Quad System, any help before I buy?

rivacom

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 23, 2007
Messages
348
GIGABYTE GA-EP43-DS3L LGA 775 Intel P43 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail - $94.99
G.SKILL 4GB (2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory Model F2-6400CL5D-4GBPQ - Retail - $79.99
Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 Kentsfield 2.4GHz LGA 775 Quad-Core Processor Model HH80562PH0568M - OEM - $169.99
Antec 300
&
Antec EA500 Combo - $99.94

Total : $499.94 (including shipping/tax)

Any suggestions, would this be a ok overclocker? (looking at 3.0ghz at least). Also will the XIGMATEK HDT-S1283 120mm Rifle CPU Cooler fit in the Antec 300 case? Or would a better HSF suit me.

I have already :
PNY 8800GT 512MB
DVD Drive
250GB WD Sata Drive
Windows Vista Ultimate 64 Bit Edition.
 
But will the HSF fit in the 300, it seems a bit tall and i'm wondering if it'll make it in. As for fans, i'm going to take them off my last case for now, and probably will upgrade them soon.

Also i notice on the board the memory standard is 1066, but im using 800mhz memory. Is this still ok?
 
i think the xigmatek should fit in there.... and dont worry about the ram.. with a Q6600 you wouldnt even be overclocking 800mhz ram until you hit over 3.6ghz with a 1:1 fsb/ram divider.
 
You're better off with a core 2 e8400, better OCer, better performance for anything you'd use it for.
 
Won't a Quad core OC last me longer than a 8400?
"Future Proofing" yourself with a q6600 today is like "Future Proofing" yourself with a Pentium D back in 2005. Dual-Cores are now in their prime where companies are designing software around them. This wasn't the case in 2005, much like it is today with Quad-Cores. But, back then when you bought a Dual-Core, you still noticed a boost to performance between XP helped split threads between the 2, much like with the performance boost Hyperthreading gave, it was pretty big. You don't get that with Quad-Cores because no amount of multitasking you do at home, unless you're using software you know you need a Quad-Core for, is going to benefit from a Quad. I've said before, people severely underestimate the multitasking of a Core 2 now days.

By the time anything you would do, at home, uses a quad core, there would be something a lot better for a lot less available. Hell, even the new i7 Intel chips coming out will have Hyperthreading. You could wait for the mainstream Dual-Core i7 w/Hyperthreading, and it would be a virtual 4 Core CPU. That would be good at home for the following reason. With Hyperthreading, the CPU automatically helps split threads between 2 cores, 1 real, 1 virtual. Since software is designed now days for 2 cores, Hyperthreading will take that the next step further and expand on that, putting it between 4 cores, 2 real, 2 virtual. However, in the case of Quad-Core, you need the software to do the work of threading work, and nothing at home except Video Rendering etc, uses 4 cores, your wasting 2 cores. You're better of buying a fast Core 2 now and getting a quad core 2-3 years, or more, down the road. Unless of course you know you have something that needs 4 cores, like rendering, but if that were the case you wouldn't be asking for advice because you know you need it. Crysis is supposed to be threaded for 4 cores but there is virtually zero performance boost with a Quad. Don't let the "coolness" of a Quad cloud your judgment. Are they neat? Sure. Are they anything that people need unless you're specifically using development software that requires one? Absolutely not.

Do the research online and search for benchmarks comparing q6600 to others. You'll find that in gaming there is zero benefit and that running a faster dual cores nets better frame rate. The only time you'll notice a quad with better performance is in productivity software like Adobe, Pinnacle etc.. Those are all applications designed around threading of multi core or multi CPU systems in order to reduce downtime of rendering. You could use those on a dual quad core skulltrail setup for blazing fast performance, but games are not going to be any faster.That's an easy thing to do with productivity software but designing around 4 + cores for gaming is not as easy because of latency between cores (in processor terms it's a lot). Quad-Core gaming is years away. And even if something released in the next year or two 'truely' supports it, an e8400 would still be faster because of clock speed. You're not going to get a quad with all 4 cores at 100% load in gaming.

Overall, I would avoid the q6xxx series like you would the plague, or your mother-in-law. The only one I would even consider buying someday would be the q9550 or the up coming q9650, and only after the price drops closer to the e8xxx series in a year or two. Simply because they are a quad but at least the 2 cores you would use are clocked similarly to the e8400, so the performance for everyday applications/games, would be the same.

The new Hyperthreaded core i7 dual cores are going to be BADASS at home though. CPU controlled threading + modern dual core support is going to be a big noticable boost. It will basically be a quad core (in task manager).
 
Well say I want to run a bunch of applications like Vent, Xfire, MSN, and some other software like my video Capture solution while I'm gaming. Would the E8400 still have as much juice as the Q6600 with multitasking all this?
 
Well say I want to run a bunch of applications like Vent, Xfire, MSN, and some other software like my video Capture solution while I'm gaming. Would the E8400 still have as much juice as the Q6600 with multitasking all this?

It would probably be ok, but that's exactly the sort of activity quads are good for. A quad won't give you a whole lot of benefit in a single application like most games, but when you're trying to do a lot of stuff at once they're great.

I saw enormous improvement when I went quad. To be fair most of what I do is video editing and 3d rendering rather than extreme multitasking, but the system as a whole feels a lot more responsive.
 
ive had both q6600 and e8400 chips and while gaming at high resolution i noticed no difference between the 2... i do video editing / converting aswell and the quad smoked the dual core.
 
Well say I want to run a bunch of applications like Vent, Xfire, MSN, and some other software like my video Capture solution while I'm gaming. Would the E8400 still have as much juice as the Q6600 with multitasking all this?
The reason I try to stress such a difference is people recommend Quads to people before they even know what they'll be using the system for. Considering you can bind the affinity to different cores, a quad could work for you. But keep in mind that Vista or XP is not going to split up the workload between 4 cores from those by itself. If the applications are not designed to look for more than 1 or 2 cores, then quad still won't do you any good. All you'd be doing is trying to push all those applications through the same core. You'll have to manually set them and that can get annoying each time you launch, unless you keep your system running a lot. That's why I recommend a fast dual core because you're getting more done on the 1 or 2 cores that are being used.

Lasso can help you divide up your task on Quad-Cores.

Most people, 75-80% of users, maybe higher, will never notice a difference with a Quad over a Dual-Core. Yet, on here at least, 80-90% of CPU recommendation is Quad.
 
The reason I try to stress such a difference is people recommend Quads to people before they even know what they'll be using the system for. Considering you can bind the affinity to different cores, a quad could work for you. But keep in mind that Vista or XP is not going to split up the workload between 4 cores from those by itself. If the applications are not designed to look for more than 1 or 2 cores, then quad still won't do you any good.

Uh, yeah it will. You don't have to manually set the processor affinity. Have you ever used a quad core system?

Obviously a single-threaded application can only make use of one core, but Vista does a good job at balancing out multiple applications/threads by assigning separate applications/threads to separate cores.
 
Uh, yeah it will. You don't have to manually set the processor affinity. Have you ever used a quad core system?

Obviously a single-threaded application can only make use of one core, but Vista does a good job at balancing out multiple applications/threads by assigning separate applications/threads to separate cores.
There may be some minor threading going on but nothing significant that the 2nd core on a dual couldn't easily handle.

You say one thing, every sites benchmarks say another. For every day computing usage and gaming, Quad-Cores are not needed, and are not shown to provide a benefit.

I still say a 3ghz core 2 will out perform a 2.4ghz quad for everything except productivity suites that are designed for multi-cpu systems.
 
Most people, 75-80% of users, maybe higher, will never notice a difference with a Quad over a Dual-Core. Yet, on here at least, 80-90% of CPU recommendation is Quad.

Most of the people who ask about getting a quad-core have already planned on buying one. Whether or not they actually "need" one is irrelevant for the most part.
 
And it does this because you say it does? :rolleyes: All those software developers that make applications to help split task between cores must just be wasting their time then.

Think about what you're saying. If XP/Vista couldn't distribute individual applications and processes to the seperate cores there would be no performance increase at all, which is not the case.

Like I said, obviously a single threaded application can only be assigned to a single core, but when you're running multiple applications the operating system will automatically let each core take some of the threads. I'm not saying the OS splits up the individual threads.

For what the OP wants to do, run multiple applications at once, a quad sounds like the better choice. It will be plenty fast for gaming and there are more games coming down the line that actually make use of or even require at least 2 cores.

(I caught your ninja edit :p)
 
You say one thing, every sites benchmarks say another. For every day computing usage and gaming, Quad-Cores are not needed, and are not shown to provide a benefit.

I still say a 3ghz core 2 will out perform a 2.4ghz quad for everything except productivity suites that are designed for multi-cpu systems.

Again, obviously a single threaded application will only make use of one core. I'm not arguing that quads are the holy grail of gaming or anything like that.

What I'm saying is that quads are good for multitasking, show me a benchmark that says otherwise. Plus, if you do run any multithreaded applications there can be enormous benefits.

And hey, you may be able to get a sweet OC out of a Q6600.
 
Most of the people who ask about getting a quad-core have already planned on buying one. Whether or not they actually "need" one is irrelevant for the most part.

I agree, but as long as he's making an informed decision, then we've done our part. I don't think it takes as many words as bigdogchris typed, but eh, it sheds light on the other side, I hope (TLDR, lol).

The reason I try to stress such a difference is people recommend Quads to people before they even know what they'll be using the system for. ...

The funny part, IMO, was the fact that you recommended a dual core not only for OC'ing (which is what the OP asked about), but also for what he'll be doing with the system, before you even knew what he was using the system for...

You're better off with a core 2 e8400, better OCer, better performance for anything you'd use it for.

Yet nowhere in the OP did the OP say what he was using the system for. :p Sure, its better for OC'ing, but its that last part of your post that made me laugh: ... better performance for anything you'd use it for. ... how ironic.
 
Back
Top