Questions regarding owning a 45nm cpu

CoolZone

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 14, 2004
Messages
101
Hello to all,

I am saving for 3 years for a better setup on my computer.I currently have a P4 2.4C and a 865PE mobo.
I am waiting to jump over the Yorkfields when they appear,and more explicitly,the Q9550,with a X48/X38 board.
I found out that because of the low multiplier,the Q9550 will reach 4GHZ very hard,and not even the Q9550 ES clock very well.
The BIG questions are:
1)It is safe to buy a QX9650 from ebay,or should I stick to the retail stores and buy a normal Q9550?I saw a QX9650 at bidded 700$ a day ago,but now it is over 800$.
2)Do you think that the price of the extreme edition QX9650 will go down after the regular 45nm quads appear on the market?
3)Is it better to buy a new in box QX6850 from ebay,or a Q9550?Which yelds a better performance?
 
always buy from a bigish retailer. Never buy the top of the line, you want the best for the price not the best at a price.
 
You say I should not upgrade top of the line,even if I do full upgrades like this at 5 or more years?
 
I would not think that the extreme edition would be worth the price premium. You're looking at something like $500 for what would probably be less than 500 Mhz of clock speed difference - just doesn't seem cost effective. It probably isn't even worth the price difference between the 9450 and the 9550 - with a 400 FSB (should be easy) the difference in clock speed is 3.2 to 3.4, for a whopping $200 price increase.
 
I would not think that the extreme edition would be worth the price premium. You're looking at something like $500 for what would probably be less than 500 Mhz of clock speed difference - just doesn't seem cost effective. It probably isn't even worth the price difference between the 9450 and the 9550 - with a 400 FSB (should be easy) the difference in clock speed is 3.2 to 3.4, for a whopping $200 price increase.
You are wrong, it is a bit difference now and for the future with low multiplers and that make the extreme worth the money.
Don´t expect anything more than max 3.6GHz out of Q9550 at best since FSB Max won´t be any higher than Kentfield has but some golden ones will do highre but they are rare and not just anyone fall over.
QX9650 do easy 4GHz and 4.2-4.5GHz+ at max and still on low FSB but on high multi so you will se a difference of up to 1Ghz+ and at minimum 400MHz and even more with some tuning and tweak since you are not limited with extreme and desktop quad dont like high FSB so there is no way to catch up and i belive that Intel has done its homework and binned the desktop so they can´t touch even a bad example of the extremequad that dont do more than the "normal" 4GHz witch seems to be the level all extreme so far do one way or another with no problem.
Dont expect the QX9650 to fall mutch in price until we see Nehalem late 2008 or as i suspect early or mid 2009 if nor AMD get their act togheter and get a good product out that can touch Intel more than just a small shake like Phenom. It needs more like a earthquake from AMD to see nehalem out in time .
 
You are wrong, it is a bit difference now and for the future with low multiplers and that make the extreme worth the money.
Don´t expect anything more than max 3.6GHz out of Q9550 at best since FSB Max won´t be any higher than Kentfield has but some golden ones will do highre but they are rare and not just anyone fall over.
QX9650 do easy 4GHz and 4.2-4.5GHz+ at max and still on low FSB but on high multi so you will se a difference of up to 1Ghz+ and at minimum 400MHz and even more with some tuning and tweak since you are not limited with extreme and desktop quad dont like high FSB so there is no way to catch up and i belive that Intel has done its homework and binned the desktop so they can´t touch even a bad example of the extremequad that dont do more than the "normal" 4GHz witch seems to be the level all extreme so far do one way or another with no problem.
Dont expect the QX9650 to fall mutch in price until we see Nehalem late 2008 or as i suspect early or mid 2009 if nor AMD get their act togheter and get a good product out that can touch Intel more than just a small shake like Phenom. It needs more like a earthquake from AMD to see nehalem out in time .

Well, if you want to spend $600 or $700 extra to get an extreme that can do 4 or 4.2 against a Q9450 that can do 3.6, then more power to you. My point is that it is a big price jump for what is, in reality, a small jump in performance. 3.6 to 4.0 is 11%, and you are basically tripling the price to get that 11%. Even if your Q9450 can only do 3.2 (400 x 8) and the extreme can do 4.2 - it's a 33% increase for again, a 300% price increase. For me, not worth it at all, but your situation may vary. Given that not a lot of software even takes full advantage of a quad at 3.2, not sure how much benefit there is in one running at 4.2 - if you want high clockspeeds just get an E8500 and run it at 4 Ghz instead.

I would recommend getting a Q9450 or Q9550 and putting the extra money towards beefing up the rest of the system, better video card, better monitor, more RAM, bigger hard drive, etc - you'd probably see more benefit for that than from the extra speed of an extreme.
 
Well, if you want to spend $600 or $700 extra to get an extreme that can do 4 or 4.2 against a Q9450 that can do 3.6, then more power to you. My point is that it is a big price jump for what is, in reality, a small jump in performance. 3.6 to 4.0 is 11%, and you are basically tripling the price to get that 11%. Even if your Q9450 can only do 3.2 (400 x 8) and the extreme can do 4.2 - it's a 33% increase for again, a 300% price increase. For me, not worth it at all, but your situation may vary. Given that not a lot of software even takes full advantage of a quad at 3.2, not sure how much benefit there is in one running at 4.2 - if you want high clockspeeds just get an E8500 and run it at 4 Ghz instead.

I would recommend getting a Q9450 or Q9550 and putting the extra money towards beefing up the rest of the system, better video card, better monitor, more RAM, bigger hard drive, etc - you'd probably see more benefit for that than from the extra speed of an extreme.

Exactly, and hell with the extra money you saved you can save it and buy the next gen processor to replace your old one, as it will be faster, use less power, and be smaller (most likely).
 
Exactly, and hell with the extra money you saved you can save it and buy the next gen processor to replace your old one, as it will be faster, use less power, and be smaller (most likely).
As of now, i gonna skip Nehalem. DDR3 price for nice and fast enought 4GB is stupid high,like 800-900$ so it is now way worth it just to get a small benefit over what i already have.
I partly spend them now on a extremequad and as part of one or two new GFX when the real NV G100 is out. That gives me more now rather than spending that kind of money on just memory. I dont expect DDR3 to fall in price until the first suckers is fooled to buy them and that is when nehalem is out. I just jump on DDR3 when price is down to DDR2 level and save like 500-600$ that way and that gives me one GFX just by waiting for the first loosers to get fooled pricevice.
 
Back
Top