PlayStation 4 Controller Almost Adopted Xbox Layout

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Here's an interesting little nugget of information about the design of the DualShock 4 controller.

"For the analog sticks, we did test having the analog sticks on top, since the Xbox has the left side on top [above the D-pad]," Aoki told GamesBeat in an interview published on Monday. "Especially from the shooter teams -- we got feedback that that's what they wanted. They knew that consumers liked the 360 for shooters."
 
Yea I read that earlier, but also understood why they just stayed with the same design a day just improved it.

I'm torn either way, it looks like they addressed all the issues with the DS3. Then again I like the 360 controller better for everything other than situations where I need to use a dpad (2D fighters, etc)
 
BAH can't edit supposed to be and*.

His point made sense, it's part of their identity. Same with the 360.
 
the PS D pad is retarded as hell.

I got a hori d-pad for my ps3 and it was tons better.
 
I actually really enjoy the PS3 d-pad...but those sticks are way too twitchy. It's a tough call as I prefer the Xbox layout for shooters and PS3/PS4 layout for fighting games and sports games. I'd almost rather have multiple controller options as long as they aren't overly expensive.
 
I'm thinking that Sony would have shot themselves in the foot adopting the 360 layout. If PlayStation users wants a 360 controller, they'd be buying an Xbox.

Anyone know if Xbox One and PlayStation 4 will be interchangeable? Is it USB, or is it USB with a proprietary interface?
 
I'm thinking that Sony would have shot themselves in the foot adopting the 360 layout. If PlayStation users wants a 360 controller, they'd be buying an Xbox.

Just offer both that way consumers can pick the one they like and you can have increased sales as many consumers might like both. Problem solved. Profits increased.
 
I actually really enjoy the PS3 d-pad...but those sticks are way too twitchy. It's a tough call as I prefer the Xbox layout for shooters and PS3/PS4 layout for fighting games and sports games. I'd almost rather have multiple controller options as long as they aren't overly expensive.

I believe that controllers generally have good profit margins for Sony and Microsoft. Maybe multiple controller types is a good opportunity for them...
 
At least it's not like it's going to be that stupid boomerang design they were originally planning for the PS3.
 
Thank god they didn't. I hate the Xbox controller layout. Never could get used to it.
 
I think I would have liked it, always prefered the Xbox 360-controller of these two. The only game I remember that I actually disliked the layout was with Beautiful Katamari because of how the sticks are used.
 
Just offer both that way consumers can pick the one they like and you can have increased sales as many consumers might like both. Problem solved. Profits increased.

Well I'm sure third party controller manufacturers are free to adopt the 360 layout for PS4 consoles anyways.
 
Thank god they didn't. I hate the Xbox controller layout. Never could get used to it.
It's far better imo, at rest xbox controller is one thumb on an analogue stick one on buttons. VS D-pad plus buttons. The main issue probably would be for shooters, when you have to use both analogue sticks for ps controller you have to angle both your hands in slightly which means you have to grasp instead of cradle the controller which is uncomfortable for extended periods.
 
I don't have a problem using either controller.

Maybe you guys who can't use one or the other have some sort of neuromotor deficit. You should get that checked out.
 
Glad they didn't. I own both platforms and overwhelmingly prefer the PS controller to the Xbox. I have never liked the xbox controller even after using it for years I find it cumbersome, clunky and terribly laid out.

Don't care from a shooter perspective though, I play those on PC.
 
Um, I have an idea. How about releasing TWO VERSIONS of the controller? I know, crazy.
 
They should have done this. The PS controllers in general do not feel as comfortable as the 360 controller did and has.
 
The sad part us that some people just haven't spent alot of time to be able to be used to the 360 layout. It's not a brand thing. It's more of a I'm used to this wonky layout and I don't want to try and fix it thing. Just like with people and old apps with broken UI's.
 
The sad part is that some people just haven't spent a lot of time to be able to be used to the 360 layout. It's not a brand thing. It's more of a I'm used to this wonky layout and I don't want to try and fix it thing. Just like with people and old apps with broken UI's.
 
I wonder if something like the layout has a patent on it. If so they may have had to pay to copy the layout too much.
 
Just offer both that way consumers can pick the one they like and you can have increased sales as many consumers might like both. Problem solved. Profits increased.

Yup. The PS controller is the deal breaker for me because I cannot stand the location of the thumb sticks. If Sony is willing to offer me a X360 style controller, they will have my business as a PS4 will sit next to my X360 and XB1
 
I wonder if something like the layout has a patent on it. If so they may have had to pay to copy the layout too much.
Nope. Other companies have already used similar layouts - the Ouya controller uses it and that was a Kickstarter project. Also, the Dreamcast controller was pretty obviously the inspiration for the original Xbox "Duke" controller, simply adding the right thumbstick.

What cracks me up is that Sony's own testing showed that people preferred the Xbox-type layout but they settled on the familiar DualShock layout because change is scary.
 
They should have given in and adapted it. Keyword "adapt". But they chose not too however they still did improve the controller in other areas and lets hope that it's enough to be almost as comfortable as Microsoft's controller. Otherwise it's a deal breaker for me as well. The PS1-3 controllers are very awkward for prolonged use and for shooters.
 
From what I have been hearing from FPS people who have actually used it (for a limitied about of time now doubt) is that they like it, it's probably split down the middle but the main factors that got people angry have mostly been fixed other than thumbstick placement. The DS3 had many more issues other than the placement of those sticks.
 
Back
Top