want to regain their old position, they need to start leading the industry with new features and more advanced cores rather than waiting on nVidia to innovate; thanks to nVidia we have SLI/HDR/SM 3.0/TMSAA/TSSAA and who knows what else in the future. I remember ATi outright dismissing SLI and now they're embracing it with Crossfire.

ATI is the only one that went Unified Shaders for consoles and then next years release and the only one that went 90nm, and the only ones with an excellent and working acceptable SM2.0 part at launch and the only ones who support SM1.4 while nVidia dismissed it for all Nforce 4 cards. And the ones who created Alternate Frame Renderring that is now back in use today by nVidia and ATI. nVidia has not lead in innovation always; hardly the case.
 
F a n n y b o y s, you done yet? Nvidia layed the smackdown on ATI before the 9700 pro. I mean you never WANTED to buy an ATi card during any time before the 9700. Saying you had an ATi inside during a LAN party got you a spit on. Then Nvidia quite simply fucked up, ATi took the performance crown and a many consumers. Then the 6 series came along with a shit load of new features, but ATi road the same one trick R300 core into the next generation with more pipes and insane clock speeds. Why would people buy a 225 hp BMW for the same price as a 400 hp Pontiac. That BMW with a shit load of technology and optimizations can still out run and out corner brute force. That's what Nvidia did and kudos to them, ATi just kept pushing the clock speeds and uber low yields to hold the performance crown. Nvidia got their groove back and introduced many features that ATi still hasn't integrated. Oh and SLi, has anyone seen a Crossfire board yet?
Lol if any ATi fan n b o y were to say something along these lines they would be bashed like five times over. I always find it funny how bad ATI Fan boys are treated (not defending them) yet Nvidia Fan boys can come out screaming that yeah Nvidia has never let them down (Cough Cough FX line...) so they are quite biased towards them and all us logical people have to sit here and say ok ok fine. I always hated that meh let idiots be idiots.

Neubspeed Im not just dissing you your post had some good info in it but stuff like.
Nvidia will always be the #1 graphics company for the high-end because they always innovate and introduce new features each product line, and their Quadros sweep the floor with FireGL cards. Also, except the FX series, Nvidia always introduced their product lines first while ATi followed.

Also while the X800GT may be late lets face it its a great product. At that price/Performance range SM3.0 isnt needed and at that price I may buy it for my next Shuttle PC.

Also what does it matter if ATI ramps core speeds? the X800 gen had similar power reqs as the 6800 series a smaller board and was just as fast or faster in certain games.

Thats all for me!
 
Shifra said:
ATI is the only one that went Unified Shaders for consoles and then next years release and the only one that went 90nm, and the only ones with an excellent and working acceptable SM2.0 part at launch and the only ones who support SM1.4 while nVidia dismissed it for all Nforce 4 cards. And the ones who created Alternate Frame Renderring that is now back in use today by nVidia and ATI. nVidia has not lead in innovation always; hardly the case.


They haven't been innovating enough in the past 3 years. It can't come in bursts, otherwise someone else will come out on top.

Where is the 90 nm thing come in nV is also doing 90 nm for the RSX, come on thats not even innovation, just a fab choice doesn't really have much to do with innvoation unless they are making the fab too. If thats the case the nv30 would be the most radical and innovative chip when it came out not just a bloated dx8 chip. nV has been doing 3d chips longer then ATi, much longer. They were the first to do T&L, which pretty much is the basis of all modern GPU's. If I remember correctly nV had 4 generations of graphics cards released before ATi had there first graphics card.

nForce 4? thats a chip set , you mean GF 4. ATi did make AFR but man was the Maxx Rage a piece of crap.
 
Shifra said:
ATI is the only one that went Unified Shaders for consoles and then next years release and the only one that went 90nm, and the only ones with an excellent and working acceptable SM2.0 part at launch and the only ones who support SM1.4 while nVidia dismissed it for all Nforce 4 cards. And the ones who created Alternate Frame Renderring that is now back in use today by nVidia and ATI. nVidia has not lead in innovation always; hardly the case.

Unified shaders means what for the PC side of things? Nothing. nVidia is also developing a unified shader architecture but it won't be available on the PC for sometime, just like ATi. Going 90mm means nothing if you can't produce a product with it as is evident with R520's absence. Having an SM 2.0 part was their greatest achievement with the 9700 (R300) core, after that they haven't innovated at all. It was nVidia that pushed SLI to the masses and have now made it mainstream (deal with Dell) while ATi clobbed together a Crossfire solution after dismissing the need for it initially. You're giving ATi way more credit than they deserve.

P.S. There is no such thing as an nforce 4 video card.
 
ATI did not even inovate the 9700 they bought the R300 core from a company called Artx and they have stretched it like a fat chick in a size 3 bikini ever since.

This may just be there first real chip that they did no their own.
 
{NG}Fidel said:
Lol if any ATi fan n b o y were to say something along these lines they would be bashed like five times over. I always find it funny how bad ATI Fan boys are treated (not defending them) yet Nvidia Fan boys can come out screaming that yeah Nvidia has never let them down (Cough Cough FX line...) so they are quite biased towards them and all us logical people have to sit here and say ok ok fine. I always hated that meh let idiots be idiots.

Neubspeed Im not just dissing you your post had some good info in it but stuff like.


Also while the X800GT may be late lets face it its a great product. At that price/Performance range SM3.0 isnt needed and at that price I may buy it for my next Shuttle PC.

Also what does it matter if ATI ramps core speeds? the X800 gen had similar power reqs as the 6800 series a smaller board and was just as fast or faster in certain games.

Thats all for me!

Also good points, maybe the #1 thing was a bit presumptuous. We all know for some reason INTEL has the most market share in discreet graphics lmao. Goddamn Dells

And to be honest I wanted to try ATi so I sold my 6800 Ultra and bought an X850 XT. They both ran the same coolness but the X850 XT brought my 12v rail to its knees. I just put the 7800 GTX in and everything is that much more cooler and stable. I'm loyal to Nvidia when performance difference is negligable because I love the drivers. The ability to boot Gentoo and play UT2004 without a lot of screwing around deserves accolades. Also wtf is with needing .NET framework to install bloatware lol.
 
PRIME1 said:
ATI did not even inovate the 9700 they bought the R300 core from a company called Artx and they have stretched it like a fat chick in a size 3 bikini ever since.

This may just be there first real chip that they did no their own.



incorrect go do research for a change. facts from others dont get through the jelly in your head, that also counts as flamebate in my book since you did that for no other reason then to insight argument.


razor1 said:
They haven't been innovating enough in the past 3 years. It can't come in bursts, otherwise someone else will come out on top.

Where is the 90 nm thing come in nV is also doing 90 nm for the RSX, come on thats not even innovation, just a fab choice doesn't really have much to do with innvoation unless they are making the fab too. If thats the case the nv30 would be the most radical and innovative chip when it came out not just a bloated dx8 chip. nV has been doing 3d chips longer then ATi, much longer. They were the first to do T&L, which pretty much is the basis of all modern GPU's. If I remember correctly nV had 4 generations of graphics cards released before ATi had there first graphics card.

nForce 4? thats a chip set , you mean GF 4. ATi did make AFR but man was the Maxx Rage a piece of crap.


90nm is being pioneered by them razor, no other form of fabrication previously known can be carried over and used. TSMC may be whos doing it but its ATI dollars thats creating the first VPU 90nm parts known. And you know just as well as i do that the result of this will be the allowance of higher clocks and once leakage is solved over time, a cooler running chip as well as using less power then anything out, thats the plan anyway. I see these things as innovation, steps ATI took. Dont even bring up that RSX, its absolutly meaningless at this time. The PS3 design isnt even finalized and theres no exact release date, just mid 2006.
 
Shifra said:
Dont even bring up that RSX, its absolutly meaningless at this time. The PS3 design isnt even finalized and theres no exact release date, just mid 2006.

And the exact release date for the R520 is????

I stand by my claim that ATI has never done a real competitive 3D chip on their own. If you have proof otherwise post it. The 9700 was their first real competitive card and it was based off of the Artx design that they bought. The same design that's still being used in the x8xx cards.
 
ArtX was a company formed in 1997 by a group of engineers from Silicon Graphics, Inc. that worked on the Nintendo 64's graphics chip. Focused on delivering a PC graphics chip that was both high performance and cost effective, they hoped to be able to instantly compete with the giants in the industry at that time, 3DFX and nVidia. David Orton, who was head of Silicon Graphics' advanced-graphics division, was appointed President of ArtX. He has now become CEO of ATi Technologies. They demonstrated their first integrated graphics chipset with built-in geometry engine at COMDEX in the fall of 1999, which was marketed by Acer Lab of Taiwan. ArtX was contracted to create the graphics processor (called the "Flipper chip") for Nintendo's next generation game console, the GameCube.

The company was acquired by ATi Technologies, Inc. in February 2000 for $400 million dollars in stock options. ArtX paved the way for the development of the R300 graphics chipset from ATi. Today, ATi closely rivals the nVidia Corporation in an intense race for the fastest, and most advanced graphics processor.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ArtX
 
PRIME1 said:
And the exact release date for the R520 is????

I stand by my claim that ATI has never done a real competitive 3D chip on their own. If you have proof otherwise post it. The 9700 was their first real competitive card and it was based off of the Artx design that they bought. The same design that's still being used in the x8xx cards.

We know what your claim is but what is the point? They bought the company, it has became ATI. You act as if they just bought a single design. ATI bought Artx shortly after 3d first started becoming a lucrative market and their were enough games to warrant demand for expensive and specialized cards. Could they have developed one in house just as good? Yes. Would it have cost more than $400 million that Artx cost? Probably. Welcome to the world of corporate America.
 
Im excited to see whats to come from ATI. I dont mind waiting, as long as its worth it. If the previews for their mobos are representative of the retail item ill be super happy. DFI OC style boards, without being DFI!!!! If the R520 is the same speed as the 7800GTX, thats fine with me too. Im just ready for a change.
 
Labrador said:
what are you talking about they lose >? nVidia finally took over ATI with their 7800GTX, while ATI's X850 was top dog up till now. Then the R520 will come out soon and nVidia will be 2nd place again. So no, the 7800GTX lose in a couple of weeks :)

Good god Labrador, looking at your sig, what do you do for work? Wait no, don't tell me, you'd probably have to kill me too. :eek:
 
5150Joker said:
The high end enthusiast boat has sailed, ATi missed it by 3 months.

If R520 supports FPb HDR with FSAA (rumours say it might), then all those guys jump overboard instantly. :D
 
Apple740 said:
If R520 supports FPb HDR with FSAA (rumours say it might), then all those guys jump overboard instantly. :D

Yeah right and even if by some chance it did, nobody would bother since the performance would be so horrible. At this point all the R520 has going for it is rumors -- it might also come with a portable fusion reactor thus solving the worlds energy problems.
 
5150Joker said:
Yeah right and even if by some chance it did, nobody would bother since the performance would be so horrible.

You know that's not true, look at the 6800's with FP16 HDR, people still use it despite the performance loss
 
tornadotsunamilife said:
You know that's not true, look at the 6800's with FP16 HDR, people still use it despite the performance loss

HDR + FSAA = guaranteed major performance hit. It will be good for screenshots if they even manage to pull it off but that's about it. But like I said, seeing how nothing but rumors surround the R520, the chances of it including a portable fusion reactor are just as high.
 
Shifra said:
90nm is being pioneered by them razor, no other form of fabrication previously known can be carried over and used. TSMC may be whos doing it but its ATI dollars thats creating the first VPU 90nm parts known. And you know just as well as i do that the result of this will be the allowance of higher clocks and once leakage is solved over time, a cooler running chip as well as using less power then anything out, thats the plan anyway. I see these things as innovation, steps ATI took. Dont even bring up that RSX, its absolutly meaningless at this time. The PS3 design isnt even finalized and theres no exact release date, just mid 2006.

Are you sure the RSX isn't ready, there has been PS3 dev kit already if you didn't know.

The PS3's design isn't finalized? Where did you get that? we already know whats in the thing from top to bottom.

http://www.ps3land.com/news/article105.php

The first PS3 hardware was sent out 2 months before E3.


Sony also unveiled the PS3's graphics chip, the RSX "Reality Synthesizer based on Nvidia technology. The GPU will be capable of 128bit pixel precision, 1080p resolution, some of the highest HD resolution around. The RSX also has 512mb of graphics render memory and is capable of 100 billion shader operations and 51 billion dot products per second. It also has over 300 million transistors, larger than any processor available commercially today. It will be manufactured using the 90nm process with 8 layers of metal. The RSX is more powerful than two GeForce 6800 Ultra video cards, which would cost roughly $1000 total if bought today.

To show off the PlayStation 3's graphical brawn, Sony showed several game demos, including an Unreal 3 tech demo of what appeared to be Unreal Tournament 2007. In what must come as a relief to developers, Epic Games' Tim Sweeney was on hand to vouch for the PS3, saying it was "easy to program for" and that Epic had received its first PS3 hardware two months ago. He proved the tech demo was real time by showing it again and manipulating the camera and zooming in.

According to this ATi and nV have migrated at the same time to .09
 
I think he is suggesting that like the xbox360, the ps3 isn't running at it's full potential (in terms of hardware speed) but I may be wrong ?
 
tornadotsunamilife said:
I think he is suggesting that like the xbox360, the ps3 isn't running at it's full potential (in terms of hardware speed) but I may be wrong ?


The PS3 is done, the SDK isn't fully complete from what I understand, but the hardware is ready to go, also the xbox360 SDK's with the xenox chip came out at the same time too.
 
Yiffy said:
Good god Labrador, looking at your sig, what do you do for work? Wait no, don't tell me, you'd probably have to kill me too. :eek:


my sig is nice thank you. But it is not top of the line ? It is just parts I have had for awhile and put them togther in the other rig
 
5150Joker said:
HDR + FSAA = guaranteed major performance hit. It will be good for screenshots if they even manage to pull it off but that's about it. But like I said, seeing how nothing but rumors surround the R520, the chances of it including a portable fusion reactor are just as high.


True theoretically there would be a 50-75% performance penelty for using FSAA with HDR at fp 16, closer to 75%. If AA is turned on in rthdribl demo its pretty much unplayable on the last line of cards. There will be the same performance hit on FP 16, OpenEXR HDR
 
tornadotsunamilife said:
So they're running at 100% now? Cool.

Yep pretty much, Actually most likely the documentation isn't full ready, I'm not sure exactly but the hardware is ready to go. Xbox 360 is coming out sooner because they sent out dev kits last year with 9800's, so games are going to ready for xbox launch earilier.
 
Yeah right and even if by some chance it did, nobody would bother since the performance would be so horrible

If they manage Farcry @ 1280x1024, HDR, 2xAA/4xAF with no or hardly any dips below 20/25 then Ati has a knocker. Ofcourse 4xAA/8xAF would be nice but even a playable 2xAA will be a major selling point for Ati, I'm sure of that. And btw, what is a R520 Crossfired rig capable of? 4xAA with good framerates? This will make 7800 obsolete already.

So wait, will Ati introduce the power of 4? sm3.0 & Crossfire & HDR & HDR with FSAA :D
 
Apple740 said:
If they manage Farcry @ 1280x1024, HDR, 2xAA/4xAF with no or hardly any dips below 20/25 then Ati has a knocker. Ofcourse 4xAA/8xAF would be nice but even a playable 2xAA will be a major selling point for Ati, I'm sure of that. And btw, what is a R520 Crossfired rig capable of? 4xAA with good framerates? This will make 7800 obsolete already.

So wait, will Ati introduce the power of 4? sm3.0 & Crossfire & HDR & HDR with FSAA :D

LOL it's a nice prospect but unlikely :D
 
Why do people go on and on about this shit? :confused:

buy what you want and use it. When something comes out that's better, and you can afford it, buy it.
 
Apple740 said:
If they manage Farcry @ 1280x1024, HDR, 2xAA/4xAF with no or hardly any dips below 20/25 then Ati has a knocker. Ofcourse 4xAA/8xAF would be nice but even a playable 2xAA will be a major selling point for Ati, I'm sure of that. And btw, what is a R520 Crossfired rig capable of?

So wait, will Ati introduce the power of 4? sm3.0 & Crossfire & HDR & HDR with FSAA :D


Even at x2 aa there is huge penelty hit, the g70 gets 50-80 fps depending on resolution. Take that and cut it down by lets say 60%, its unplayable. I say 60% since Far Cry will have quite a bit more performance hit because its a game situation, then the rthdribl demo, the rthdribl demo at 800x600 going from no AA to x2 there is it goes from 60 to 45, thats a 25% drop, then going to x 4 it goes to around 30 fps, At 800x600 there really is a need for x 4 AA, as resolution goes up HDR hits performance more, So unless ATi implements a fp10 format in the r520 there is a very good change AA with HDR fp 16 isn't likely. The memory usage will also be enormous if AA is done in hardware for HDR, DK nvidia's chief engineer has already stated this. Benching on a 6800 go ultra btw.
 
32 pipe, supports HDR and AA simultaneously , 70% more efficient shaders ala unified archecture,.09 fab


So says my crystal ball
 
jacuzz1 said:
32 pipe, supports HDR and AA simultaneously , 70% more efficient shaders ala unified archecture,.09 fab


So says my crystal ball

Again that would be sweet but I'm doubtful. Although one question that does spring to mind is: 'Why wasnt the 7800GTX etc. not on a 90nm process if nvidia developed the RSX on a 90nm process?'
 
Back
Top