Pondering a new comp hardware purchase. Comments?

agrikk

Gawd
Joined
Apr 16, 2002
Messages
933
I'm building a second computer for gaming to replace my main computer, which will become a part of my dedicated recording studio:

AMD Athlon 64 4000+
ASUS A8N-SLI
2GB Kingston ValuRAM
ASUS EN7900GT
Samsung 204B 20" LCD Monitor
NEC 16x DVD-RW ND-3550A
Antec TruePower TPII-550

I will be receiving a PPU Card in the near future.


I'm still debating going the dual-core path but I just don't see paying the premium for a performance hit in single-threaded applications and the scarcity of multithreaded apps. I think it's just too early to buy a dual-core CPU for gaming.

Ditto for SLI. Two 7800 8x cards might out perform a single 7900 16x card, but not by much and not enough to justify shelling out that kind of wood.

Thoughts?

What do you think?
 
What do you mean, a hit in singlethreaded apps? Link to info? I think that's of the past now.

I think that dual-core is the way of the future, and there is no good reason not to go dual-core unless you have a REALLY good reason not to; gaming? Games are mostly limited by RAM or GPU nowadays, not the CPU AFAIK.
 
..and I think the 4000+ is overpriced. I'd pick up a 3500+ and make due with a couple hundred less MHz and overclock the sucker...or just make due with adding a couple seconds here and there for whatever stuff you do.

Your last statement on SLI is almost contradictory though...because you're getting an SLI motherboard. :confused: Don't want to shell the case for SLI, why pick up an SLI mobo in the first place? Might as well save a couple bucks..

Actually...come to think of it. If you're going to oc, then you would've got performance RAM. So nevermind the overclocking..
 
General Crespin said:
What do you mean, a hit in singlethreaded apps? Link to info? I think that's of the past now.

I think that dual-core is the way of the future, and there is no good reason not to go dual-core unless you have a REALLY good reason not to; gaming? Games are mostly limited by RAM or GPU nowadays, not the CPU AFAIK.

I found this link on Tom's Hardware and compared a single core Athlon 64 3800+ with a dual-core Athlon 64 X2 3800+ here. It's running Doom III at 12x10 which is where I'll be running it. The single core processor runs 3 FPS faster.

I have no multithreaded applications that will be running on this box, so I wondered why I should pay a little bit extra for a processor that runs single threaded apps slower.


gwai lo said:
..and I think the 4000+ is overpriced. I'd pick up a 3500+ and make due with a couple hundred less MHz and overclock the sucker...or just make due with adding a couple seconds here and there for whatever stuff you do.

Your last statement on SLI is almost contradictory though...because you're getting an SLI motherboard. :confused: Don't want to shell the case for SLI, why pick up an SLI mobo in the first place? Might as well save a couple bucks..

Actually...come to think of it. If you're going to oc, then you would've got performance RAM. So nevermind the overclocking..

Very astute Gwai. No, I won't be overclocking. The reason I picked this motherboard is reviews saying that it's single-instance video running at 16x performed better than some other boards. The ASUS A8N-E is also a consideration for $15-20 cheaper.
 
Because the ability to run Oblivion in a window, QuickBooks Pro 2005, a 40MB Exel spreadsheet, and run an anti-virus scan at the same time is all very nice. Very, very nice.
 
agrikk said:
I found this link on Tom's Hardware and compared a single core Athlon 64 3800+ with a dual-core Athlon 64 X2 3800+ here. It's running Doom III at 12x10 which is where I'll be running it. The single core processor runs 3 FPS faster.

I have no multithreaded applications that will be running on this box, so I wondered why I should pay a little bit extra for a processor that runs single threaded apps slower.




Very astute Gwai. No, I won't be overclocking. The reason I picked this motherboard is reviews saying that it's single-instance video running at 16x performed better than some other boards. The ASUS A8N-E is also a consideration for $15-20 cheaper.

the extra 3fps are from the 400mhz quicker the 3800+ is over the x23800 if theyre the same speed i think theyd perform the same
 
General Crespin said:
Because the ability to run Oblivion in a window, QuickBooks Pro 2005, a 40MB Exel spreadsheet, and run an anti-virus scan at the same time is all very nice. Very, very nice.

I'm sure it is, but that's not my style. If I'm gaming, I'm gaming. If I'm cooking the books, I'm cooking the books. And how much processing power does Quicken 2005 need, anyhow? :D

Besides, I have multiple computers, and will have one more by the time this is through. So if I ever need to I can KVM between games and work.
 
agrikk said:
The single core processor runs 3 FPS faster.

I have no multithreaded applications that will be running on this box, so I wondered why I should pay a little bit extra for a processor that runs single threaded apps slower.

If you can see the difference between +/- 3 FPS, you're kidding yourself. That's error margin right there.

I take it you are using WinXP? Then in itself you are running a huge multi-threaded app. Or let's say you are not a Windoze type of guy and are using Linux. That's even moreso multithreaded. It's in your BEST INTERESTS to get a dual core proc. Once you get and experience using one, you'll never go back.
 
General Crespin said:
Well, if you're set on single core, I guess nothing I say will change your mind. :)

Actually, I'm not set on it at all. :D

Obviously dual-core is the Next Big Thing because I'm not seeing any single core plans from either AMD or Intel. I have a couple of SMP machines, both at home and at work and I think they're the smoothest ride ever.

What I'm asking for is a discussion about whether or not it's worth moving to dual core right now or wait a while and buy a single core speed demon for gaming in the meanwhile.
 
agrikk said:
Obviously dual-core is the Next Big Thing because I'm not seeing any single core plans from either AMD or Intel. I have a couple of SMP machines, both at home and at work and I think they're the smoothest ride ever.

What I'm asking for is a discussion about whether or not it's worth moving to dual core right now or wait a while and buy a single core speed demon for gaming in the meanwhile.

You just proved what I was telling you in my previous post. The cost difference between a single and a dual core processor is not so much as to draw you away from making the change, at least on the Intel side. Whether or not the CPU is HT or actually dual core, you still get the same type of functionality: SMP. I don't know about the prices on the other side (AMD), but I think it's safe to say you'd be better off just getting a dual core CPU. I understand that we gamers change our systems as often as the weather changes, but it'll still get you longevity over a single core processor.
 
Dammit. I've just thrown together a new system including a X2 4200+ for $1700 on NewEgg.

This all started with buying a processor and RAM for a motherboard I had around, and now here I am seriously considering a whole new rig for a whole lot more. Double dammit.
 
Back
Top