Question about viewable size in CRT vs LCD

simon741

Gawd
Joined
Apr 28, 2007
Messages
642
Im thinking about picking up an lcd in one of these black friday sale extravaganzas and I was wondering if a 19" LCD monitor would be an improvement over my 17" CRT. Ive read numerous times that CRT's sizes are specced from one corner of the case to the other, not the viewable area. However, when I measure my Dell 1028l (which is rated as a 17" monitor) the viewable area is 17" while from case to case is about 20.5". WTF is up with this? Which one is it? Are LCDS rated from case to case or viewable area. Im really stumped on this. One more thing. Are there any places that show something like a 17" CRT right next to a 17"LCD or just monitors side by side. I dont know if a 19" WS would be an improvement over my 17". Thanks
 
some of the 26'' LCDs are only 26'' for marketing and actually 25.5''. Other than that exception all LCDs are measured by the actual viewable diagonal.
CRTs are measured by the diagonal of the image plane of the tube that can be hidden behind the monitor frame or almost completely exposed as on your monitor.
So a photo of a 17'' CRT won't help you much. It's also possible that your CRT is actually 18'' and dell chose to call it 17'' because ppl are now used to an accurate measurement.

It should also be noted that your monitor is probably 4:3 format whereas a 17 or 19'' LCD will be 5:4 or 16:10 wide screen depending on the model which will have an impact on the actual size of the screen surface, a 19'' WS will be wider but a little less high than your model if it's a full 17'' 4:3 viewable.
If you measured your display simply use it's size on http://www.tvcalculator.com/ and try out different LCD diagonals to compare.
 
Back
Top