Please help me chose a bluray player (internal)

bloomstomb

n00b
Joined
Mar 2, 2011
Messages
59
I dont have any software, or the drive. I've never owned one either. Im bulding a pc for someone who wants a internal bluray player. Ive been reading alot of complaints (newegg) about no software included . Im guessing these are mostly OEM's but Ive also been reading reviews saying the software when included also does not support all the blu ray movies.

Can you guys reccomend either a package (player and software) or a drive and seperate software?

I would like to go as cheap as possible.
 
Last edited:
You need to buy both; some drives come with software but it's going to be outdated and garbage. Get the cheapest drive and if you're really serious about this then Total Media Theater is the best player. Power DVD kind of sucks and has issues but it should work too (I'm not a fan so this isn't a suggestion, just an option).

The cheapest option is to use Media Player Classic but that only supports movie playback and nothing else like menus and extras.
 
This is the cheapest way since the software alone is $100.
Samsung with Power DVD9.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16827151232

I currently have an LG and Lite-On BluRay readers in my machines. Depending on your audio chipset and how you have it routed, you might not get sound on some BluRays.
I have an issue with a few movies when playing them on my main machine with PowerDVD 9.
The issue is with digital audio not being decoded and routed properly.

My HTPC plays everything fine using HDMI to my TV, but I have decided to just use my Panasonic BD player for BluRay playback.

I originally bought the LG since it was the cheapest way to play BluRays at the time and it also plays HD-DVD's.
 
Does MPC integrate with MCE?

Yes and No. WMC can be trained to use MPC, though it can run into some headaches depending on the OS (32 v 64 bit) and what codecs you have, and what files you have. I'm sure most of the issues encountered could eventually be solved, if you feel like spending a lot of time messing with it. And you still won't get BR menus/extras/etc.

As Crim said, Total Media Theatre is the way to go if you use WMC.
 
Yes and No. WMC can be trained to use MPC, though it can run into some headaches depending on the OS (32 v 64 bit) and what codecs you have, and what files you have. I'm sure most of the issues encountered could eventually be solved, if you feel like spending a lot of time messing with it. And you still won't get BR menus/extras/etc.

As Crim said, Total Media Theatre is the way to go if you use WMC.

Don't care much about menus, just simple playback. I'm using 64 bit versions of both 7 and MPC. Is TMT still worth the c-note ?
 
I posted a thread on here when TMT5 was $59 on sale and didn't get a single reply to my thread.

You can buy it all day long for $79 with coupons.

You're silly if you pay $100.
 
Don't care much about menus, just simple playback. I'm using 64 bit versions of both 7 and MPC. Is TMT still worth the c-note ?

There are coupons to get it for like $80 but if you want blue ray disc playback then yes it is worth it to get TMT.

If you rip your BRs then its easy enough to use just Media Browser and MPC instead.
 
Yeah keep your eye out because I've seen Bluray players go for $49 on deals for decent ones. If you're planning on spending more than $80 it better be a writer.
 
Yeah keep your eye out because I've seen Bluray players go for $49 on deals for decent ones. If you're planning on spending more than $80 it better be a writer.

Uh, we're talking about BR players as in software. Not disc drives.
 
I posted a thread on here when TMT5 was $59 on sale and didn't get a single reply to my thread.
.
Yeah, unfortunately missed that deal.

Time to fish for coupons. I take it it's more work to rip than to just play natively.
 
Back
Top