Question about HTPC with speakers

wfarid

Limp Gawd
2FA
Joined
Apr 20, 2006
Messages
370
I'm getting a 46" Samsung 8 series LCD (led backlight) and I wanted to build a home theater system with an HTPC at its center. I want everything to be played from the HTPC from satellite tv, dvds, blu-ray, networked stuff, youtube etc and I want a reasonably simple interface (thinking XP MC). Well, i've been doing research into what speakers to get and I am totally at a loss. Basically what I want is when I switch on my TV and HTPC and play music/dvds/etc I get a nice surround sound (I have a small living room so it shouldn't be that hard). Then if I want to fire up my Xbox 360, I get a nice surround sound as well without pushing to many buttons turning this thing off and that thing on, I want a seamless hassle free switch. Something a grandma could do (thats why Im considering getting a logitech harmony remote).

Any suggestions? Is there any way this could just be done through the HTPC itself with a simple amp just powering the speakers?

I'm thinking the HDMI cable with its 1.3 spec should fit the bill here, but I'm not sure and budget is a big factor. I've heard some awesome things about Onkyo but the cheaper ones only have hdmi pass through, will that make switching between the htpc and other things more difficult?
 
for the audio, i would go with a reciever and speakers. Use the logitech 550 that is like $50-$70 (its a nice remote) and plug all your AV equipment into it.


for an OS I would go with Vista MCE (or VMC) over XP MCE but that is my opinion.

check out monoprice.com for HDMI cables
 
Vista MCE over XP, really? I heard XP MCE was rock stable. I even used it for a while and my experience with it was nothing but positive. Haven't heard to much about Vista MCE, but I've heard nothing good about Vista.
 
hmm, why not have all the audio inputs to your TV and run an optical audio from TV to receiver, that's what I do. Minimal input switching, since if your TV is on, u get surround sound (5.1)
 
Would I still be able to hear full uncompressed sound if I went that route?
 
Would I still be able to hear full uncompressed sound if I went that route?

I love this question, i see it all the time. My counter is always this...What is your budget for speakers? In the price range that most of us live in, the bandwidth differences are inaudible. basically, if you buy just about anything from best buy, circuit city, or frys, you are fine. now if you are looking at high end speakers int he $1000 plus range you may be able to tell. but a speaker set that cost a few hundred bucks isn't capable of accurately reproducing the extra bandwidth anyway.

I have a buddy that insists on using only lossless audio...to play on his $10 earbuds. its pointless.

now, I am not totally pissing on the question, but to give accurate recommendations, we need a budget, especially since you said it was a factor. so, what are you looking to spend?
 
Good point. around $500, I already have two infinity bookshelfs that are really good and I'd just want to get a center, 2 surrounds, base and then a receiver.

The budget for the HTPC is around $1000
 
for that budget I suggest you forgo the exotic sound cards. your money can be better spent elsewhere. there are several threads about building an HTPC for $1000 and there are a lot of ways to do it, so I am not really going to go into much detailother than to say I have an ati3600 and a Nvidia 8600 and really like both of the images. either would be good choices if you have an HDTV. onboard SPDIF is plenty for what you are going to be doing.

speakers...spend the most on the center if you watch movies. I have seen several different stats, but the opinion ranges between 70 and90% of your audio in a movie comes from the center. even if it isonly 60, that a lot. so find a reasonable center that goes well with those infinity bookshelfs. infinity primus is a decent entry series for movie watching. a bit sharp for music, but great for environmental detail and dialog. for now go with some cheap, small surrounds. I got some spare speakers from a logitech 5500 set on ebay for $35 a pair. they do very well in my small living room. for the sub there are a few options around $100 that will do you well.

http://www.partsexpress.com/pe/showdetl.cfm?&Partnumber=300-635

http://www.abesofmaine.com/item.do?item=ATHASP4100&id=ATHASP4100&l=PRICEGRABB

for the receiver, I dont think you can beat anything onkyo for a budget setup. take a look at shoponkyo.com for factory recertifieddeals. the 605 is great if you can spring for it.
 
Vista MCE over XP, really? I heard XP MCE was rock stable. I even used it for a while and my experience with it was nothing but positive. Haven't heard to much about Vista MCE, but I've heard nothing good about Vista.

I can only speak from my own experience, but i have not had any instability issues with vista or VMC. I love the UI; both in look and function. To me MCE looks like early 2000's stuff (which it is) if you like the look and function of the MCE UI than go for it....


I have not had any issues with Vista as an OS. Just turn off the UAC and it will be fine.....


I have really enjoyed vista as an OS... i am much more productive with the new file explorer interface and I love the searchability (if thats a work) in the start bar.....


YMMV
 
XP MCE is not stable at all. VMC kills it in stability, and the interface is simply new and more attractive.
 
XP MCE is not stable at all. VMC kills it in stability, and the interface is simply new and more attractive.

id love to know why you think xp mce is not stable....
xp is a proven op system and is very stable, requires alot less hardware to run properly and has little to no driver issues.

vista is still in its infancy compared to xp, is wrought with driver conflicts and incompatibilities, geting proper sound is still an issue with many people, and it requires more hardware to run properly. (yes you can run it bare but thats like running xp on a system with 512 kb of ram....not a bright idea) microsoft is ever extending xp's support deadline and are already developing another op system to replace vista (which of course they wont release until vista is out long enough to milk the world of more money)
quite honestly other than a little more eye candy i have no idea why so many people are jumping on the vista and/or vista mce bandwagon.
 
I had to migrate to Vista. well I guess I could have used one of the PITA workaround to get MCE to install on my new motherboard, but I didn't feel like it. so I have vista and I have had some stability issues. I do like the new interface and as you get used to it it is more functional.
 
hmm, why not have all the audio inputs to your TV and run an optical audio from TV to receiver, that's what I do. Minimal input switching, since if your TV is on, u get surround sound (5.1)

Would I still be able to hear full uncompressed sound if I went that route?

A lot of TVs will not send 5.1 audio from input sources via the optical audio output. You might get 5.1 from broadcast TV where it can pick up the signal, but any game systems, PC, DVD player, etc that you have connected to the TV this way, even if running that optical output to a receiver, will only get stereo audio, even if you connect with HDMI cables and they're sending a full surround sound signal to the TV.

So no, you wouldn't be getting proper surround sound if you used the TV as the main switch box for audio and just ran the optical output to a receiver.

Since you mentioned a total budget of $1500 for HTPC and receiver/speakers, I would suggest not getting a subwoofer... especially since you've said you have a small living room. I don't think you'd be able to get all of the parts you need and fit it into that budget (building the PC with no spare parts will probably get you to around $800, give or take a little... decent receiver for between $300 and $400, leaving $300 for the 3 speakers).

Use your bookshelf speakers as the surrounds. Get a slightly larger set of floor speakers for the front channels. You'd be surprised at how unnecessary this makes a subwoofer in a small room. I have a pretty big living room and a setup with no subwoofer in it, using some inexpensive Sony speakers (fronts are floor speakers, rears are bookshelf and a center) and I do not feel the need for a subwoofer at all.

If you want some more specific recommendations I'd be willing to try and come up with a whole parts list, otherwise I hope this helps in some way. :)
 
Back
Top