Question about C2D vs AM2 and Gaming.

Both CPU's will do great in gaming.
Conroe will do a little better (at stock, in benchmarks) ;)
Both CPU's will overclock well.
Conroe will overclock much better :eek:
Both CPU's will run cool enough.
Conroe will run cooler... :cool:

At stock, in games, you will not see/feel the difference between the two.
Overclocked (3.3~3.6GHz average), Conrore will have much greater impact on your games, and you'll actually notice it. But then you'll be limited by your GPU (no SLI, Crossfire.. :mad: )
Get a Gigabyte mobo. Or wait for the Nvidia R600 chipset mobos for SLI.

Good luck.
 
mzs_biteme said:
Both CPU's will run cool enough.
Conroe will run cooler... :cool:
my AM2 3800+ X2 running almost 12'c cooler than the e6600 C2D.
AM2 idle temp at stock 35'c
C2D 47'c
 
unless you are going for very low budget, it makes no sense to buy an AMD system

mzs_biteme said:
Or wait for the Nvidia R600 chipset mobos for SLI.

Good luck.

that made me laugh alot
 
brucedeluxe169 said:
unless you are going for very low budget, it makes no sense to buy an AMD system



that made me laugh alot

Ahh, got me there.. Too much forum flipping. Mixed things up. ATI has (most likely HAD) RD600 chipset in the works for INtel, but that was before AMD/ATI merger. Brain fart on me.. ;)
PS - Isn't Nvidia coming out with new Intel chipset. I know I saw it somewhere... It's gonna bug me now.... :rolleyes:
 
RailGunRiz said:
Well I am not much of an overclocker, but its something I would like to do in the future. Would I need a new CPU HS or does the stock one suffice?

And your gigabyte mobo, which one would you recommend? :confused: and what kinda ram would be better matched with it?
Get a zalman 9500 and be set for life with it :p stock is ok and you can do good with it, but the zalman will be much better for overclocking in the long run.

You want the gigabyte DS3, and people seem to love the patroit 667mhz ram with it. i'm sure somebody has a link. for it
 
RailGunRiz said:
Well I am not much of an overclocker, but its something I would like to do in the future. Would I need a new CPU HS or does the stock one suffice?

And your gigabyte mobo, which one would you recommend? :confused: and what kinda ram would be better matched with it?

I'm using Intel stock HS in my setup, but I moded my case so it has a side fan blowing cooler air from outside directly over CPU area. Then I have a power supply with 120mm fan pulling hot air away from the CPU and additional 120mm on top of the case. Most of newer (better quality) cases come with some sort of a vent/fan on the side cover for better ventilation. May wanna look into that. If my case wanst moded, I'd probably not OC as much. Not that I couldn't, but I just don't like to see CPU temp go much above 50deg C under load.
DS3 has been very good for me so far... ;) Make sure you update BIOS as soon as you get it. Gigabyte seems to actually listed to people's complaints and come up with BIOS fixes quite often. I got my DS3 with F4 BIOS. The latest version is F7 (I think).
On RAM, I've been seeing quite a few people use Patriot RAM with great results, and it was priced right for my needs... :D
Look up anandtech.com for more details on Patriot and DS3. They have articles about both of them on the front page.
 
Thermalright FTW.

though they are considered old they still will do well.

Xp or Si 120 and the new SI 128. Put whatever fan you want and can be a push or pull on the fan. Also it isn't heavy and will do pretty much what the others do.
 
jhartono0002 said:
my AM2 3800+ X2 running almost 12'c cooler than the e6600 C2D.
AM2 idle temp at stock 35'c
C2D 47'c

Using the same heatsink with same thermal compound and the same fan, in a case with teh same ambient temperature on the same motherboard and same method of measuring temps ?

Didn't think so
 
You can try your luck with the stock Intel heatsink first, the C2Ds OC so well that lots of people are getting above 3Ghz on stock air, but for the very best, go with one of the ones mentioned above.

Also, why no Asus boards? Asus makes some of the best (if not the best, both feature and quality-wise) boards on the market.

As for memory, I would go with the Patriot, it has proven to be extremely OCable for many people with the C2D chips.

The Gigabyte board mentioned also has gotten some good revies, but be careful with RAM, it has been proven to be very finicky with certain RAM from OCZ, and possible another manufacturer (though I can't remember what that was off the top of my head) something due to voltage issues.
 
Problem is many boards default at 1.8 and some memory needs higher to boot... People just don't know that.
 
I have the DS3 and the Patriot 667 RAM. I am running the ram at 800 and it has passed all stability tests that I've thrown at it. It worked from the start, I didn't have to mess around with voltages or anything like that. I am running my e6300 at 400 x 7. This was by far the easiest build I've ever done. I even got all the lights plugged in properly on the first try:)
 
MC FLMJIG said:
Problem is many boards default at 1.8 and some memory needs higher to boot... People just don't know that.

But unless you have some memory that defaults at 1.8 laying around to boot up and change the BIOS, there is nothing you can do about it.

Plus, it isn't many boards, the Gigabyte DS3 is the only one I have ever heard reports of problems with.
 
Don't go crazy with your CPU upgrade. If you're running at a respectably high resolution, all recent games are GPU bound.

Yes, a Core 2 is better than an AM2, and much better when overclocked, but if you're playing Oblivion at 1600x1200, we're probably talking about 2 FPS difference. The only way you're going to be able to turn all that extra processor power into some real FPS, is by getting a G80 or SLI/Crossfire setup to remove the GPU bottleneck.
 
RailGunRiz said:
Well, because every, and I mean EVERY, Asus board that I've owned (p4C800-Deluxe, A8 deluxe, a8 premium, a8r32mvp ect) have all died within the first week of opening / installing them. I've had a DFI boards/ Epox boards that I could throw down the stairs and still have them boot up/ not give me any problems.

Asus is flat out a shitty motherboard company, and their boards are no different. Their customer service dept is the only place where the operator tells you "we'll call you back" and never get back to you. + RMA's take FOREVER with them, I waited about a month to get my old P4C800 Deluxe back a year ago, worst thing ever. Besides they're too damn expensive even for their "budget boards".

Wow, OK, sorry you have had a bad experience with Asus (actually, it sounds sort of like my experience with nVidia), I have never had to deal with their customer service system as I have never had an Asus board die on me, but to each their own. The DS3 still appears to be a great board as long as you get the right RAM, a lot of the people who are doing great OCs on their C2Ds use it.
 
RailGunRiz said:
lol I didn't mean to come off as yelling at you bout it. Its just that company has literally fucked me on every board they've sent me. I'm the idiot who keeps buying them but, no more.

I just ordered the C2D E6600 / Gigabyte DS3 board (4G of patriot DDR2800 as well) we'll see how things turn out.

Thanks for all your opinions. :D

What you say about Asus is exactly what happened to me with Gigabyte. Yet, I own a DS3. Then add to this I've never bought an Asus board that was bad. The one that sucked the most had a VIA chip set that sucked on every board makers board. I think the first Asus board I owned was P2B, then quickly added P2B-F, 3 P3B-F's, A7M (the one that sucked but worked). P4T-E still my favorite i850, Asus A8N (still using) and so many built for others I can't possibly remember them all. In fact, I just worked on a lady's computer I sold to her 8 or seven years ago Asus P2B-F with a P3 450MHz.
 
Donnie27 said:
What you say about Asus is exactly what happened to me with Gigabyte. Yet, I own a DS3. Then add to this I've never bought an Asus board that was bad. The one that sucked the most had a VIA chip set that sucked on every board makers board. I think the first Asus board I owned was P2B, then quickly added P2B-F, 3 P3B-F's, A7M (the one that sucked but worked). P4T-E still my favorite i850, Asus A8N (still using) and so many built for others I can't possibly remember them all. In fact, I just worked on a lady's computer I sold to her 8 seven years ago Asus P2B-F with a P3 450MHz.

I am still on an Asus P4P+ (i845 chipset), works fine for me, but since S478 is dead, not much of an upgrade path. I am going Apple anyway, the 24" iMac has too good of specs and is too sexy to resist, I can just get some firewire enclosures for my current hard drives to get to my files anyway.

Via made the chipset of the only board that died on me (and took my first K6-2 450 with it). I don't remember who made the board, it was before I became knowledgeable in the tech field.
 
NulloModo said:
I am still on an Asus P4P+ (i845 chipset), works fine for me, but since S478 is dead, not much of an upgrade path. I am going Apple anyway, the 24" iMac has too good of specs and is too sexy to resist, I can just get some firewire enclosures for my current hard drives to get to my files anyway.

Via made the chipset of the only board that died on me (and took my first K6-2 450 with it). I don't remember who made the board, it was before I became knowledgeable in the tech field.

OT warning!

Yup. I too have given the Macs a very long and Hard look:)

Tale of two boards.

All motherboard makers have had the Champs and Chumps! AOpen is a prime example. Their AX6BC Pro was one of my favorite BX boards if not my Top BX. How good was it? When A bud couldn't find another to replace his damaged by a Failed water cooling system (LEAK). He traded me a Mobo , Processor and 256MB of RAM for mine. To this day he's still using it and I came out on the short end of the deal. I still have the Slot-1 650MHz Processor that overclock to almost 1GHz on it. I think it got to about 975MHz IIRC. But I digress.

http://www.lostcircuits.com/motherboard/aopen_ax6bcpro/

My AOpen AX4C i875 was almost as bad as my A7M. Yes, I haven't trashed the board and I have for it (kept it) proof of how bad it was. It talked but the only thing it said was "Your CPU may have a Problem". All 6 CPUs that worked without pause on other systems had problems on it. Even in-between corrupting the Hard, cold boot and etc.. it ran slower than ALL other i875's. AOpen said nothing was wrong with it. Yet, their i865 version worked perfectly, go figure. Their own Forums are full of folks who had problems with them. They should have recalled it.

On Topic.
I've bought Good and Bad from DFI, Gigabyte, Aopen, Asus, ABit, MSI and Iwill. All of their support sucks!
 
mzs_biteme said:
Both CPU's will do great in gaming.
Conroe will do a little better (at stock, in benchmarks) ;)
Both CPU's will overclock well.
Conroe will overclock much better :eek:
Both CPU's will run cool enough.
Conroe will run cooler... :cool:

At stock, in games, you will not see/feel the difference between the two.
Overclocked (3.3~3.6GHz average), Conrore will have much greater impact on your games, and you'll actually notice it. But then you'll be limited by your GPU (no SLI, Crossfire.. :mad: )
Get a Gigabyte mobo. Or wait for the nForce 680i chipset mobos for SLI.

Good luck.

Quoted for truth and fixed the chipset name...
 
How about in the long run when games are not so gpu limited? Which would be the better choice (compare mid-range chip amd to mid-range c2d, higher end to higher end)?

Case1: stock
Case2: oc'd to average oc's ppl have been getting.. rough estimate since OCing varies
 
OP said:
(AM2 or C2D motherboard (NOT ASUS) *
(AM2 x2-4800 or C2d E6600)*
Patriot DDR2 800 Ram or Corsair DDR2 XMS2 800*
XFX 7900GTX 512
Auzentech X-Plosion
WD 250G HD SATA

UnlimitedMP said:
How about in the long run when games are not so gpu limited? Which would be the better choice (compare mid-range chip amd to mid-range c2d, higher end to higher end)?

Case1: stock
Case2: oc'd to average oc's ppl have been getting.. rough estimate since OCing varies

I don't know if a 4800+ is enough to max out games enough to make it GPU limited. I know an E6600 can.

Case1: E6600 is in the FX-62 class (slighter faster LOL!).
Case2: E6600 out overclocks anything AMD has.

http://www.buyxg.com/store/item.asp?key=CU-189-103
http://www.pc-ontime.com/store/product3906.html
 
mzs_biteme said:
Both CPU's will do great in gaming.
Conroe will do a little better (at stock, in benchmarks) ;)
Both CPU's will overclock well.
Conroe will overclock much better :eek:
Both CPU's will run cool enough.
Conroe will run cooler... :cool:

At stock, in games, you will not see/feel the difference between the two.
Overclocked (3.3~3.6GHz average), Conrore will have much greater impact on your games, and you'll actually notice it. But then you'll be limited by your GPU (no SLI, Crossfire.. :mad: )
Get a Gigabyte mobo.

Good luck.

QFT

Conroe is better in EVERYTHING.

Even an e6600 vs FX-62.
In gaming, if you jack up the resolution to just barely playable settings the 2 will be very close ONLY b/c at that point you're limited by the videocard. If you lowered the resolution/game settings you'd see the Core 2 beat the X2 easily. I like my framerates higher than an average of 30!! So at the resolutions I play at where I want 100fps average, there's a much bigger difference.

And all of this is comparing stock processors.


If you compared OC'd to OC'd it would be more like 2.9Ghz X2 vs 3.3+Ghz Core 2 and the AMD system would be DESTROYED. All while the Core 2 system would be running MUCH COOLER.
 
FSX is cpu over GPU today.

Good luck getting that to run really well in all instances today.

Sometime tomorrow, but it's essentially single threaded and will cripple your system.

Flight sims never get fps frame rates, but this is bad- ~5 at LAX
 
Asus is flat out a shitty motherboard company, and their boards are no different. Their customer service dept is the only place where the operator tells you "we'll call you back" and never get back to you. + RMA's take FOREVER with them, I waited about a month to get my old P4C800 Deluxe back a year ago, worst thing ever. Besides they're too damn expensive even for their "budget boards".
Call Samsung, Sony, DFI, Epox, Kingston, Viewsonic, just a handful of company names, and have them call you back.
Whoever believes a company will call you back, has it coming to them. Do you realize Asus is a multi-billion dollar company, and for some kid who kills a motherboard a week, they are not out for your audience. They want people who love computers,and know what there doing. If I owned a shop by you, I would refuse service to you probably after the 2nd board, maybe third. Simple as that, I say you don't know what your talking about. Lets see you throw a DFI or Epox board down the stairs and see it still boot? Our schools philosophy / debate team would tear you a new one kid.

My experiences line-up different....
I remember...Epox...the laughing stock of motherboards. The most unreliable even @ default. I had to replace a few of these POS boards with some real top tier boards every time.
DFI.......well they haven't had a bad name, the shop I worked at never carried them, except for K6 boards. Asus is #1, but DFI has came a long ways I hear.
Asus just posted all of its quarterly profits and what not, they are still #1. I think Kyle would agree, Asus is a top quality tier producer of hardware. You don't find brands that make top of the line video card, motherboards, and other snazzy stuff.

I used to work at a shop and we sold probably off the top of my head around 1,000 Asus boards yearly, if you figure roughly 3 a day. Which was no problem, and we saw Asus come back the least, even though we sold them the most. Which is contrary to what stats for that should be.

I will be the first to call BULLSHIT. On someone owning like half a dozen new in box Asus boards DOA's or dead within the first week. You killed the boards overclocking them, or mishandling them, or just like the movie "My Name is Earl", you have serious issues with karma. But I repeat, Asus is literally the #1 brand name, and #1 in quality motherboard. I would like you to show me a company with a better track record.

Asus does not market their motherboards to the "Best Buy / Circuit City / Wal-Mart" crowd, which is one clear difference between them and Epox.
 
Back
Top