PS3: Sony justifies the boomerang

steviep

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jan 18, 2005
Messages
4,985
boomerangdebunked.gif

So does that change your mind? :p
 
Interesting very interesting. I prefer to reserve judgement until I have one in my hands.

Joe
 
I can see where Sony is comming from, the actual outer curve of the controller is very close to the Madcatz controller I have for my Dreamcast:

tmc-lan4.13.jpg

tmc-lan4.14.jpg
 
Eh.... has Sony officially said if you can just use your old DS2 controllers or not?
 
umm...
if you shape your hands like in the pictures taking note of the index fingers for the top, you can tell that the controller doesn't fit a regular hand.

Take note of how your middle to pinky fingers are curled, the controller would require an extreme bend to accomodate your gripping fingers. (much like the microsoft freestyle pro controller).

Even in the picture it doesn't look like his hands are gripping the handles.

The driving wheel comparison doesnt work, since you cannot drive with your index fingers pointed towards each other with your thumbs in the front.
 
how about you wait until you actually hold one until you pass it off as uncomfortable and awkward?

Furthermore, this gif image isn't done by Sony, it's obviously fan based
 
Why did it take them this long to release that justification? Couldn't they have said that 6 months ago?

It's almost like they've had a team of guys working overtime for the past 6 months to come up with a reason why Sony -isn't- retarded.
 
I'm surprised they didn't just use their standard justification: we're sony and we said so, assface.
 
"As natural as holding a steering wheel?"

Who the hell holds a steering wheel and 11:45 / 12:15?
 
IceWind said:
*Looks down at hands in natural holding state* Well I"ll be damn....Sony might be on to something

Heh, I was thinking, "There's not way that's going to work, it looks horrible." Then I did like you, and looked at my natural holding state, and it's like, wow...

This could be good. :D
 
I"ll tell you one thing.. the dual shock controller does suck.. i hope this is better...

that dual shock controller sucks sooooo much ballz.. it cramps my hands like hell..
 
RancidWAnnaRIot said:
I"ll tell you one thing.. the dual shock controller does suck.. i hope this is better...

that dual shock controller sucks sooooo much ballz.. it cramps my hands like hell..

Seriously? I've found the DS2 to be by far the most comfortable controller I've ever used.

The only true really terribly horrible controllers I can remember were the N64 controller and the original (mega-ultra-huge) Xbox controller.
 
RancidWAnnaRIot said:
I"ll tell you one thing.. the dual shock controller does suck.. i hope this is better...

that dual shock controller sucks sooooo much ballz.. it cramps my hands like hell..

I agree 100%! The dual shock is awful, especially for big hands. Everyone is complaining about this thing because it looks big and wierd even though they've never tried it. Hello, looks don't matter in a controller, functionality does. I am actually loving the design because it looks bigger. For someone with large hands I think this will be much more comfortable.
 
I always figured the reasoning behind the boomerang was to give the controller more room. If you think about the DS2 there isn't much space inside of it to have decent battery life. The boomerang shape adds more real estate inside the controller which would give Sony more wiggle room to increase the battery life of the controller.

I would much rather have a double (censored) shaped controller that has 30 hours of battery life than a wireless DS2 that needs to be charged every 10 hours.


Although Sonys choice of Bluetooth sucks IMO, due to the fact that two consoles near each other will interfere with the bluetooth signals, meaning no PS3 lan parties.
 
those the controller looks funny.. it looks promising...

but we'll see..

honestly.. my single issue with the PS2 was the controller.. that's all..
 
Erasmus354 said:
Although Sonys choice of Bluetooth sucks IMO, due to the fact that two consoles near each other will interfere with the bluetooth signals, meaning no PS3 lan parties.

The Wavebirds used some variety of BlueTooth, and they are still today (even with the X360 out) the best wireless controllers hands down, both for range, ease of use, playability, and battery life. I've literally travelled half of my house (and it's not small) and was still able to play fine :)

As for this being "bigger" - actually I think the boomerang will be smaller than the DS2. I don't like the DS2, anyway. I find the Gamecube controller to be much more comfortable.
 
NulloModo said:
Seriously? I've found the DS2 to be by far the most comfortable controller I've ever used.

The only true really terribly horrible controllers I can remember were the N64 controller and the original (mega-ultra-huge) Xbox controller.

That's the one I liked.... It was WAAY more comfortable for me than that dinky piece of shit S controller. : / I wish they still sold them. D :
 
Out of all the controllers out now I think the most comfortable have been the Gamecube controllers. This PS3 controller looks bad ass though.
 
HighwayAssassins said:
I still think the xbox 1 controllers were the best designed controllers of all time.


the controller S is well deisgned.. except for the placement of the black and white buttons.. a bit hard for me to reach.. but over all.. i can agree..

I also really like the gamecube controller.
 
RancidWAnnaRIot said:
the controller S is well deisgned.. except for the placement of the black and white buttons.. a bit hard for me to reach.. but over all.. i can agree..

I also really like the gamecube controller.

The gamecube controller, In my opinion, is the most comfortable controller i've used to date ( with the Xbox S in second). I also loved the Dreamcast controller. Something about it made it very easy to use in my hands. :cool:
 
I concur, I THOUGHT the DS2 controllers were the most comfortable but then when I tried a Gamecube control, that changed my opinion.
 
yeah i still perfer the dreamcast controller over all others.. im not saying its the best, just the best for my hands.
 
Makes sense, actually...the DS2 was very uncomfortable when you had to use the analog sticks, IMO.

The X360 controller feels infinitely better. I thought the Gamecube controller felt pretty good as well, though it didn't feel sturdy.

steviep said:
The Wavebirds used some variety of BlueTooth, and they are still today (even with the X360 out) the best wireless controllers hands down, both for range, ease of use, playability, and battery life.

...because you own both so that you may compare, right :rolleyes:
 
Here's a third for the Dreamcast controllers....although it might change to the 360 controller once I get some more playtime on it. Hard to judge a controller based on the 45 seconds of racing before the error message pops up :rolleyes:
 
Ballz2TheWallz said:
horrible joystick, what about FPS's, why dont sony think of those

You don't think it'll be good for FPSs? Why? It looks pretty good to me, in the animation it shows that the controller was designed so you could easily use both analogs. That's the whole point of the boomerang design. What makes you think it isn't good fro FPSs, it looks a lot better to me for them than any other console controller that has ever been made.
 
hkhawk said:
You don't think it'll be good for FPSs? Why? It looks pretty good to me, in the animation it shows that the controller was designed so you could easily use both analogs. That's the whole point of the boomerang design. What makes you think it isn't good fro FPSs, it looks a lot better to me for them than any other console controller that has ever been made.
PS controllers analog sticks are the most unaccurate things ive ever touched
 
Ballz2TheWallz said:
PS controllers analog sticks are the most unaccurate things ive ever touched

Fair enough, hopefully these will be better.
 
the@ntipop said:
It looks like the position your hands are in when eating a very large hamburger...

*Cheap shot*

well.. i guess they're just making it much easier for us fat ass Americans to make the transistion from lunch to video games??
 
the@ntipop said:
It looks like the position your hands are in when eating a very large hamburger...

I dunno about you, but when I eat hamburgers, my thumbs are at the bottom, NOT the top.
 
hkhawk said:
The dual shock is awful, especially for big hands.
I never could understand that reasoning. I'm 6'5 with big hands and it's fine. Maybe people just mean 'fat' sausage hands.

I also wonder if people are holding the controller incorrectly, ie with two fingers on the shoulder buttons instead of one (each). That requires a drastically different orientation with little support. If people are using their indexes and second fingers for shoulders at the same time, no wonder they get cramps.
 
Nuzzles said:
Mouse and Keyboard support, maybe?
I've been saying for years that someone should come out with a thumb trackball in place of the right joystick.

There was a mockup of a concept someone was going to release next year, but it looked ridiculous, with a grossly oversized ball. What a way to ruin the idea.

For the time being I'm keeping my thumbs crossed.
 
Arkham said:
I never could understand that reasoning. I'm 6'5 with big hands and it's fine. Maybe people just mean 'fat' hands.

I also wonder if people are holding the controller incorrectly, ie with two fingers on the shoulder buttons instead of one (each). That requires a drastically different orientation with little support. If people are using their indexes and second fingers for shoulders at the same time, no wonder they get cramps.


no.. that's not my problem.. the reason it cramps my hands is because of the placement of the analog stick.. i have to reach so far for it.. it cramps up my hands.. they really should have swithced the analog stick with teh D-pad
 
Back
Top