Quad Core VS Dual Core Which Is Better?

NYXX

n00b
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
59
So I'm builiding anew computer this coming this June when Intel releases a bunch of new processors. I know Pretty much what kind of system I'm building. I have one aspect left to contend with its the processor.

I'm mostly going to game on full quality settings. But not to Crysis standards. I also plan to run other applications like Photoshop CS2, Illustrators CS2, Adobe Premiere and After Effects.

The Chips I'm looking at

Intel Core 2 Duo Core E8500 45NM VS Intel Core 2 Quad 9650 OR 96550 45NM

I've heard I should save my $300 from a Quad stick with Dual Core then Upgrade to Quad Next year. Put the $300 towards other hardware.

Some Possible Products I'm looking at to build my computer.

Processor: Intel Quad Q9550/Q9650 OR Intel Core 2 Dual E8500
Video Card: ATI Radeon 3870 X2 OR ATI Radeon HD 4870X2 or HD4870
Motherboard: Asus Rampage Formula X48
Computer Case: Thermaltake Armor + Full Server Tower
Hard Drive: Western Digital 2x500 Gigabit Hard-drives and 500GB Raid Edition
Power Supply: Antec Quattro 850 Watt Powersupply
Ram: Muskin Redline XP PC2-8000 2x2GB or OCZ RPX Reaper 1066 2x 2GB

What are your thoughts.
 
There's already a ton of posts on this very forum asking the same question you are.:rolleyes: The search feature is your friend. I went Quad and will never go back. What's better depends on what you are doing. Just gaming Dual core is good, multitasking, photoshop quad is good, flip a coin and decide.
 
It's not a simple answer, personally I am going Quad over the newest wolfdale.
 
The never ending cycle of this question is just stunning. I feel like I'm stuck in some fucking Star Trek time loop.

FYI: spending the extra money on the Q9650 or 8500 means you have too much money and too little sense. For what you do get a Q6600 and clock it to between 3ghz and 3.6 and call it a day.

Hell if you just want to piss money away you can send me a Q6600 or Q9300 as well.
 
*sigh*

We had this same debate about dual core vs. single core. There was an idiot on another (non-computer) forum I frequent who insisted that dual was superior to quad, and previously single was superior to dual. Why? "Framerates." Okay........

Games have evolved to multithreading-capable PCs. They will continue to do so. 4GHz really doesn't help most games (GPU limits, anyone?) so I'll take a 3GHz overclocked quad (which I have) over a super-OMFG-major-overclock-4GHz dual. Or even a stock quad over a stock dual. Quad is ahead of the curve, dual is behind (if you can afford a quad, if not the whole question is moot but since you're asking you obviously can).
 
Today right now, a faster DualCore is the better buy for Gaming only. Not many games get much benefit from QuadCore yet, and when games do really need Quad like 2009 there will be a whole new generation of cpu's

But DualCore is only better for high rez gaming, at 1920x1200 or 2560x1600 it is 99% the VideoCard that make the difference at that rez, a $1000 cpu or $199 will be within 2% at highrez, again it is all gpu
 
a $1000 cpu or $199 will be within 2% at highrez, again it is all gpu

Heck, OC'ing the $200 E8400 almost makes the $1100 extremes useless, OC a E84 to have 400FSB to match the DDR2-800 rather than upping the multi on a X6800 or such(with mem @ 667mhz)
 
If you're getting a new computer that you want to last a bit of time I would go Quad. To be honest, although some games don't use the multithreading, new games will. Since I assume you'll want to play the newest titles well, I would go for Quad-core. Dual-core is perfectly acceptable for gaming now but if you're throwing down that much money I doubt you'll want to get outshined soon.
 
I've heard I should save my $300 from a Quad stick with Dual Core then Upgrade to Quad Next year. Put the $300 towards other hardware.

If you are already planning to upgrade (again) next year and your main concern is gaming performance between now and then, then yes, stick with the dual core.

If however you want to save a bit of money in the long run and want to keep the PC longer than next year, and/or if gaming is not your only concern, get a quad now and you shouldn't need to touch the CPU for some time to come.
 
If however you want to save a bit of money in the long run and want to keep the PC longer than than next year, and/or if gaming is not your only concern, get a quad now and you shouldn't need to touch the CPU for some time to come.

I'm a fan of this for the simple reason that I believe every computer you build should be able to run for as long as possible with reasonable performance. If you give it to family, charity, a school, etc it feels good to know that you're giving away a capable system.
 
Depends on how much After Effects and Premiere and editing stuff you're gonna do. Sounds like mostly gaming...then don't bother with a quad. Unless you're big time rendering or editing, its just pure overkill, simple.
 
I think the answer to the question is pretty simple. If you encode video though, the quad trumps all.

OK....

You game mostly and keep your CPU's for about a year - get a faster dual.

You keep your CPU's for about two years - get a quad.

If he games mostly, he would be better served by a faster dual. And when the rest of the planet moves to quad as the mainstream, (a year'ish maybe?), he can move then.

Robert
 
If you do any editing/modelling, quad

for general purposes, gaming, dual until quad becomes mainstream in gaming
 
Or you are using production systems that require 100% reliability and overclocking is not part of the picture.

Overclocking is not for everyone or every machine in every circumstance.


The never ending cycle of this question is just stunning. I feel like I'm stuck in some fucking Star Trek time loop.

FYI: spending the extra money on the Q9650 or 8500 means you have too much money and too little sense. For what you do get a Q6600 and clock it to between 3ghz and 3.6 and call it a day.

Hell if you just want to piss money away you can send me a Q6600 or Q9300 as well.
 
you're doing it wrong.

Buy a cheaper processor!!

your options should be more like e8400, q6600 or q9450, both 45nm's can probably hit 4Ghz with enough cooling & volts and the q6600 will probably do about 3.4Ghz+- 200Mhz.... SO why spend more $ for a 1/2 a multiplier (in the case of the e8500).
 
what about my quad core at 4.2ghz?

The post you quoted answered your own question, if you'd turn on your brain for a picosecond.

Your 4.2GHz quad, however is not at all indicative of average performance of overclocked quad core CPUs, and is in fact higher than all but 2 quad core overclocks in the [H] Intel OC database at the top of this forum. Funny how I don't see it in there. Hmmm :rolleyes:
 
The post you quoted answered your own question, if you'd turn on your brain for a picosecond.

Your 4.2GHz quad, however is not at all indicative of average performance of overclocked quad core CPUs, and is in fact higher than all but 2 quad core overclocks in the [H] Intel OC database at the top of this forum. Funny how I don't see it in there. Hmmm :rolleyes:

Funny, didn't know I could turn my brain on or off, guess I learned something new today, and posting my overclock? i dont really live on forums buddy not that big of a deal to me.
 
I need to find a forum where people dont have this simpleton single minded obsession with gaming.
 
/dumbmath

2.4ghz * 4 > 3.0ghz * 2 durrrrr

No really, both are good, I doubt either will bottleneck you. To be painfully honest the only reason your CPU would be your major bottleneck is if you're running an encoding program or doing some other programming thing, in which case it will probably benefit from the 4 cores. Besides, it'll benefit from the cores later. Just get the quad-core >.>
 
I am seriously going to shoot myself with so many people posting this now. Either one will do fine for what most people use thier computers for. If you can afford the extra bucks get a quad. If not oh well.
 
Ok everyone who thinks the Unreal3 engine runs so much better and faster on a QuadCore than a DualCore.

I have always said that at high rez it is 90% the VideoCard, and that a $200 cpu vs the eXtreme $1400 cpu's does not make a difference, and here it is to prove my point.

Look at the last benchmark of UT3 2560x1600rez showing a cheap E6600 vs expensive QX9770 and there is like 5% difference at most.
http://techgage.com/article/intel_core_2_quad_q9450_266ghz/10
 
Zorachus, it's pretty much because for most games all we need is a 2.66ghz+ C2D(E6750 w/ 4MB cache for example) or better.
 
Ok everyone who thinks the Unreal3 engine runs so much better and faster on a QuadCore than a DualCore.

I have always said that at high rez it is 90% the VideoCard, and that a $200 cpu vs the eXtreme $1400 cpu's does not make a difference, and here it is to prove my point.

Look at the last benchmark of UT3 2560x1600rez showing a cheap E6600 vs expensive QX9770 and there is like 5% difference at most.
http://techgage.com/article/intel_core_2_quad_q9450_266ghz/10

I'm not sure that proves anything. From the screenshot taken, there is nearly nothing going on. Was this a simple timedemo or a real game with players in there? My old X2 4400+ had no issues running the game in a scene like that, but add several players into the mix, all shooting rockets and flack cannons at each other, and it became unplayable.
 
Back
Top