Poll Worst MainBoard Ever Vote now.

lopoetve

Extremely [H]
2FA
Joined
Oct 11, 2001
Messages
34,263
Originally posted by Tyklfe
I had a Giga GA-7VAXP, and I just updated to the latest bios and I can finally run 24 hour sessions of Prime 95 without crashing! w00t!


My vote goes to the ASUS A7M-266. Truely shitty AMD chipset.
A7M? That was the AMD 760, the first DDR mobo... it was the fastest for a long time. I had a good many of those, and they rocked. It took Via 2 tries to catch up...
 
Originally posted by E4g1e
Oh, the worst motherboard that I've bought was *cough* *gag* *choke* an Intel VC820 motherboard! That F-ing piece-of-crap mobo - which dated back to the earliest days of Intel's official support of a 133MHz FSB on a Pentium III CPU - used RDRAM (which was ASTRONOMICALLY expensive in those days) that the PIII couldn't take any advantage whatsoever of! And for that price its performance (at a 100MHz FSB speed) is no better overall than a motherboard based on the old faithful 440BX chipset. Worse, I had trouble getting into its BIOS the first few times I used that mobo; the crappy-looking logo obscured what was going on during POST for a mere two seconds - and then the OS began booting up! I would have needed a rapid trigger-finger just to get into the VC820's BIOS. Worst of all it had faulty LPT (parallel) port hardware.

I wish I would have stuck with BX for a while longer while awaiting for my current AMD-based setup, instead of buying into the Rambust/PIII pile of s***.

I made that statement over a year ago. But today I'm finding all three of my AMD-processor-based motherboards to be a big, steaming pile, as well. My current Asus A7V333 has been having intermittent problems with the IDE ports, particularly the primary IDE channel. My previous Abit KR7A-133 had problems with its floppy port - and I needed a floppy drive in order to install the OS that I was using at the time that I had the board. And the ECS K7S5A that I had also had problems with its temperature sensor, measuring much higher than what the BIOS read.

Three AMD-based motherboards with some problems, plus the fact that I cannot use a slower, quieter PSU fan correctly with any of those three mobos (the PSU fans in my Antec TruControl 550 PSU are the loudest fans that are currently in my system, and I must have the fans at full speed all the time), make me want to move back to the 'dark side' (read: heading back to Intel-processor-based systems).

By the way, I want the most stable, rock-solid system with no lock-ups or crashes at all whatsoever - even if those traits mean sacrificing all tweakability whatsoever.
 
i have to cast my vote to the MSI K7N2. it's gotta be the most unstable board i've ever seen in my life. RMA'd 3 of them and i'm sending off another very soon.
 
I've never had too many problems with motherboards, I've built 3 comps with giga-byte, and while initially there was some stability problems, a little added voltage and they were rock solid :) Asus and Intel are pretty good also, those are usually the three companies I go with. I think the main problem with motherboards in general, is that early revisions just tend to be crappy, it always kind of bothers me that early boards are like "beta" versions in a sense, and the buyers are almost like "beta testers". Only the buyer is paying for unrevised hardware.
 
Originally posted by eraser_16
i have to cast my vote to the MSI K7N2. it's gotta be the most unstable board i've ever seen in my life. RMA'd 3 of them and i'm sending off another very soon.

That gets my vote too. No board has ever given me so much grief in my life:mad:
 
I have and currently use an ASUS p599VM which I think is a pre- p5A?

Anywho, I have been using this board for almost 3 yrs and it has been rather good to me. Aside from being wayyyy outdated, it seems as if it was a goo dboard in its day.
 
Originally posted by eraser_16
i have to cast my vote to the MSI K7N2. it's gotta be the most unstable board i've ever seen in my life. RMA'd 3 of them and i'm sending off another very soon.

I gave my sister a K7N2 Delta-L on October 25 of last year (along with a 2500+ and a pair of Kingston ValueRAM 256MB DDR333 modules), and the system hasn't been rebooted for any reason other than Windows XP updates since that day.
 
...I would have to say the worst motherboard is that motherboard that didnt work for me ..that motherboard that died on me ...that motherboard that lets you install everything and says "hey, I'm ok!" ...only to randomly lock up on you seemingly without rhyme or reason ...

older via chipset mobos
ECS K7S5A
Asus A7N8X
Asus A7V8x
Soyo Dragon Ultra KT333
Giga-byte GA-7VRXP

..to name a few
 
The sis530 chipset it would have to go down in history as the most annoying piece of shit motherboard EVER invented i shudder to even think of the 2 unplesent years i spent on one of these:eek:
 
Originally posted by evildre
I've been running one 24/7 for the past 3 years without a problem ... it has been serving web pages like a champ :D

Ditto
 
I'll be the next one to recommend the Abit KT7A as the worst Mainboard ever. I'd nominate Abit as a whole when it comes to "Worst" and "Mainboard" considering that just about every Abit I've ever seen had problems that boarderline on "How the hell did this get past testing?", but I only owned a KT7A, and let me tell you it's the last time I buy an Abit Product.

This thing actually made me sit down and ask myself if I was losing my touch in system building, that is until I bought an MSI k7n420 and all my problems went away. That and they finally fixed the bios after 9 months of hell.

Speaking of Bios, for folks that still have one of these things, Try flashing the BIOS to the latest Version you can. It seems to fix a majority of the problems that this board had with crashes and makes the board stable (I ran a CS server non stop at 100% load for a week on a KT7A. The Fact that it was up a week even though that's low is an achievement for this Board.) Although That doesn't excuse Abit considering it took them 9 months to release a stable bios for this thing. If the bios doesn't work and your still getting crashes well at least you tried.
 
Originally posted by Almost Anyone With A Statistically Insignificant Sample Size
I'd nominate <insert company> as a whole when it comes to "Worst" and "Mainboard" considering that just about every <insert company> I've ever seen had problems that boarderline on "How the hell did this get past testing?", but I only owned a <insert product>, and let me tell you it's the last time I buy an <insert company> Product.
Unless you're building on huge scales (i.e. hundreds of boards, spread across a long time span), blanket statements are not only useless, but unfounded. Another way to qualify is to be one of a member of a huge majority of users of Company X's products who are dissatisfied.

(PCChips generally gets the Golden Raspberry by the latter means; nobody in their right mind uses PCChips boards for more than one or two builds. ;))

I highly doubt that anyone here goes through enough boards to be qualified for a statement like, say, Deathlizard's. I know I'm not. And people who do meet the requirements for a statement like that will agree with me.

That said, the KT7A was a pretty gimp motherboard. I still say that
 
Originally posted by Almost Anyone With A Statistically Insignificant Sample Size
I'd nominate <insert company> as a whole when it comes to "Worst" and "Mainboard" considering that just about every <insert company> I've ever seen had problems that boarderline on "How the hell did this get past testing?", but I only owned a <insert product>, and let me tell you it's the last time I buy an <insert company> Product.

Well, I agree with you, Stiletto One.

Furthermore, <insert [H]ard member>, if you say that the <insert motherboard brand/model> sucks, it sucks to you - and not necessarily anyone else. So quit rubbing your "don't buy the <insert mainboard>" campaign into the whole forum.
 
Originally posted by Stiletto One
Unless you're building on huge scales (i.e. hundreds of boards, spread across a long time span), blanket statements are not only useless, but unfounded.
The statement that I made, as well as statements of other people in this thread are of their personal experiences. Pure and simple. Regardelss of what they are saying, they had a bad experience with the board and in the end it can be counted and an statistic can be drawn from it. Just because I've built 1 board doesn't change my opinion that the board was crap, Therefore its valid in the contex of this thread, which was "your nomination for worst mainboard ever".

Originally posted by Stiletto One
I highly doubt that anyone here goes through enough boards to be qualified for a statement like, say, Deathlizard's.
Again, My statement was based on my personal experience. If I wanted to get really technicial in why I would nominate Abit overall...

KT7A - Hard OS Crash when Doing Heavy IDE Transfers resulting in unreccoverable hard disk corruption, Unstable under heavy system load, ETC.
BX133-Raid - Would Not boot from Raid, normal ATA, CD-Rom. Barely Booted From Floppy. RMA'D, Returned DOA, RMA'D Again. Third one finally would install an OS but was somewhat unstable.
VP6 - unstable, Blown Caps. RMA'D, Blown Again, RMA'D Again. Still running on that one but expecting the caps to blow on it.

I know that there's much more than this, but its been over two years since I worked with an abit outside of my KT7A and my Friend's VP6, and honestly, out of all of the Aopen, ASUS, Intel and MSI boards I've build or serviced over the last 4 years, which would be in excess over 500, I've never had to RMA any of them including an Aopen AX6BC that took a lightning hit and took out just about everything except the board and hard drive, which both worked fine and broke a three month uptime after the hit. I can't say the same for Abit, PcChips, or whatever board they put in the older compaq athlon towers.
 
Originally posted by evildre
I gave my sister a K7N2 Delta-L on October 25 of last year (along with a 2500+ and a pair of Kingston ValueRAM 256MB DDR333 modules), and the system hasn't been rebooted for any reason other than Windows XP updates since that day.

sure, if you have RAM that's on the approved list, go ahead, get one, but don't try it with RAM it wont accept like i did. (my point being, you shouldn't have to have approved ram except for the speed and size specs for the motherboard)
 
Via P4PB. Definitely sucked a lot. In my experience, windows 2000 is NEVER supposed to have a hard freeze. I can tell you that after having the board for a few months, I got tired of having daily hard freezes and I got myself a new intel D875PBZ board, and never looked back.

That fucking board even screwed up a hard drive and I had to low level format that thing numerous times with my new board for it to even work right. Ugh. Fuck you VIA.
 
My vote goes to the Acer AP53. The name is etched into my memory for the rest of my life. It was the bane of all who worked in tech support at my college. If there was a tech call about a dead computer, you guessed it - it was the AP53. Replacing the board and setting up all the jumpers was a pain. We had about 4 different boards in use at that time and it certainly was the worst at our school. By revision 3 they worked out most of the problems. But the Revision 1....a nightmare. Piece of crap
 
Originally posted by Stiletto One
Unless you're building on huge scales (i.e. hundreds of boards, spread across a long time span), blanket statements are not only useless, but unfounded. Another way to qualify is to be one of a member of a huge majority of users of Company X's products who are dissatisfied.

My statement regarding the ECS P6S5AT still stands, seeing how hundreds have gone through my workplace :D Sure, it may have been 350 or 400 boards ... but that is hundreds :D
 
Well, I've had a MSI K7 PRO die on me, as well as (presumably) a ABIT KA7-100...well it was either the processor or the board with the ABIT, but i replaced both so it doesn't really matter...I Try to stay away from MSI boards...i like ABIT and ASUS myself...but to do my dually i went GIGABYTE....
 
i had an ECS and the USB's and sound got glitchy after about half a year
thats whay you call relaibility:rolleyes:
 
I don't know what time frame you are all talking about.. but back a while ago I bought a Chaintech 7AJA2E. had no thing but problems with it before it just stopped working completly.
 
Well i have to nominate ASUS A7N8X, not because they ran with problems but because they didn't boot at all after a couple of hours due
to the BIOS issues.

A word of simpathy to Jetway, i´ve had a few n zero problems with them.
 
Originally posted by zArt
Well i have to nominate ASUS A7N8X, not because they ran with problems but because they didn't boot at all after a couple of hours due
to the BIOS issues.

A word of simpathy to Jetway, i´ve had a few n zero problems with them.
Blame nVidia for those BIOS issues—Asus isn't the only company by any stretch of imagination with BIOS death problems.
 
I might be lucky, but I love my ECS K7S5A... A friend has one too, and he likes it as well. I would venture to guess that their quality is VERY bad, so we must have lucked out and gotten the two that worked right.

Back to topic: FIC can suck it. They are HORRIBLE. Had a number of boards from them that were bad. Their tech support is down right garbage. They won't even RMA without charging the customer $20.

PCChips is bad stuff too. Seen numerous boards of theirs that are just quirky... Their boards are very picky about memory and other supporting hardware, etc.

All time worst motherboards? Abit. I was a HUGE fan of Abit, and purchased about six of their motherboards within about a year of each other. Well, wouldn't you know, that was the SAME YEAR that they had their supplier screw them on an order of capacitors. Guess what!? After a year, all of the boards started being intermittent on boot. Argh, friggin pieces of crap. I don't care what the story is, if it's Abit's fault or not, but their name was on the box, and they are who I hate for the oversight. All I know is that I got $1000 (initial market value) worth of Abit boards that won't reliably boot, and need $30 worth of capacitors each to make them work again. LX6, BX6, BF6, BE6-II. Yep, I owned them all. ARGH.

Also, I had an OEM motherboard from BCM back in the day. Man, that thing was a piece of crap, too.
 
Still trying to figure out what went wrong w/ my K7VMM+ - then I looked at the box ... it was an ECS .....
 
I'll cast my vote for PC Chips too. I have only worked on a couple, but in each case, the board was bad. As a tech, I have worked on many systems and built quite a few as well. I've had a lot of luck with MSI boards and I've only had to RMA one of them out of nearly 2 dozen. I have also had some bad experiences with FIC and I can nearly guarantee that any board used in an HP/Compaq system will be crap. I've built a few systems using Biostar boards and they seem to work pretty reliably, but they seriously need to make better owners manuals as they usually leave you to do a lot of figuring out on your own. I have only used a few Asus and Abit boards, but they did not give me any problems.
 
Abit KA7-100

Sent board back to manufacturer twice and it took over a month to get it back each tiime. Ended up just buying an Asus board.
 
I have been a computer technician most of my life (I am 38 now) and the manufacturer that scores my vote for worst is PC Chips. But, as the saying goes, you get what you pay for. I can't count the number of PC Chips boards that have had compatibility or stability issues in every system that I have had to put together for customer's who bought their own parts to put their systems together cheaply. There was one customer who RMAd the board they bought 7 times before finally giving in and buying an Asus from the shop I worked for. I have seen numerous boards that were DOA. PC Chips support leaves much to be desired. Performance wise, stock Intel boards outperform them chipset per chipset. From my experiences, I really do not see how PC Chips, nor the companies that purchase their boards, can stay in business and make any money.
 
Originally posted by AceGoober
I have been a computer technician most of my life (I am 38 now) and the manufacturer that scores my vote for worst is PC Chips. But, as the saying goes, you get what you pay for. I can't count the number of PC Chips boards that have had compatibility or stability issues in every system that I have had to put together for customer's who bought their own parts to put their systems together cheaply. There was one customer who RMAd the board they bought 7 times before finally giving in and buying an Asus from the shop I worked for. I have seen numerous boards that were DOA. PC Chips support leaves much to be desired. Performance wise, stock Intel boards outperform them chipset per chipset. From my experiences, I really do not see how PC Chips, nor the companies that purchase their boards, can stay in business and make any money.

They didnt, heh , ECS bought them out, very easily I might add ;)
 
:D Well, someone wanted the votes tallied up. I've done it for each (or most) specific MB mentioned and the MB manufacturers as well as the OEMs mentioned and should have the results posted in this thread soon! I will try to show the worst specific MB mentioned, the worst MB manufacturer based on mentions of the name only, and the worst combining the specific boards and the name only.........if that makes any sense......hopefully will post tonight!
 
Abit VP6, I had 2 and had trouble with both of them constantly. Horrible capacitor burn-out problems too.
 
Here the list of the votes so far (but I did not differentiate between MBs, Systems and Chipsets):

ABIT 6

KT7A (raid or not) 17
KT7 (raid or not) 11
KA7 6
KG7 5
BE6-II 4
VP6 3
BX6-2 2
AN7 1
BD7 Raid 1
BE7 1
BF6 1
BH6 1
BX133R 1
BX6R2 1
IC7 1
IT-7 Max 1
KR7A-133 1
LX6 1
NF7-S 1
NV7 1
VA6 1

Total Specific MB ABIT 62
TOTAL ABIT 68


ACER 5

ACORP 1

ALI 1


AMPTRON 5

M748LMRT 1

TOTAL AMPTRON 6


ASUS 9

P4T533 7
A7A266 6
A7N8X 4
P5A 3
CUSL2-C 2
A7V133 2
A7M266 2
A7V266-E 1
A7V333 1
A7V8X 1
CUFW 1
P3C2000 1
P3V4X 1
P4S533 1
P4S8X 1
TUSL2-C 1

Total Specific MB ASUS 15
TOTAL ASUS 24


AZZA 10

BIOSTAR 4


CHAINTECH 2

7AJA2E 1

9CJS 1

TOTAL CHAINTECH 4


COMPAQ 5

DELL 3

DFI 3

DTK 2


ECS 14

K7S5A 16

K7AMA 1

K7VMM+ 1

P6IWP-Fe 1

P6S5AT 1

Total Specific MB ECS 20
TOTAL ECS 34


ELEMENTS 1


EPOX 5

7KXA 2
8KHA+ 2

8K3A 1

8K7A+ 1

8RDA 1

Total Specific MB EPOX 7
TOTAL EPOX 12


FIC 17

AZ-11 4

PA-2013 2

SD-11 2

VA-503 3

Total Specific MB FIC 11
TOTAL FIC 28


FREETECH 1

FUGUTECH 1


GIGABYTE 6

GA-7VRXP 4

GA-5AA 1

GA-5AX 1

GA-7DXR 1

GA-7VA 1

GA-7VT600-L 1

G7-VKML 1

Total Specific MB GIGABYTE 10
TOTAL GIGABYTE 16


HOUSTON TECH 1

HP 3

IBM 1


INTEL 5

CC820 2

VC820 2

TOTAL INTEL 9


IWILL 1

DVD266U-RN 1

KA266 1

KV200-R 1

Total Specific MB IWILL 3
TOTAL IWILL 4


JETWAY 2

LUCKY STAR 2

MATSONIC 1

MICRONICS 1


MSI 14

K7T Turbo/Pro 9

K7N2L 4

KT3 Ultra 2

K7 Pro 1

K74 Ultra 1

Total Specific MB MSI 17
TOTAL MSI 31


PACKARD BELL 5

PC CHIPS 58

Q-LITY 1

SHUTTLE 6

SIEMENS 1

SOLTEK 2


SOYO 6

DRAGON 4

6BA +IV 1

DRAGON+ 1

DRAGON ULTRA 333 1

P4 DRAGON ULTRA 1

SY-SEHM 1

Total Specific MB SOYO 9
TOTAL SOYO 15


SUPERMICRO 1

TEKRAM 1

TOSHIBA 1

TRINITY 1

TYAN 3

VIA 1

ZETA 1

ZEUS 1


Now here’s the shocker! The top 12 worst MBs based on the total values for each manufacturer are:

1. ABIT - 68
2. PC CHIPS - 58
3. ECS - 34
4. MSI - 31
5. FIC - 28
6. ASUS -24
7. GIGABYTE - 16
8. SOYO - 15
9. EPOX - 12
10. AZZA -10
11. INTEL - 9
12. AMPTRON - 6
12. SHUTTLE - 6

Of course, this has as much to do with popularity as how bad the boards suck. For example, PC Chips position is more based on how their boards suck whereas Abit is probably mostly on popularity. Asus and Gigabyte are also high on the list mostly because of popularity.

And now the 6 worst specific MBs mentioned:

1. Abit KT7A - 17
2. ECS K7S5A - 16
3. Abit KT7 - 11
4. MSI K7T Turbo/Pro - 9
5. Asus P4T533 - 7
6. Asus A7A266 - 6
6. Abit KA7 - 6

All MB manufacturers have their sh*t boards, so there's really no fantastic company. Just read the reviews and the forums and decide for yourself!
 
skaarjmaster, thanks for the in-depth list. u save reading about 25 pages of text just by reading your post.
 
Worst Board for me? Abit BE6 Rev 2.0 ... . onboard ata66 controller caused problems with windows 98 ad 2000 pro.

Worst manufa for me, ASUS......worst asus board that was A7m266 amd 761 NB, VIA 686B SB....piece of sht. no over clocking, ample P/S and it still only lasted 1 year?????????

Best board so far? Abit KG7-Raid 2001 production year...not a hickup- so far?!

D e e p
 
My AN7, it doesnt work with MBM 5 and therefore doesnt work with my LCD. It is a decent board, but this just kills me because Abit endorses MBM!!! Stupid UGURU!
 
Back
Top