R520: Is ATI in trouble?

Status
Not open for further replies.

CrimandEvil

Dick with a heart of gold
Joined
Oct 22, 2003
Messages
19,670
http://www.penstarsys.com/editor/company/ati/r520/index.html

It has been widely commented on that TSMC’s 90 nm Low-K process is actually quite robust, and the yields and bins are better than expected with such a new and complex process. So if ATI’s R520 taped out so long ago, and TSMC’s process is running at a higher efficiency than expected for this time frame, where are the R520 parts? The information I have received paints a rather grim picture for ATI. Add to that the recent information released by ATI about the lower than expected revenues due to product pressure and poor yields and packaging problems, things are not as happy as they should be.

The information on the R520 suggests that there are some extreme yield problems with the current design. Not only are there few working dice per wafer, but a large number of those dice only have 16 pixel units working, and others are lucky to get 24 working. The information I received suggested that the R520 was in fact designed with 32 pixel units (each with multiple ALU’s), but due to the issues that the chip is facing, very few of them so far are fully functioning. There are of course fully functioning parts that have been shown behind closed doors, and apparently Abit showed off a working card at AConn that scored some impressive 3D Marks.
So I was alittle worried when I didn't see anything about R520 at Computex last week (although XFX had SLIed G70s). What do you guys think?

Oh, leave the fan-boy crap outside.
 
http://www.forbes.com/markets/2005/06/07/0607automarketscan10.html?partner=yahootix&referrer=

Here's a different article from a financial site which suggests the same thing:

Goldman Sachs said:
First, we remain concerned with the delay of ATI's next generation high-end graphics processor, code-named R520, which appears to be now due out in August, flatly missing the 'spring refresh' window. Given the tape-out took place as far back as October, and Taiwan Semiconductor's yields on 90nm have been generally good on other products including the Xbox 360 graphics chip, we believe the delay is due to a design issue.
 
Ati will live on!!

intro.jpg
 
I'm confused...if the process is doing well...what kind of flaws are resulting in bad chips?

Like, what changed between last generation and this generation that is causing such an issue?
 
^eMpTy^ said:
I'm confused...if the process is doing well...what kind of flaws are resulting in bad chips?

Like, what changed between last generation and this generation that is causing such an issue?

Well, first of all last year 130nm was being done well and ATI had to redesign their X800XTPE in the form of X850 in order to get a decent yielding 16-pipe chip while Nvidia was cranking out 16-pipe 6800GT cards with ease...

Second of all, ATI has a lot to tackle. They need to increase pipelines, increase shader precision to FP32, add FP16 HDR with blending, upgrade shaders to 3.0 capable, master 90nm, all in one generation in order to compete with Nvidia.
 
Not to mention this is suppose to be a new core rather then tweaking the R300.
 
tranCendenZ said:
Well, first of all last year 130nm was being done well and ATI had to redesign their X800XTPE in the form of X850 in order to get a decent yielding 16-pipe chip while Nvidia was cranking out 16-pipe 6800GT cards with ease...

Second of all, ATI has a lot to tackle. They need to increase pipelines, increase shader precision to FP32, add FP16 HDR with blending, upgrade shaders to 3.0 capable, master 90nm, all in one generation in order to compete with Nvidia.

yeah, no shit....:p you can drop the !!!!!! drivel with me tranC, you're preaching to the choir...

the question is...with a good process...how are they getting flawed chips? how can you design a chip poorly to the point that an otherwise good process doesn't work for you?
 
^eMpTy^ said:
yeah, no shit....:p you can drop the !!!!!! drivel with me tranC, you're preaching to the choir...

the question is...with a good process...how are they getting flawed chips? how can you design a chip poorly to the point that an otherwise good process doesn't work for you?

Like I said, the same thing happened last gen with X800XTPE. Even after RAM was abundant, they couldnt provide a decent supply of cores until they redesigned the chip with X850. Plus, its not drivel, there is A LOT of technology ATI has to catch up on all at once with this design in addition to making it much faster than their last generation.

I guess it boils down to the virtual simulation of their design worked well, but in the real world it doesn't work so well.
 
Maybe they started producing the chips a while ago and just been stocking up millions of them, so when they do announce it, Millions will be ready and available that day. No more paper launch horror.


Ever think of that?
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
Maybe they started producing the chips a while ago and just been stocking up millions of them, so when they do announce it, Millions will be ready and available that day. No more paper launch horror.


Ever think of that?

ATI wouldn't let their stocks and financials go down the drain if that were the case. They'd counter Nvidia's G70 launch, but they aren't.

ATI's $550 16 pipeline X850XTPE Crossfire edition is currently their only answer to Nvidia's 24 pipeline 7800GTX w/ SLI, and I don't see it being able to compete in performance or featureset.
 
tranCendenZ said:
ATI wouldn't let their stocks and financials go down the drain if that were the case. They'd counter Nvidia's G70 launch, but they aren't.
well, we haven't really seen proof one way or another, have we?
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
Maybe they started producing the chips a while ago and just been stocking up millions of them, so when they do announce it, Millions will be ready and available that day. No more paper launch horror.


Ever think of that?
That doesn't explain why they wouldn't be showing it off at Comptex, they could of atleast had some for the CrossFire anouncement.
 
If this IS a new core, they may be having technical difficulties. Even after taping out, some minor bugs can cause huge delays.

Who knows they may have actually started making chips and then had to scrap em because of some bug that popped up. I remember Intel scrapping a bunch of chips a while back because of some bug in the chips.

My other theory :p is that they may have placed to much of their resources into getting the Xbox up and running to beat Nintendo and Sony.
 
USMC2Hard4U said:
Maybe they started producing the chips a while ago and just been stocking up millions of them, so when they do announce it, Millions will be ready and available that day. No more paper launch horror.


Ever think of that?

Well if that was the case we would certainly have heard some whisper of it by now. It's not like you can stockpile millions of chips and have nobody know about it. Also, if that were the case where are the rumours of yield issues coming from? It makes no sense to have an arsenal of cards in hiding while your stock price plummets and confidence in your ability to produce is falling.
 
Ahh poor ATi if this is true they will have another great product that is more than likely to be faster than the competition fail.....
Oh please let the R520 and G70 compete fairly so prices drop!
 
Both those articles about the R520 yields would make sense but are still pure speculation. Maybe ATI really is ramping up production secretly, both these companies play cat and mouse games, trying to out maneuver the other. However, if the R520 still is undergoing design changes, and I'm CEO Orton, heads should roll.
 
trinibwoy said:
Well if that was the case we would certainly have heard some whisper of it by now. It's not like you can stockpile millions of chips and have nobody know about it.

Yeah, I bet the INQ has a payed snitch in every factory :p
 
Personally I think they may be concentrating on the XBox 360 chips ramping up for production there. I don't think they are nearly as concerned with nVidia. XBox 360 will probably net them more money over the long haul.
 
This sucks... I really hope it's just speculation. I really want to see what the R520 is all about before I jump on another card. I would have rather gone ATI this round simply because their single cards are faster and I'm not made of money... but again, it was Nvidia's availability for the PCI express platform that got me over, and it looks like that could be the case for many others next generation.

I think they may be in trouble and I really hope they can get their way out of it.
 
CrimandEvil said:
That doesn't explain why they wouldn't be showing it off at Comptex, they could of atleast had some for the CrossFire anouncement.
Yes because there were tons of 7800's on display from Nvidia at the show........ :confused:

Give it a rest guys, the last thing Nvidia f@nboys want is a 32 pipe 90m R520 to go against a 24 pipe 110m 7800.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
Personally I think they may be concentrating on the XBox 360 chips ramping up for production there. I don't think they are nearly as concerned with nVidia. XBox 360 will probably net them more money over the long haul.

I'm not sure but based on the musings by other people in the know, the income from these console deals pales in comparison to the core GPU business so it would be silly of them to ignore R520 and focus on Xbox360.
 
tranCendenZ said:
Like I said, the same thing happened last gen with X800XTPE. Even after RAM was abundant, they couldnt provide a decent supply of cores until they redesigned the chip with X850. Plus, its not drivel, there is A LOT of technology ATI has to catch up on all at once with this design in addition to making it much faster than their last generation.

I guess it boils down to the virtual simulation of their design worked well, but in the real world it doesn't work so well.

I'm well aware of the technologies they have to make up for. That's what I'm saying, you know I know that, so why are you rehashing it? But no matter...I'm just trying to understand how you can design a chip messed up to the point that it gets bad yields...like I always associated yield problems with the process, not with the design of the core...do you see what I mean?
 
R1ckCa1n said:
Yes because there were tons of 7800's on display from Nvidia at the show........ :confused:

Give it a rest guys, the last thing Nvidia f@nboys want is a 32 pipe 90m R520 to go against a 24 pipe 110m 7800.

There were at least a few of the being shown behind closed doors. Which is better than can be said for R520...

When every rumor from every source seems to echo the same two facts: G70 is coming soon, R520 is coming later...then I start to think that's what's actually going on...at this point...how can so many rumors from so many different sources be completely false?

Bottom line, if ATi is publicly announcing financial statements saying their fourth quarter isn't going to be what they expected, they're having issues. Now whether this amounts to a disatrous R520 launch, or just a couple months of delays is a completely different story.

Either way, it looks like ATi will once again be launching a chip that is doomed to bad yields and disabled pipelines...just cross your fingers and hope availability isn't as bad as the x800xtpe was...
 
And according to this, a possible design flaw: http://www.forbes.com/markets/2005/06/07/0607automarketscan10.html?partner=yahootix&referrer=

Remember, it's not nice to lie to teh SEC (Securities Exchange Commision), so Goldman & Sachs are most likely spot on.

Doesn't sound good. Another delayed product that allows the competition to get a leading run even if it's an inferior product. Like it or not, the 6800 series dominated due to it's earlier and prolific release.
 
^eMpTy^ said:
There were at least a few of the being shown behind closed doors. Which is better than can be said for R520...
Did you see one? I sure didn't........ Funny not one major internet website posted anything about either products this year.
 
R1ckCa1n said:
Did you see one? I sure didn't........ Funny not one major internet website posted anything about either products this year.

"Major" internet websites don't post on unreleased products. Pre-release debate is usually relegated to forum banter and "minor" websites. I don't know why you're fighting this so passionately - the rumours are even coming out of forbes and Goldman Sachs!! Who are the "major" websites anyway?
 
trinibwoy said:
"Major" internet websites don't post on unreleased products. Pre-release debate is usually relegated to forum banter and "minor" websites. I don't know why you're fighting this so passionately - the rumours are even coming out of forbes and Goldman Sachs!! Who are the "major" websites anyway?
I'm not fighting it but when you have the fab 5 running around this forum spewing crap, it gets old. A warning from Goldman Sachs is much more credible than a link from a no name website, which started this whole thread.
 
R1ckCa1n said:
Did you see one? I sure didn't........ Funny not one major internet website posted anything about either products this year.
And lets not forget this: http://www.bit-tech.net/news/2005/05/31/xfx_g70_running/

We have just learned that XFX have not one, but two NVIDIA G70-based video cards running in a back room on their stand at Computex. We believe that they are demonstrating the fastest implementation of G70 that is currently planned, paired in SLI mode.
:rolleyes:
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
Personally I think they may be concentrating on the XBox 360 chips ramping up for production there. I don't think they are nearly as concerned with nVidia. XBox 360 will probably net them more money over the long haul.


Don't forget, Nintendo's next chip is ATI also. ATI bit off more than it could chew this year with the Xbox 360, Nintendo Revolution Graphics Chip design, New motherboard designs, Crossfire/GPU, and all the while trying to get R520 out the door. Need to drop something. Motherboard just don't seem scream ATI to me. Either does Nintendo. Dropping one or both of these could get their resources consolidated better leading to better products and better returns on their stock. ;) Even with ATI West(R500/Xbox 360) in the fold, it seems they are just a little thin to be trying to push too much too soon. Just my observation from a business stand point.
 
Yeah ATI does seem to juggling a bit too many eggs right now but I thought R520 was suppose to have been tapped out several months ago. If so should we have seen something by now? I would have thought they'd have wanted to do something like a "sneak peak" of R520 when they previewed CrossFire but I guess not.
 
I would definately upgrade to ATI if they did release a 32-pipeline card. I usually don't upgrade till the hardware is 2X the speed from my old hardware. At this rate I would see a 64-pipline card with XDR RAM videocards with 1GB of RAM in 2006.
 
ohgod said:
You have a link or pics for the SLIed G70's?


http://www.anandtech.com/tradeshows/showdoc.aspx?i=2431&p=2

Boards are on display at the show, behind closed doors of course. Of course, in Taiwan nothing is ever secret - and thus we’ve had the ability to play around with a number of G70 cards at the show. We can’t say much about the G70 as we are bound by NDA, but all of the cards at the show are single-slot solutions which is refreshing.

It's against the NDA to have pics for it, but it does exist ;)
 
This kind of news is always happening in the industry, and kind of goes to show that it is not always so "great" to wait. I am sure glad I decided to splurge on my two ultras awhile back. ATI will get their act together, but I wouldn't hold my breath on new product launches just yet.
 
^eMpTy^ said:
There were at least a few of the being shown behind closed doors. Which is better than can be said for R520...

When every rumor from every source seems to echo the same two facts: G70 is coming soon, R520 is coming later...then I start to think that's what's actually going on...at this point...how can so many rumors from so many different sources be completely false?

Bottom line, if ATi is publicly announcing financial statements saying their fourth quarter isn't going to be what they expected, they're having issues. Now whether this amounts to a disatrous R520 launch, or just a couple months of delays is a completely different story.

Either way, it looks like ATi will once again be launching a chip that is doomed to bad yields and disabled pipelines...just cross your fingers and hope availability isn't as bad as the x800xtpe was...

Fanb0i at it again? There were not a few, there were TWO, both from one company. That shocked quite a few people at how scarce they were.

The R520 was there running the new decoding to be used by Blue-ray and it was at E3 running the real time demos of Alen Wake and one other game i cannot recall. Please remove your head from Nvidia's ass. ATI and Nvidia have been equally secretive on using new products at these shows.

Lets face it empty, you know shit, so your end comments, laughable. You take any negative comment about ATI, fact or fiction, and you proclaim Nvidia has won a race THAT HASNT EVEN STARTED.

TSMC already leaked reports of mass chip orders from both ATI and Nvidia.

http://www.xbitlabs.com/news/video/display/20050530100343.html
 
. Please remove your head from Nvidia's ass. ATI and Nvidia have been equally secretive on using new products at these shows.

Hey everyone makes mistakes. Empty could have just forgoten, I agree you should have corrected him but calm down. You dont have to be an ass about it.
 
Maybe they're trying to fix a chip feature they'll be promoting that doesn't work at the time, before they let their consumers find the fault on their own.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top