Please help me refine my backup strategy

MountainX

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
254
I would appreciate some suggestions regarding my backup strategy for my home file server.

My question is whether my source drive (data to be backed up) and target drive should be on the same controller or not. I need to put this into context, so here's the rest of the info. (Please read on before telling me not to put the drives in the same computer.)

From now on, I will not be thinking of RAID as a backup solution. Instead, my idea is to continuously or periodically (and frequently) copy my data from a non-RAID source volume to a backup volume. I want to duplicate nearly everything (similar to mirroring in RAID), but I don't want files deleted off the source to be immediately deleted off the backup. And I want the volumes to be independent enough that a loss of data or corruption on one is not automatically and immediately propagated to the other (as it would be with RAID).

Because I want frequent backups, I think the source and target disks should be in the same computer. (This is a home server; it is OK if a hardware failure takes the server off line for a while.)

My server has an Areca 1220 (SATA controller) as well as motherboard SATA. Should I ensure that my source and target drives are on separate controllers? Will there be a big negative performance impact if I use separate controllers compared to putting both source and target on the Areca?

And, btw, what software will help me backup as I have described. I'm running Ubuntu. Here is my list of backup software solutions I've started looking at:
http://davestechshop.net/ListOfFreeOpenSourceLinuxUbuntuBackupSoftware
 
Good that you're not thinking of RAID as a backup!

Why does it have to be in the same computer? That's not a backup, that's called the same computer.

If I get what you're after I'd suggest two large capacity external drives. One for the older backup (preferrably kept off-site) and one for daily backups. Rotate the two weekly or bi-weekly.

Off-site is also important to counter physical damage beyond your control - theft, fire, water damage, etc.
 
Thanks for your reply. I understand the importance of off-site backups. What I will probably do is send a subset of my data to Mozy, Carbonite, Jungle Disk or Amazon S3 directly.

However, the immediate problem I'm trying to solve is how to get continuous or near-continuous backups (and to do it without making my server less responsive).

Backing up to another disk in the same computer makes sense to me -- for my needs. It will be fast and the overhead will be lower (I think). Plus I already have the internal HDDs and I don't have any external HDDs available at the moment.

And I like the idea of a simpler system. I have another computer I could use at the backup target, but that involves network congestion, more noise, more electricity usage, more heat, more maintenance... If I get 80% of the benefits at 20% of the complexity, I think that's a good trade off. I think backing up to another disk in the same computer is simple and inexpensive and gives me that 80/20 trade off.

So I want to know the pros and cons of having those two disks (source and target) on the same controller. How much data protection (isolation?) do I gain by using separate controllers, and what might the performance hit be?

Thank you.
 
I'm looking for a (near) continuous back up strategy...
when a file changes, I want it backed up immediately (or within a few minutes at least)
thanx

You must very accurately explain WHY! This is where paranoia and cost go hand in hand.
 
Back
Top