Possible to run 2 different branded raid cards in same system?

sonofander

Gawd
Joined
Jan 7, 2007
Messages
1,000
I am running an Areca 1230 in my file server and I am looking to expand.

Would it be possible to add a Perc 5 to this system or do I need to add another Areca card?

What are the possible problems I face if I mix and match raid cards if there are any?
 
Is it possible? Yes.
Is it recommended? No. PERC5's have a very bad habit of insisting on being bootable, forcing any other controller out of the way if there is not enough room in OROM. There are still Int13h implications as well, contrary to what others might believe. You should instead replace the Areca with one with more channels. Long term, it's the better and saner option.
 
My Perc 5 likes to push and shove, it made me have to turn off my boards esata to work properly.
 
Why not just get two percs and kick the areca out. The areca can fetch you more money than it cost to buy the percs.
 
Is it possible? Yes.
Is it recommended? No. PERC5's have a very bad habit of insisting on being bootable, forcing any other controller out of the way if there is not enough room in OROM. There are still Int13h implications as well, contrary to what others might believe. You should instead replace the Areca with one with more channels. Long term, it's the better and saner option.

I couldn't agree more.
 
Thanks for the feedback guys!
I guess I'll avoid the per and look for another areca then.
 
Well I'm in a Norco so I'd like to have at least 20 ports to fill it out. I have the arc-1230 now which gives me 12 needing 8 more. The damn 24 port arecas are 1k and I'm thinking an additional 1220 would be the cheapest way to fill out my remaining 8 drive bays
 
Well I'm in a Norco so I'd like to have at least 20 ports to fill it out. I have the arc-1230 now which gives me 12 needing 8 more. The damn 24 port arecas are 1k and I'm thinking an additional 1220 would be the cheapest way to fill out my remaining 8 drive bays

This is true. Though the 24 port would give you future expanability and it would be an easier configuration to work with.
 
This is true. Though the 24 port would give you future expanability and it would be an easier configuration to work with.

The 24 port is what I would recommend as well. If it were less ports, I would recommend pairing LSI's. They're the only controller out there that's actually designed for pairing. But there are too few motherboards with the PCIe bus to handle triple MegaRAID SAS 8888's.
 
The 24 port is what I would recommend as well. If it were less ports, I would recommend pairing LSI's. They're the only controller out there that's actually designed for pairing. But there are too few motherboards with the PCIe bus to handle triple MegaRAID SAS 8888's.

Additionally many "gaming" or other consumer motherboards have quite a few issues with LSI cards. Mainly in relation to using high end GPUs and LSI's together. (I know this all too well.)
 
Well I'm in a Norco so I'd like to have at least 20 ports to fill it out. I have the arc-1230 now which gives me 12 needing 8 more. The damn 24 port arecas are 1k and I'm thinking an additional 1220 would be the cheapest way to fill out my remaining 8 drive bays

For the cost of 24 port cards you may as well buy a chassis with a SAS expander backplane and a SAS card with a low port count.

I.E. http://supermicro.com/products/chassis/4U/846/SC846E1-R900.cfm
 
Additionally many "gaming" or other consumer motherboards have quite a few issues with LSI cards. Mainly in relation to using high end GPUs and LSI's together. (I know this all too well.)

Yeah, did you ever get that sorted? It should have been fixed a while back. If not, let me know, I can poke some people.

Also, SAS Expanders are bad on most cards. You have to be absolutely unquestionably positive that the SAS Expander and endpoints are fully supported by the RAID card in that specific configuration. Most RAID cards explicitly do not support SAS expanders. The whole protocol is too new, and too twitchy in some ways, still.
I would still strongly recommend a single card with more ports. You'll get better performance anyways.
 
Yeah, did you ever get that sorted? It should have been fixed a while back. If not, let me know, I can poke some people.

Also, SAS Expanders are bad on most cards. You have to be absolutely unquestionably positive that the SAS Expander and endpoints are fully supported by the RAID card in that specific configuration. Most RAID cards explicitly do not support SAS expanders. The whole protocol is too new, and too twitchy in some ways, still.
I would still strongly recommend a single card with more ports. You'll get better performance anyways.

I never did. I ended up pulling the LSI from my system. With dual Geforce GTX 280's, or even 4870 X2's I couldn't boot from any array attached to the card. I just got sick of messing with it. Primarily that machine is used for gaming so I don't need it. Since I've got a Core i7 for gaming my Skulltrail is going to be moved into a server role where I can better leverage the CPU power. The RAID card will go back in. I never had issues working with it and a single Geforce GTX 280 which is what's in there now. (Overkill I know, but I had a spare and my gaming rig already has three of them installed.) One issue I also had with the setup was in regard to overclocking. The Skulltrail board + Overclocking + LSI MegaRAID=BAD. I ended up corrupting the array everytime I OC'ed the system by even a fairly small amount. I am not even know why as I was only overclocking with multiplier adjustments. The system was stable when I used the onboard RAID controller, but screwy with the MegaRAID.
 
I never did. I ended up pulling the LSI from my system. With dual Geforce GTX 280's, or even 4870 X2's I couldn't boot from any array attached to the card. I just got sick of messing with it. Primarily that machine is used for gaming so I don't need it. Since I've got a Core i7 for gaming my Skulltrail is going to be moved into a server role where I can better leverage the CPU power. The RAID card will go back in. I never had issues working with it and a single Geforce GTX 280 which is what's in there now. (Overkill I know, but I had a spare and my gaming rig already has three of them installed.) One issue I also had with the setup was in regard to overclocking. The Skulltrail board + Overclocking + LSI MegaRAID=BAD. I ended up corrupting the array everytime I OC'ed the system by even a fairly small amount. I am not even know why as I was only overclocking with multiplier adjustments. The system was stable when I used the onboard RAID controller, but screwy with the MegaRAID.

The overclocking question is an easy one. The MegaRAIDs are designed with very tight tolerances, because the processors on the cards? They are running multiples of bus speed. Meaning, yes, overclocking the bus most likely overclocks the card's processor. (In other words, Skulltrail has a sloppy PCIe bus lock or none at all.) End result? Corruption, of course. I'd have to see it on a bus analyzer to tell you whether there's something on the bus side, or the card side.

The reason for the GTX's and MegaRAID not working is because nVidia, frankly, produces absolute crap. There's no doubt at all that they were blustering and bullying their way through the OROM and forcing everything else out. I've seen them dropkick PXE, which should have priority. ATI can be kinder, but the X2's? Yeah, forget it. They need huge chunks of OROM and addressable space. If the MegaRAID can't get enough OROM or addressable space, it just won't work. You can get it working by disabling INT13H and boot support, sometimes. ISTR us going through something similar like, a year or two back, where someone was having OROM woes preventing booting from another MegaRAID? Might be misremembering though, it's late.
 
Back
Top