PROBLEM: grainy 30" LCD DELL wfp-hc

datacollector

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 28, 2007
Messages
128
Is it just me or does this monitor look really "grainy"? Maybe it is just me but I just got mine and it looks pretty "grainy" especially on the whites.. I think I'm going to go to the apple store and compare it with the Cinema HD and if its really a huge difference I'm going to return this.
 
Mine is very sharp, and clear. I can't be certain but it sounds like something is wrong with either yours, the cable or the video card.
 
I really dont know how to judge this.. I just went to the apple store and the cinema on display there looks slightly "grainy" too but mine is a bit more than theirs


EDIT: I should note that the standard skin for [H] looks really nice and crisp... but the white part i'm typing on is def not as crisp.
 
I really dont know how to judge this.. I just went to the apple store and the cinema on display there looks slightly "grainy" too but mine is a bit more than theirs


EDIT: I should note that the standard skin for [H] looks really nice and crisp... but the white part i'm typing on is def not as crisp.

The Apple displays in the stores are going to generally look bad as they are usually running at the wrong resolution and sometimes they are connected to machines that can't handle their native resolution. At least that's always been the case in the stores where I live.

I can't say for sure but you may be noticing what is generally referred to as the "screen door effect".
 
it was hooked up to a mac pro and the resolution seemed to be right though. Maybe calling dell and asking to return it and then compare? I have no dead pixels though... so if it is something that is standard across all monitors could I just keep my old one...
 
Okay I'll try, what settings should I use and what resolution would be ideal (for the camera)?

Also, it is quite noticeable when I am like < 1ft away. It also becomes more apparent when I bump the brightness all the way. Lastly, I know the quality on my old 19" (non wide Dell) is much better when it comes to whites.

For some reason my eyes are sort of adjusting to this "weird" grainy effect. I mean text is pretty clear but the white is just like grainy like..
 
Grainy on white is the famous Dell anti-glare coating, better get used to it.
 
Yeah - mine is too. It's got that look like there is a thin layer of sparkle dust on the front. Considering returning it, but it is just so nice and BIG!
 
That grainy look is the anti-glare coating. Every non-glossy S-IPS panel I've seen has the same grainy/sparkly/dusty anti-glare coating, including the Apple displays. H-IPS panels have a milder coating, so maybe you should consider the Planar PX2611W. It's not as big, but it has a wide-gamut IPS panel like the Dell.
 
The max.. 2650 x 1600. Well I considered returning it only because I thought something was wrong with it.. but I got used to it now.. I just dont see why dell added that crazy stuff to it. Don't get me wrong... this monitor is so nice.. but I was just concerned that I might have gotten a defective unit.
 
As Toasty said, its not Dell, they all have it. Its one of the reasons some folks like glossy screens. They do it because it generally is better for most office lighting. Where as a glossy screen reflects and is more prone to issues with lighting.

Business applications still drive a lot of the market.
 
Also, it is quite noticeable when I am like < 1ft away. It also becomes more apparent when I bump the brightness all the way.


wow, less than 1 foot away on a 30 inch monitor...


have fun being blind when you are older, seriously man, you bought the wrong monitor
 
As Toasty said, its not Dell, they all have it. Its one of the reasons some folks like glossy screens. They do it because it generally is better for most office lighting. Where as a glossy screen reflects and is more prone to issues with lighting.

Business applications still drive a lot of the market.

I can't stand glare on my monitors. I've got a glossy screen on one of my laptops and using it in office enviroments sucks.
 
I wouldn't want a gloss on a laptop that I would be taking out in daylight and such. But after I saw photos with lighter areas like light dresses and skies etc. I don't like anti-glare on desktop monitor. AG makes pics look like they are being viewed through dusty glass. Lol the first time I realized what AG was was after I tried "dusting" LCD off and nothing moved.
 
wow, less than 1 foot away on a 30 inch monitor...


have fun being blind when you are older, seriously man, you bought the wrong monitor

Sorry for the confusion.. I meant if I get that close than I can notice it right away.. I dont think i can even use a monitor that big at such close proximity. I am at least 2ft from it at all times.
 
Mine is very sharp, and clear. I can't be certain but it sounds like something is wrong with either yours, the cable or the video card.

BTW: could you maybe take a picture of yours at a really high res? or at least compare like notepad opened next to something like this forum?

It is not really grainy.. more like "dusty" .. could you get really close to your monitor and examine to see if you see this too? Or is it so sharp that you cant tell at all? Looking at my macbook pro screen I can slightly tell but it is def more on the 30"

And to verify, you have the HC version correct?
 
BTW: could you maybe take a picture of yours at a really high res? or at least compare like notepad opened next to something like this forum?

It is not really grainy.. more like "dusty" .. could you get really close to your monitor and examine to see if you see this too? Or is it so sharp that you cant tell at all? Looking at my macbook pro screen I can slightly tell but it is def more on the 30"

And to verify, you have the HC version correct?

Mine is the standard 3007WFP, not the 3007WFP-HC.
 
It is not really grainy.. more like "dusty" .. could you get really close to your monitor and examine to see if you see this too? Or is it so sharp that you cant tell at all? Looking at my macbook pro screen I can slightly tell but it is def more on the 30"

And to verify, you have the HC version correct?

Yeah, I definitely seem to have this problem too with my 3007WFP-HC... a kind of glittery, dusty surface that is especially noticeable on solid colored backgrounds. At first it did kind of bother me, but I was able to get used to it after a few days.

Actually, I'm now bothered a bit more by the unevenness in the backlight. On a white background, I notice that one side of the display seems a little brighter than the other, enough to make that side look a little yellow in comparison to a more bluish tint in some of the darker areas. Not sure if this common to all 3007 displays or if I have a panel that shows this defect more than what is normal.
 
Yeah, I definitely seem to have this problem too with my 3007WFP-HC... a kind of glittery, dusty surface that is especially noticeable on solid colored backgrounds. At first it did kind of bother me, but I was able to get used to it after a few days.

Actually, I'm now bothered a bit more by the unevenness in the backlight. On a white background, I notice that one side of the display seems a little brighter than the other, enough to make that side look a little yellow in comparison to a more bluish tint in some of the darker areas. Not sure if this common to all 3007 displays or if I have a panel that shows this defect more than what is normal.

Thanks a lot.. so it must actually be the anti-glare coating =-P... I think I notice it less and less now.

Dan thanks for clarifying that as the wfp is known to not have that problem mainly because it doesnt really have that new coating dell used on the HC.
 
The original Dell 3007WFP does have that problem. All non-glossy S-IPS panels have the same coating. It's not a Dell thing.
 
Back
Top