Problems with EPoX 9NDA3+ and memory

FlipCody

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 28, 2003
Messages
249
I have just installed this mobo with a A64 3200+ (939 winchester). It is a great board but seems very finicky when it comes to memory. I know that the Athlon 64s are more touchy on memory. I have 2x512mb sticks of Corsair XMS 3200C2 (CMX512-3200) memory and I can not run them dual channel, they are only running at 333, and it only sees a total of 512mb of ram. These were not a matched pair, they were bought months apart. One is v2.2 and the other is v3.1.

While in CPU-Z I get odd readings on this memory. On the SPD tab it lists the dimms as follows:
v2.2 166 2/3/3/7 - 200 2.5/3/3/8
v3.1 200 3/3/3/8
According to Corsair I should be able to get 2.5, 3, 3, 6 with these sticks on an AMD CPU. Shouldn't I get these timings at 3200 (200)? It is weird that the one stick is being rated at 3 cas.

I have tried changing memory settings with no luck. I have tried all the dimm slot combinations. I have confirmed that all the dimm slots work and that both sticks work. Even though windows sees only 512mb I can see both sticks of the memory while in CPU-Z. If I have one stick in it runs at 200 and if 2 in at 167. I'm running the latest bios for the motherboard. These sticks ran dual channel on an ASUS A7N8X V2 Deluxe mobo.

Help! Any ideas?

Thanks!
 
The easy answer is that you're going to have problems anytime you use a mismatched pair and trying to run dual channel (especially with a "finicky" memory controller).

Are you sure that they are in the proper slots on the motherboard for dual channel operation?

I wouldn't worry about CPU-Z too much. It is just reporting what the RAM says about itself. What is more important is whether or not they will run at the matched speeds/timings you are trying to run them at. Since you ran them on your old board in dual channel, I'd imagine you should be able to do it again.
 
kirbyrj, Thanks for the reply. This mobo has 2 dual channels: Dual channel 1 is dimm slot 1 and 2 and dual channel 2 is dimm slot 3 and 4. The system will not even boot if I try putting the sticks in the dual channel dimm slots. The situation I was refering to in first post is when I try to run in single channel mode which on this mobo with 2 dimms means slot 1 and 3.

I have another 256mb 2700 stick of PNY memory and did some testing. It appears that when I have a stick in dimm slot 1 and dimm slot 3 (the only way to run non-dual channel) the system is only running the memory in dimm slot 3: when I have the 512mb Corsair stick in dimm slot 1 and the 256mb stick in dimm slot 3 the system only read 256mb of ram. I only have to go into the bios to see how much memory is being read.

I'm at a loss. I know the Corsair memory is not defective because I can run in other system (and in dual channel). There seems to be a problem with the memory controller in the CPU (as it is in A64) or a problem with the mobo. Anyone out there have any ideas or know how can I can figure out if cpu or mobo?

My thought was that if it was a problem with memory controller in CPU that I would see memory in the bios but not in Windows. Anyone have input on this theory? Anyone in here with this mobo that is running 2 dimms and different brands?

Thanks!
 
If your motherboard won't run dual channel without dying on you, then you have a problem. If you don't have a "true" dual channel set of RAM to test the dual channel capabilities, I'd RMA the board and try a new one.
 
I have the 3J version of this board and I ran into problems with my Corsair XMS3200. Purchased 2 sticks back in 03 so they're kind of old. Worked fine at default 200Mhz (1:1 divider). Does 2-3-3-6 at that speed, however it's officially listed on the Corsair site and the SPD as CL3 at DDR400.

Anyway, mine did in fact run fine in dual channel. The problem came when using a divider for the memory speed. At the 166 setting, I could only get it to POST at 156Mhz. At the 133 setting, it would do about 185Mhz. This was regardless of timings.

Mine wasn't defective either, since it ran just fine in my RDA+ nforce2 mobo.

Put in the Corsair value select I had ordered for my wife's rig, and it ran the dividers just fine at any HTT (up to 285...haven't tried to 300 yet) as long as the memory wasn't overclocked too far.

Of course, doesn't really explain the problem you're having with the DIMM slots and the missing memory. I simply think that these boards have issues with Corsair XMS memory. Strange, since I believe its one of the 4 "officially supported" memory types.
 
After reading your problems here I'm glad that I bought my OCZ Plat rev 2 along with my 9NDA3+. I've had no problems running at 320+ HTT on the 166 setting on my machine.
 
muddocktor said:
After reading your problems here I'm glad that I bought my OCZ Plat rev 2 along with my 9NDA3+. I've had no problems running at 320+ HTT on the 166 setting on my machine.

Why are you running at 166? What does 320+ HTT mean?

Thanks!
 
paladiin said:
I have the 3J version of this board and I ran into problems with my Corsair XMS3200. Purchased 2 sticks back in 03 so they're kind of old. Worked fine at default 200Mhz (1:1 divider). Does 2-3-3-6 at that speed, however it's officially listed on the Corsair site and the SPD as CL3 at DDR400.

Anyway, mine did in fact run fine in dual channel. The problem came when using a divider for the memory speed. At the 166 setting, I could only get it to POST at 156Mhz. At the 133 setting, it would do about 185Mhz. This was regardless of timings.

Mine wasn't defective either, since it ran just fine in my RDA+ nforce2 mobo.

Put in the Corsair value select I had ordered for my wife's rig, and it ran the dividers just fine at any HTT (up to 285...haven't tried to 300 yet) as long as the memory wasn't overclocked too far.

Of course, doesn't really explain the problem you're having with the DIMM slots and the missing memory. I simply think that these boards have issues with Corsair XMS memory. Strange, since I believe its one of the 4 "officially supported" memory types.

Were the sticks you bought in 03 a matched pair?

Where is this divider setting you are referring to?

When I went out to Corsair I thought they said it was rated at C2 on Intel C2.5 when on an AMD board.

Excuse my ignorance but what is HTT?

Thanks for you help!
 
i have this board, and when i tried 2 mismatched sticks it would only run @333. i am using latest factory bios (2/05 i think) so i guess its inherent in this model. i am using 2x pqi turbo 512mb tccd that were both bought from newegg about a week apart and have very close s/n. these work fine.
 
perp said:
i have this board, and when i tried 2 mismatched sticks it would only run @333. i am using latest factory bios (2/05 i think) so i guess its inherent in this model. i am using 2x pqi turbo 512mb tccd that were both bought from newegg about a week apart and have very close s/n. these work fine.

did it read all the memory? Like 1gb if you had 2 512mb sticks?

Thanks!
 
Anymore help out there?

I have tried a bunch more sticks of ram and system can never see more than one (though I can see both in cpu-z). The memory is fine ran memtest86+ with no issues.

If I was going to force the least aggresive memory timings what would they be? What is HTT that some of you mentioned? Are you referring to HyperTransport™ Technology? Could this impact this? What should I try relating to this?

Thanks for any help!
 
Back
Top