Q9450 vs E8500 bs Q6600

What CPU would you choose for a 2000$ build

  • Q9450

    Votes: 76 71.0%
  • Q6600

    Votes: 20 18.7%
  • E8500

    Votes: 9 8.4%
  • Other (please post about it)

    Votes: 2 1.9%

  • Total voters
    107

thinkdifferent

Weaksauce
Joined
Dec 2, 2007
Messages
72
Hi,

I'm about to go on a new build and I was wondering what you would choose. I have a 2,000$ budget. I'm going to be gaming and doing a bit of photoshop work on a 24in screen.

Please let me know what you think.

Thanks,
 
well... I had heard that the E8500 or E8300 may be better for gaming. I was just wondering if there was any truth to that and why it may be that way?

Would it be better to go cheapers on the CPU but invest more in the video cards.
 
Well, right now most games really shine with higher clockspeeds. An E8500 can reach well over 4 gigahertz. Photowork, video encoding, acad, things like that can REALLY get an advantage from a quad core processors, because those applications are better coded to take advantage of the extra two cores. Now don't get me wrong, the Q6600 and 9450 can still be overclocked well, but gamers usually chose the E8500, because you can get higher clocks. I voted Q6600 because it will serve you better than the E8500, although the Q9450 will also be an excellent choice.

As for the later question, with a $2000 dollar budget, that is PLENTY of money to not skip out on either graphics or the processor. S
 
What is the real difference between the 9450 and the 6600?

45nm process, SSE4, lower voltage req., larger L2 cache, runs cooler, more than likely better OC headroom...it's not a *huge* upgrade over the Q6600, but if you've got the cash (and it looks like you do) there's no real reason not to.

And no, dual core processors are not better for gaming. Not anymore, anyway.
 
The 9450 is significantly more future proof. The Q6600 doesn't even support SSE4.1 so when benchmarks/games/apps use the power of that, you're going to see huge jumps. Faster FSB and cache don't hurt either. If you we're trying to stay under $1k, it would be different but definitely roll with the 9450.
 
I personally have a Q9450 and I recommend it as well. All I've had to do was change the FSB from 1333 to 1600 and am running at basically the same specs as the QX9770.
 
Man, it never ends... Now i want one nice Quad, but i already have nice Dual, and with Nehalem coming out next year i'll probably want that too :mad:... my poor wallet.
 
Man, it never ends... Now i want one nice Quad, but i already have nice Dual, and with Nehalem coming out next year i'll probably want that too :mad:... my poor wallet.

I feel your pain. :D I'm trying to decide whether to get a Q9550 post-price-cut (probably after Nehalem has been out a few months, and likely wil drop <$300) or just hold out with my dual until Westmere (aka Nehalem's die-shrink).
 
Another vote for the 9450. If you are not big in OCing then I'd say go for the 9550.
 
Some people had compatibility issues with their mobos and Xeon chips, so that is always a gamble, you wont know it until you put it in your machine.
 
Some people had compatibility issues with their mobos and Xeon chips, so that is always a gamble, you wont know it until you put it in your machine.

Can you name one person for me?

The only "issue" I've heard of is the processor not being recognized properly, but they work fine. Its just the motherboard calls it "Unknown processor" or something.
 
Back
Top