Portege M200/M205 ?

MisterDNA

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Feb 8, 2004
Messages
1,058
Anyone have one of these? I was considering an M400, but I'm not going to be caught dead using something with integrated graphics for 3D work.

I'm wondering about the viewing angle in both clamshell and tablet modes, the hinge durability, 3D performance, digitizer lag, heat, and basically everything else worth mentioning.

While I'd rather have dual-core, the M200/M205 should be fine as it won't be my main system. I just want to know if it's a system I'll be replacing in a matter of months when the hinge goes to shit or if it will serve me well for years to come.

Getting accustomed to a touchpad is going to be hard...
 
My fiancee has an M200, and I've played with it a lot.

1. The viewing angle is...not the best. You pretty much have to be right it front of it. It's way worse than my Gateway tablet. I mostly notice it when it's in tablet mode.
2. The hinge is extremely durable.
3. "3D performance" is a bit of a misnomer. You do know this has a Geforce Go5200, right? And that the 5200 is one of the worst graphics cards ever? Also, it only has 32 megs of RAM built in and can't share from main memory for extra. My Intel GMA X3100 is waaaay faster.
4. There is NO digitizer lag. It is perfect.
5. It runs very quiet and cool.


Basically it's a great little tablet, but I don't know if I would reccomend it for "3D work." It's a bit on the slow side for something like that. Also worth mentioning is the lack of a built in optical drive. Let me know if you have any more questions!
 
I have a couple of Toshiba tablets, the R15 and the R25. I upgraded the R25 to Vista Premium, added 4GB of RAM and a 200GB 7200RPM hard drive. It runs pretty well. The only real hardware/durability issue I’ve had with it is dust getting under the top cover over the screen/digitizer. Every now and then I have to take off the top cover to get rid little specks of dust here and there. I never had that problem with the R15. The hinge on both machines is very sturdy and I’ve not had a problem in 18 months with the R25 and two years with the R15.

You might want to look at the Toshiba M700 tablet; it just came out and had Intel X3100 graphics, which should be fine for anything besides high end 3D apps and games.
 
I actually purchased the M200 last year and I have been liking it.

Toshiba's power management software is pretty good, with it on it runs pretty cool and has a decent battery life (chances are you will be buying this used, so your mileage will depend how old the battery is). The processor mine has is a 1.5ghz Pentium M which has done a fine job with general web browsing, office stuff, etc and I have even played some UT 2004 (runs pretty well on medium-ish settings) but I do not know about your 3d work. You can forget about any high definition video. No input lag (I love the pen, it is my first tablet). The hinge on mine seems a little squeaky yet sturdy. I like the keyboard (as far as keyboards for 12" laptops go.) Some discoloration on the silver lid.

The screen is not too great. The thing is about 5 years old and it shows; ALTHOUGH it has one of the best pixel densities you will find anywhere (1400x1050, I love toshiba for that I just wish there were more today with that resolution. Can you believe that most tablets have a 768 vertical resolution? How am I supposed to even properly fit web pages when in portrait mode?.) Any tablet you get will be a little grainy, but this even gets washed out at angles I typically write at which is not too great for a tablet. I can barely see the screen in sunlight.

Since you will be buying this used, also consider possible expenses such as new hard drive and battery because you do not know what you will be getting. I would actually recommend either the HP Pavilion tx2000 or Gateway C-140X over the outdated m200. Both are relatively inexpensive. The Gateway in particular is 14", dual core, and has an option for dedicated graphics.
 
That the graphics on the M400 are integrated does not mean they are inferior to whatever's in the ancient M200, only less glamorous. The GMA950 and GeForce 5200 Go shouldn't be too far apart in performance terms, and the other benefits of the newer M400 probably outweigh whatever small advantage the 5200 confers. As mentioned above, you would be still better off with the M700 and its Intel X3100 graphics, but even this is only cutting-edge in the company of the 5200 Go and the GMA950.

None of these will be good for intensive 3D work. If this is for something professional, I'd recommend allocating a bigger budget.
 
The M400 and M200 being equal in terms of graphics performance would be laughable, considering the M400 goes for around $1100 on ebay whereas the M200 can be had for $450 to your doorstep.

The M700 would be good, but I'd have to wait and find some jackass selling theirs to make rent or whatever because that's just too damned expensive.

I'm not wanting a tablet for intensive 3D work. I've got my Alienware rig for that. The idea is to have something I can do rough work on while away from the big guns. AutoCAD, 3dsmax, PhotoShop, etc. I'm an XNA developer in my free time so it's mostly game related work, not mechanical engineering. The reason for a tablet is I'd rather have that than spend a fortune on a Wacom Cintiq.

It is because of this that I am looking more in the direction of the M200. It's cheap, isn't faster than the gear I already have, and doesn't have a screwed up aspect ratio. The m700 just fails for that. I'd rather draw on a fat A4 sheet than a Lilliputian Legal pad.

But, all the same, having an LED backlight has been a dream of mine for a long time, especially since upgrading from my Treo 650 to a Centro. No high voltages, less heat, longer lifetime, better efficiency, no flicker...

I remember years ago there was an [H] member who was selling a Toshiba tablet that had had the GPU upgraded to a Quadro with 128MB RAM. I think it was a Tecra M4, but I am not sure at all. I can't search that far back, either, since the archives only go a year back.
 
Back
Top