potentially dieing hard drive?

zrikz

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
May 29, 2006
Messages
1,228
Just bought a Seagate Barracuda 7200.12 ST31000528AS 1TB about 2 weeks ago and I kept trying to play some steam games, which I have installed on it now and they kept stuttering and freezing. Now all of a sudden its clicking, or at least I believe its that hard drive.

I downloaded seagate seatools and it doesn't detect it for some reason, so I'm just backing up the little data that I have on it. Is there a way to test it? I opened up everest and did disk stress test and one of my 4 drives started clicking like crazy but they are all together in a rack so its hard to determine which one it is.

I guess I could individually pull the power out of them on boot up and see which one stops clicking?

I'm guessing the easiest way would be to return this to newegg rather than contact seagate, pretty sure newegg harddrive return policy is 30 days.

/edit - transferring data it stopped clicking again?
 
Could this have been an overheating problem? I took the hd rack out of my case and have it sitting on my desk, outside of the case. Earlier the HD's were pretty damn hot, now they are just pretty warm. I'm now doing the everest disk stress test and there appears to be no sounds, going to give steam a try now and see if the games are playable.
 
well, going to try one last thing and format it and then put new data on it and see if it runs at all, otherwise I guess I will RMA it with newegg tomorrow.

Ran TF2 for about 20 minutes and then it kept stuttering and then froze, now it doesn't last more than 60 seconds playing before it freezes.
 
is that one of the seagate drives that was shipped with a bad firmware? ive tried western digital and hitachi and i like both.
 
No he has a 12 series. I would say its just a bad drive and I would send it back and RMA it for sure. I'd also test ALL of the drives and make sure they are all working good. Cooling could be a issue and if they are in a rack setup try and see if you can get some active cooling on the drives, believe me that does help a lot. Some Seagates do tend to run warm on their own, let alone with 3 other drives. The newer Seagate drives aren't as bad, but again they are with 3 other drives so I would most definitely get some active cooling if you don't have it already. Hope this helps.
 
Back
Top