Question about Motherboard for File Server

Hudson187

n00b
Joined
Dec 1, 2009
Messages
36
Knowledgeable Folks on Hardforum,

I currently am running a WHS home-brew system in a Norco 4020 case with a 2.2ghz Core-2-Duo and a Foxconn motherboard with one PCI-E x16 that has a Supermicro AOC-saslp-mv8. I'd like to use another system I have as a file server which is a bit older K8N Neo4/SLI 939 motherboard running a 2.4 AMD Opteron so I can have two PCI-E x16 for 2 AOC-saslp-mv8. Problem is, I've done a little bit of research and apparently the motherboard will only be x16 if video cards are in SLI mode - can anyone verify if this is correct?

The specs from newegg are:

PCI Express x16 = 2
PCI Slots = 3

The manual says:
Two PCI Express x16 slots (supports PCI Express Bus specification v1.0a
compliant).
†2nd PCI Express x16 slot (PCI_E3) is compatible with PCI Express x 1

If I cannot use two AOC-saslp-mv8 cards, do you think two of these Syba PCI 4x SATA 3.0gb/s cards will be fine in addition to one AOC-saslp-mv8v?
 
Correct me if i'm wrong but the AOC-SASLP-MV8 is PCIE 4x so if you put those into a 16x slot they will only run at 4x anyways. Should be fine.
 
Correct me if i'm wrong but the AOC-SASLP-MV8 is PCIE 4x so if you put those into a 16x slot they will only run at 4x anyways. Should be fine.

I understand what you are saying, but I'm concerned about what the manual says:

† 2nd PCI Express x16 slot (PCI_E3) is compatible with PCI Express x 1
 
You can put two AOC-SASLP-MV8 in there. One will run at x4. The other will run at x1.

People have been cutting away PCI Express x1 slots and have gotten their AOC-SASLP-MV8 to work in it. The difference for you is you don't need to damage your board.

You could just test it by putting your card in the 2nd slot and leaving the first one empty.
 
You can put two AOC-SASLP-MV8 in there. One will run at x4. The other will run at x1.

People have been cutting away PCI Express x1 slots and have gotten their AOC-SASLP-MV8 to work in it. The difference for you is you don't need to damage your board.

You could just test it by putting your card in the 2nd slot and leaving the first one empty.

Is there any disadvantage to running in x1 mode?
 
The controller should work in the second PCIe x16 (x1 electrical) slot. The only downside is that your throughput will be limited to the maximum bandwidth the x1 connection will give you. If high bandwidth/throughput is not a concern for you, then the x1 connection should work just fine for your application.
 
The controller should work in the second PCIe x16 (x1 electrical) slot. The only downside is that your throughput will be limited to the maximum bandwidth the x1 connection will give you. If high bandwidth/throughput is not a concern for you, then the x1 connection should work just fine for your application.

Sounds good. I will be using the file server to host SD & HD video, photos, music, and other files to users in the house and a HTPC. I have a wide range of hard drives currently in the server; most of them are WD Green 1tb - 2tb or Samsung HD154UI.
 
For pure server duties, the SuperMicro X8SIL-F is currently the best choice. It supports IPMI (remote management - view the console in a web browser), ECC RAM, and has 3 x8 slots, one of which is really a x4. It also has 2 onboard Intel Gigabit NICs. The current revision supports a Pentium G6950 which is pretty cheap. Being a server board, there's no odd issues with RAID controllers that can plague consumer/gaming boards. It just works and works well.

I have two of these - there's nothing currently better for the low end.
 
Back
Top