Please help me decide: Adaptec, Areca or SuperMicro.

Ed R

n00b
Joined
Nov 10, 2008
Messages
3
I am considering to combine a ASUS P6T WS Professional with one of the following SAS RAID controler cards:

At first the system will use three 1TB Seagate ES.2 SAS drives in a RAID 5 array. In long run I want to extend this to eight 1TB Seagate ES.2 SAS drives in a RAID 60 array. Because of this I don't intend to use the two SAS controlers on the ASUS P6T WS Professional. I might use them in the future for a fast RAID 0 startup solution. The operating system will probably be MS Server 2008.

I know the Areca card has more features (extra cache memory and out-of-band management), but I also know it costs a lot more. I want to know if it’s worth the extra money.

Further I would like to know if the Adaptec and the SuperMicro card will offer the same kind of speed and quality. The SuperMicro card seems to be a bit cheaper, but is it wise to buy one?

Finally I understand that the backup battery can be placed on the Adaptec card where Areca needs a separate slot for the backup battery card. The SuperMicro cards uses the optional battery backup unit BTR-0012L. I would like to know if this will also consume another slot.

Kind regards,

Ed R.
 
The Supermicro card, while PCIe, is meant for their servers (they call it UIO form factor) as the component side is reversed (as is the bracket location). You will have a difficult time mounting it. I personally would go with the Areca, but that's just me (what can I say, I'm on my 2nd Areca card now :) ). Out-of-band management rocks too.
 
out of band management does kick ass, I have both areca and adaptec controllers. Both work very well as long as the drives are compatible. The areca is bit faster then adaptec. As far as bbus go yes the one for adaptec mounts right on the card and requires no extra space, the one for areca comes mounted to pci bracket and includes fairly long ribbon cable for connecting to controller card. You can mount it in empty expansion slot but you don't have to, it will work just as well if you use double sided tape and stick it to the side of the case.
 
I own an Adaptec 51645, so I'll chime in here.

Pros:
1. Fast.
2. Nice GUI interface, although a bit bloated as it uses Java.
3. Has all the usual features of high-end raid card.
4. Support is based in the USA, but they tend to ignore non-enterprise users' needs.
5. Adaptec is a fairly established company for RAID controllers.

Cons:
1. Heat. You will need to tack a fan on it somehow - PCI slot cooler or zip-tie a fan.
Otherwise you will get battery and raid cpu overheat issues. Areca has an integrated fan.
Thus this card is actually a 2-slot solution, unless you have sufficient airflow in your case. I'm talking server-level airflow with very high CFM fans...
2. Kernel bootup is very slow. Adds about 1 minute to your boot time.
3. Expansion/Raid level conversion very slow. (Took one entire week to add 1 drive to a raid, and the data ended up corrupted.) Better off deleting/remaking the new array. Areca seems to be much faster.
4. Drivers/BIOS doesn't seem to be updated very much. Only 1 update since 5 series launch in April.
5. Picky about SATA drive compatibility. Areca seems to be picky too. Might be related to
the Intel IOP chip.
6. Might be related to my particular configuration, but it causes a 30000us DPC latency spike every 30 minutes or so. (Traced to STORPORT.SYS using xperf). That causes audio dropouts in my system.
7. Drive detection seems to be wonky at times (latest bios/driver). Sometimes the GUI and the internal state of the card do not match, causing system to freeze up. Adaptec blamed it on my Seagates. (Bog standard 7200.10 500gb and 7200.11 1TBs.)
8. Latest driver/bios seems to have issues with enabling raid level write cache. However, latest driver/bios added the power management features, which I use. Drive-level write cache still works.
9. Boot bios warning messages very user unfriendly. You need to get used to how it shows warnings to you, and the accept/reject configuration system.
10. RAID6 currently limited to 16 drives.
11. Onboard RAM not upgradeable, limited to 256mb/512mb depending on the card. Should not really be an issue, though. Areca supports 2gb/4gb, but I don't know if there's tangible performance benefits.
12. No temperature monitoring of hard drives, or smart monitoring besides smart error. Only temperature monitoring is Battery (good/bad) and raid IOP (which hovers about 55-60C with a fan attached). May actually be a benefit since you don't obsess about drive temperatures.
13. Price. However, comparable to Areca in cost. Battery Backup is pretty much mandatory and will cost another $100 or so. UPS is not a substitute for battery backup for the write cache.
 
Thanks alot for all of your quick responses.

I start feeling like the Areca is the better choice and maybe also worth the extra money.

First of all I don't like a slow kernel bootup and I suppose the Areca does better here. Maybe somebody can confirm that it does. :(

Further the heat seems to be an issue. Because of this I would think the fan on the Areca and a slot besides the controlercard with just a battery come in handy and are not that much a disadvantage as they may seem.

Finally I get the impression that the out-of-band-management is not redundant and does kick ass.

B.T.W. Why is an UPS not a substitute for the battery backup for the write cache? Does it jump in too late all of the time or is the change of data corrupting too big to solely rely on an UPS? :confused:

Ed R.
 
If you do decide to purchase the Areca, you'll get a LOT better support from Jus (find him on 2cpu) than you will from Newegg or any other US retailer.
 
You may want to reconsider:
areca RMA tale

OK, I understand Areca has the better product and Adaptec is a more professional company. Why is it that the products of Adaptec can't keep up with those of Areca? :confused:


If you do decide to purchase the Areca, you'll get a LOT better support from Jus (find him on 2cpu) than you will from Newegg or any other US retailer.

I'm located in the Netherlands, so I think that Jus, Newegg or any other US retailer isn't an option. Areca might also have learned from negative publicity. Also a product shouldn't malfunction. I suppose it's a small chance that an Areca controlercard will malfunction and will have to be send to Taiwan for repairs like the one in the areca RMA tale.
 
Back
Top