Quake 4 = Doom 3 jr.

Rtstrider

Gawd
Joined
Dec 3, 2004
Messages
597
Is it just me or does Quake 4 seem like a Doom 3 add on...The menu's look the same....Some of the textures in the first level are the same....And it just looks the same all over the place....Seems very unoriginal....
 
HighwayAssassins said:
i feel the same, although i have only played about 5 minutes and seen screenshots.
And I'm guessing it close to the same for the OP. The gameplay is signifigantly different. So is the great environment artwork.
 
Mhmm!

I played for a couple of minutes thinking "Oh gee, Doom 3....Yay..." But I played a bit more, and they're actually really different. The gameplay is so much better than Doom 3.
 
IT just amazes me on how guys compare QUake 4 to Doom 3. Ofcrouse Quake 4 will look simillar to doom 3 because its made usind the doom 3 engine. That said Quake 4 is much better than Doom3 and unless you are a quake fan you wont probably like the game.

and i say again. Quake 4 is a 50$ well spent game for me. MP was a blast so was the single player. The only game that made me go "one more try"
 
i got both games and have never touched sp.
mp is decent in q4 but the game gets old fast as fuck.
all you gotta do is run around and hold down the shoot button.
you can finish top5 with this skilled technique.
 
Quake 4 for me brings back the memories of Quake2 and Quake3....

Oh i so LOVE QUAKE.................it is better gameplay than doom3...but the game play between the 2 are differnt...and it's all because they are differnt games.... ;)

I would like to see a quake 1 remake or even a sequal of quake1... :D
 
How many more threads are we going to see like this?

After playing both games, Quake 4 and Doom 3 are two diffrent games. The only similarities they have is that there on the same engine. Other than that they are diffrent. Quake 4 has lights, Doom 3 didnt. Quake 4 has fast paced action, Doom 3 didnt. Quake 4 didnt get repetitive like Doom 3 did. Doom 3 multiplayer sucked, Quake 4 multiplayer rocks, even though I experience some lag sometimes. The list can go on.
 
honkee said:
i got both games and have never touched sp.
mp is decent in q4 but the game gets old fast as fuck.
all you gotta do is run around and hold down the shoot button.
you can finish top5 with this skilled technique.

How about instead of playing in a public DM server you play someone in a duel? Or even a public tournament game.
 
Lazy_Moron said:
How many more threads are we going to see like this?

After playing both games, Quake 4 and Doom 3 are two diffrent games. The only similarities they have is that there on the same engine. Other than that they are diffrent. Quake 4 has lights, Doom 3 didnt. Quake 4 has fast paced action, Doom 3 didnt. Quake 4 didnt get repetitive like Doom 3 did. Doom 3 multiplayer sucked, Quake 4 multiplayer rocks, even though I experience some lag sometimes. The list can go on.

I consider this post trolling. You have been warned.
 
Nuzzles said:
Mhmm!

I played for a couple of minutes thinking "Oh gee, Doom 3....Yay..." But I played a bit more, and they're actually really different. The gameplay is so much better than Doom 3.

It couldnt be any worse. Hey Doom 3, 1995 called and it wants its gameplay back.
 
Well since the gameplay is different....Anyone one notice how the Quake 4 menu setup closley resembles the Doom 3 one? With the tabs on the bottom...

The only game that made me go "one more try"

There's quite a few games that have done that to me.... Rise Of The Triad, Wolfenstein 3d, Chasm, Soldier Of Fortune, Soldier Of Fortune 2, Medal Of Honor, Call Of Duty, Medal Of Honor Pacific Assualt, Call Of Duty 2 Demo, Brothers In Arms.....There's so many more.....I just wanted to make the list short...
 
I've been playing for awhile, and I think its better than Doom 3 by a long shot, but so was Russurection Of Evil.

My biggest gripe so far is I ran past a couple overhead turrets which I was supposed to have taken out, I guess to buy some time, but when I ran past I went to the other side of the room and ran right into spawning Strogg.

POP!

Right out of nowhere. :mad:
 
astern said:
How about instead of playing in a public DM server you play someone in a duel? Or even a public tournament game.


duel?
tournament?
that would sound pretty cool, but if its like last man standing for ut series.
ill pass atm.
:D
 
Q4 does not feel like an add on for D3 at all. The more I play the game the more I am getting flashbacks to Q2. The environments, the monsters, the weaps, the overall feel of the game is ripped right from the Q2 pages.

Sure it looks similar but that would have to be from the D3 engine and the fact that the D3 textures are similar to what they are using for Q4.

Overall great game with a better SP experience than D3.
 
I thought Doom3 was fun for the most part ..looking forward to playing Quake IV as I just finished my 3rd time thru F.E.A.R. ...time to dive into a new game for a bit ... :)


[H]
 
Well its usiing Doom3's Engine thats why its the almost identical. The single player is the best im up to the area where u got change to strogg (might be a spioler but meh) muiltplayer is good but im getting my a** kicked on it with all those Quake Fan boys and girls.

If i rated it outa a 10 it would be a 10, best game I have played so fare then FEAR.

just my $0.02

:)
 
Well I gave it the benefit of the doubt....Even though it looks like Doom 3, it has a whole different feel.....I've played it up to the destroy the hangars part....Still in the beginning...Haven't gotten too far into it....One thing on the upside though is that it's not so freakin dark like Doom 3.....
 
Back
Top