Piracy will Save Kindle DX

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
TechCrunch has an article about why Amazon’s new (and more expensive) Kindle DX is poised to fail unless textbook pirates take interest in the reader. The larger size of the DX makes it an appealing replacement for college textbooks and PDF rips of these books are available… you can see where this is going, right?

Just find the book you want in PDF form, upload it to your Kindle over USB, and you’ve got a perfectly readable and convenient textbook. Sure, students will have to deal with the usability issues I raised above, like slow highlighting. But these books, frustrating as they might be, will be 100% free. That’s $300 per quarter in extra beer money. Most obstacles and morals fade quickly in the face of that much alcohol.
 
Sounds reasonable... I mean it was the "pirate" that made mp3 players where they are today.
 
Even better and I believe more interesting will be the upcoming generation of nettablets. To me the Kindle is just yet another dedicated device that can be useful in certain environments but a nettablet has more uses, not tide to any format, runs any application like a standard laptop and has an awesome reading interface with the prn and touch capabilities of Windows 7.

What I HATE about the Kindle is that its a proprietary format that doesn't need to exist save for the Kindle itself. We don't need another format.
 
The question I have, though, is if Amazon is making decent margins on the hardware or if they're selling Kindles basically "at cost" and attempting to profit instead on book sales. Though the Kindle doesn't seem all that expensive to produce, I literally have no idea how costly the display itself is to manufacture.

If the case is the latter, piracy has a real opportunity to put the pain on Kindle profits rather than "save it".
 
I don't seem to hear Apple, nor other MP3 player companies, crying about how much "money" they think they are losing by people not buying music from their store... hmm. Is Amazon not making enough profit on all the other crap they sell? heh

Books are just like all the other media. It can be infinitely and perfectly duplicated for near zero cost. I'm all for cheaper school for students. The cost on college books are a complete ripoff. There are thousands of people out there who could have had a much different life, but couldn't afford college. What a fine system the US has... :rolleyes:
 
Other then the wireless features my Sony reader kicks the crap out of the Kindle. Calibre really helped it along ;)
 
TechCrunch has an article about why Amazon’s new (and more expensive) Kindle DX is poised to fail unless textbook pirates take interest in the reader. The larger size of the DX makes it an appealing replacement for college textbooks and PDF rips of these books are available… you can see where this is going, right?

One of the big reasons seems to be cost with the second being college books.

On cost a lot of ebook readers cost more, hell people pay that much for mp3 players. I don't see cost as an issue. The first kindle is a good example of this, they couldn't keep them in stock.

College books is an area they really need to work on. If I could get a book at a good discount for them not having to carry an overhead I would. It would be nice to carry that thing around(or the smaller one) instead of books that way a few times more then it.
 
Shoot, buy one Kindle for the price of a couple books for one semester...
I could see it going over very well.

Textbooks is a freaking monopoly. The bookstore, the teacher, and the publisher are all in it together. Getting a teacher to tell you exactly what book you need to buy (So you can do it on your own for a ton cheaper) was like pulling teeth.
 
I own a few pdf books from RPGNow. Would I be able to upload them to a Kindle DX and actually be able to use it? I thought you could only use Amazon's dumb format or something?
 
Books are just like all the other media. It can be infinitely and perfectly duplicated for near zero cost. I'm all for cheaper school for students. The cost on college books are a complete ripoff. There are thousands of people out there who could have had a much different life, but couldn't afford college. What a fine system the US has... :rolleyes:

Textbooks are only a very small component of the high cost of college.
 
Textbooks are only a very small component of the high cost of college.

$600 (last term; $500 for current term!) worth of books for $1000 worth of courses is without a doubt "only a very small component of the high cost of college".
 
TechCrunch has an article about why Amazon’s new (and more expensive) Kindle DX is poised to fail unless textbook pirates take interest in the reader. The larger size of the DX makes it an appealing replacement for college textbooks and PDF rips of these books are available… you can see where this is going, right?

300 dollars a quarter? Where can I find such cheap books???
 
$600 (last term; $500 for current term!) worth of books for $1000 worth of courses is without a doubt "only a very small component of the high cost of college".

At UVA I get to pay (in state) ~$20,000 per year, $1,000 of which is textbooks. That's 5%. If you pay out-of-state tuition, books are 2.5%.
 
Let's put it this way: simple math.

I spent $500 to $600 for the first trimester in one college year. The next college year I spent a bit more as the courses got harder-- $750-ish.

If I were to have found those same books as eBooks on torrent and the Kindle DX existed 5 years ago, then I would have considered spending $300 or $400 for the Kindle DX and save myself hundreds of dollars in books.

Piracy is inevitable. But, price of college books is absolutely ridiculous. Having spent close to $5000 in college textbooks, not include summer courses, just sucks-- simply put.
 
Well shit; after my freshmen year, I learned very quickly that just because a course says there's a book, does not necessarily mean that the book will be used.

If anything, this is now justification to buy a Kindle....gaaargh. Must save money for loan payments instead...
 
At UVA I get to pay (in state) ~$20,000 per year, $1,000 of which is textbooks. That's 5%. If you pay out-of-state tuition, books are 2.5%.
That sounds more like live-in expenses though. The $1,000 example was just the class, my guess is living off campus.


Piracy is inevitable. But, price of college books is absolutely ridiculous. Having spent close to $5000 in college textbooks, not include summer courses, just sucks-- simply put.

Exactly.

Obviously, not everyone wants to pirate. And not all books will have been pirated yet.
So, there's still a market for legit copies.

My question is, what kind of deal Amazon can strike with the Publishers. If they can get a good deal ($40 for a textbook or something), it'll do well. But if it's still the super-inflated cost of $100 or more, looks doubtful that anything will work.
 
Well shit; after my freshmen year, I learned very quickly that just because a course says there's a book, does not necessarily mean that the book will be used.

If anything, this is now justification to buy a Kindle....gaaargh. Must save money for loan payments instead...

What's even when a new edition of the book comes out, virtually unchanged, and they make you buy it. So I had to spend ~$500 for two nearly identical textbooks.
 
What's even when a new edition of the book comes out, virtually unchanged, and they make you buy it. So I had to spend ~$500 for two nearly identical textbooks.

Yep, it's a monopoly.

Honestly, that stuff should be a crime. Or at least have a federal manditation that states all courses should CLEARLY list the materials, ISDNs, etc, required by the course ahead of time so that students may prepare.
 
And then we all realize we can just open the PDF's on our laptops with no need to spend extra money on the Kindle.
 
And yet again the fine line between carrying a full blown laptop (or even a Netbook) and a simple eBook reader is lost in the cracks... it's about convenience, and unless we're talking about tablet PC with a convertible screen, I personally can't stand reading a standard page of textual content on a screen that's 90 degrees off axis compared to the layout of the page.

Oh, sure, I can just tilt the laptop up on its side I supposed, but then I'd not only have more difficulty holding it comfortably, but I'd look like an ass at the same time I suppose, not that I care what people think (that's understood, right?).

Tablets... someday someone will build one like the one I have in my imagination. If I had the money to develop it I would, and it would sell like hotcakes...
 
And then we all realize we can just open the PDF's on our laptops with no need to spend extra money on the Kindle.

Until YOU realize that carrying around a laptop with a 5-6 hour battery life (hell, you could double that number) and reading books on a backlit LCD on a device that weighs and is the size of a book or three (depending if you have big hardcover textbooks or paperback literature) nullifies half the reason why a student (or anyone really) would want the convenience and usability of an e-reader.

That's like saying we should just use power saws to cut our steaks instead of... I dunno... a steak knife.

e-readers are lighter, more compact, easier to read, more convenient, and have longer battery life.
 
You just have to convince someone else to pay for you to make it. It can't be that hard to do if the Phantom guys could do it. I mean, just look at the name! They may as well have called it the Vaporware.
 
I know that for some of my students the textbook cost is the straw that breaks their back. They can barely afford it as it is (some come from low income areas) and then most of my colleagues are oblivious to their plight. However, I don't see textbook piracy taking off like mp3s or games for the simple fact that the audience is limited; furthermore, some instructors like to assign lab materials, workbooks or readers which can not be easily reproduced.

And for the record: I have all the required books for my class listed on the uni web page as well as on my syllabus complete with bin number and links to amazon. Plus, I have two hard copies of each available for checkout at the library reserve room which I purchased myself. Total textbook cost to take my class $46 for four books.
 
And then we all realize we can just open the PDF's on our laptops with no need to spend extra money on the Kindle.

Power an LED/LCD 24/7... or use the E-Ink of the Kindle and get WEEKS worth... Only using electricity when you change each page????

Plus, thinner, lighter, no running fans.
 
That's like saying we should just use power saws to cut our steaks instead of... I dunno... a steak knife.

When I was at school, I had a laptop with me anyway, so reading books on the laptop would have made more sense than buying and carrying around a Kindle. Do you eat dinner on a table saw?
 
Textbooks are only a very small component of the high cost of college.

What do you consider the "cost of college"? It isn't rent, or food, or beer, because you would pay for those regardless if you went to college or not. I'm talking money that strictly goes to education... those are course/college fees. Of course it varies depending on where you go to college (university vs community). When you can easily buy a new laptop every year for the cost of books that you may or may not even use, that is ridiculous.

It does go beyond just college books though. The price of electronic distribution is near free, and this is one of those devices that can benefit from the sharing of knowledge.

A digital book reader will never have the same feel or nostalgia as a real hardbound book.
 
Hey, I wasn't saying textbooks are cheap. I'm strongly considering pirating them myself.
 
(pressed post button too quickly)

I was mainly attempting to say that the other costs of college are also ridiculously high; moreso than textbooks.
 
Whether it be 5 percent or 50 percent, I think most people will agree that the price for college textbooks is too high. Honestly I would LOVE to just buy a Kindle (or whatever, doesn't necessarily have to be a kindle) freshman year and just download the textbooks after that--even for a fee.

I've been watching the kindle for a long time now, but I still just can't bring myself to buy one :( The book prices aren't quite cheap enough to justify the price of the hardware, plus the whole proprietary thing.
 
If the government can't competently make for force college to be affordable for anyone who wants to go, then I fully support piracy giving a few more people the opportunity to not have to drop out due to insane schooling costs.
 
Whether it be 5 percent or 50 percent, I think most people will agree that the price for college textbooks is too high.

If the latest Harry Potter book was predicted to only sell as a particular college text book then you'd see that selling for $50-100 as well.
 
Edit:

That's to say, college text books don't sell dick for numbers, plus add to them all the glossy colors and what not, and prices add up.
 
I would love to replace all my text book with this thing... it would really cut down the weight I have to carry around in my backpack. Plus reading long text from an lcd sucks.
 
until I saw this thread, the idea of pirating/PDF textbooks had never crossed my mind....

goddamn... i hope textbook pirating and digitizing become the new norm... nothing would make me happier than seeing this industry burn....
 
And then we all realize we can just open the PDF's on our laptops with no need to spend extra money on the Kindle.

Battery life is strike one. Strike two is the fact that you can read e-paper for hours in a wide variety of lighting conditions with no eyestrain. LCDs, not nearly so much...

E-paper has many disadvantages, limited gray tones and slow refresh rate being major ones. This is why things like webpages and scrolling pages suck on them. Their big advantage is that they are awesome for reading books on, LCDs don't come anywhere close.
 
Back
Top