Quadcore vs two Dual Core?

OmegaAquinas

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 10, 2002
Messages
1,046
Got an interesting question from one of the other admins, and I'm a bit stumped...mostly from lack of data on my part regarding the subject.

We're about to bump up to Exchange 2007, and we're looking into new 64bit hardware for the install. The question was, which performs better for exchange: two dual core chips or a single quadcore?

Or in other words, are several physical chips better than a single chip with multiple cores? I imagine the single chip has better latency, but are there other benefits to the multiple chips?

Just thought I'd bring it to the [H] and see if I can get this answered...thanks a bunch!
 
I would speculate that the single quad-core would be the cheaper route, and would be good enough.

I would think the separate, pair of dual-core cpu's would be the faster as each pair of cores would have their own direct bus to memory, but for Intel the memory controller isn't in the CPU, it's in the northbridge... So in either configuration the 4 cpu cores have to go through the northbridge. I dunno.
 
Cost isn't the issue, performance is...exchange is one of those lucky projects that gets every dollar it needs. :)
 
I'm positive that 2 chips with 2 cores each would outperform 1 chip with four cores, as long as we're talking about current technology. The main factor here would most likely be the cache size. Two chips with a 4MB Cache each would be a better performer than 1 Chip with 4 cores but only 4MB of cache.

If you take a step down to a chip that has 2 cores but only 2MB Cache, I'd still venture to guess it would be a better performer than the single quad core.

Here's a link to a November 2006 review that shows heads up the difference between running dual cpus compared to 1 quad core: http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=585&num=1
 
Back
Top