Photorealism close

Photo realistic screenshots for games have existed since Far Cry. Gameplay photorealism... I bet that goes all out the window once you start playing the game
 
The dancers still look like shit compared to the players, same as NBA2K15. I can't really tell any difference from the old to new game by those shots. The players faces are great and their tattoo's are on point. The part that kills me is that they use generic shaped arms/legs/torso, so the player doesn't really look like himself.
Kevin Durant was the on the cover of 2k15 but his in game character was no where near as lanky as he is in real life. I still really did like 2k15, but I'm not in a hurry to grab 2k16 until its on a steam sale.
 
not even close


Yup. There are different levels of photorealism and right now everything we've seen is only touching the surface and frankly I don't want because then it's going to get too weird. Gamers will eventually realize they don't want true photorealism by the time we do get there.

Can't even trust these new UE4/Crytek Demo's because we've seen it before. Look at the tech demos they showed for UE3. I've still yet to see any UE3 game come close to that Samaritan demo and others like it. Most of what you see is all fluff from these engine developers.
 
In terms of in motion, in game: We will never reach photo-realism. We are always going to get better and better, but its purely impossible. Every generation we get halfway there. The early generations made the biggest strides, but now that we are closer, that 'halfway' becomes a shorter and shorter distance, and our eyes are VERY good at learning the 'tell's that show something is fake.

Take for instance, I can tell the difference between ANY (genuine) racing game screenshot and a picture of a real-life car. I can teach you the way to tell as well, and its quite easy, but I warn you, once you know, you know and cannot unsee.
 
^ Teach me, Sensei. For though I walk through the uncanny valley of the shadow of photo realism, I will fear no deception; for you are with me, thy rod and thy staff comfort me (no homo).

Article%20Lead%20-%20wide6274952711cxwjimage.related.articleLeadwide.729x410.11cxuf.png1414573152902.jpg-620x349.jpg
 
Okay, this is a BAD example, as the cars are the same but the in-game screenshot is not the best quality, but it can be done with ANY in-game screenshot.

2250853-7473589216_257b438a52_o.jpg


This is a screenshot from a game ^^^

1.jpg


This is a photo ^^

Seeing the two side by side, its pretty easy to tell. Like I said, the in-game screenshot is not at the highest fidelity you may be able to find.

That said, the clickbait worthy line: one simple trick! How can I immediately tell the two apart without looking at the environment, the colour accuracy...

The mirrors. The car does not reflect its own mirrors. The car does not reflect itself or protrusions of itself at all. Spoilers, fenders, mirrors, even the car's cockpit will reflect against the bonnet/hood. Modern realtime engines CANT have an object reflect itself. It needs to render itself before it can... render itself?

You may see this go away with UE4-style screen-space reflections that act in a differed level, but so far NO racing game has the car reflect the mirrors, or any part of itself.


cannot unsee.
 
The rendered car isn't half bad, except for the aliasing/jaggies, and the aluminum foil behind the honeycomb grill, lol.
 
Technically, we can do photorealism, we just can't do it at any reasonable speed.
 
I'd chalk this up as another one of those:

"A fan of a sports-game said something weird"

; and not think more about it, best that way.
 
In terms of in motion, in game: We will never reach photo-realism. We are always going to get better and better, but its purely impossible. Every generation we get halfway there. The early generations made the biggest strides, but now that we are closer, that 'halfway' becomes a shorter and shorter distance, and our eyes are VERY good at learning the 'tell's that show something is fake.

Take for instance, I can tell the difference between ANY (genuine) racing game screenshot and a picture of a real-life car. I can teach you the way to tell as well, and its quite easy, but I warn you, once you know, you know and cannot unsee.

If you say every generation we get half way there then we will get there since eye is not infinitely sensitive. Pascal should be significant jump for motion due to the new memory.
 
Higher Framerate =/= more realistic.

Higher Framrate DOES = better, but MOAR POWAAA is not going to make graphics more realistic. The issue is the amount of work it takes to create something 1-1 realistic.

In the end, limited resources and limited time means corners have to be cut in order to make a scene or a game ready to ship. I always use spiders' webs as an example of the endpoint of graphical fidelity. Whenever you have a 'realistic' forrest or jungle, or even ANY sort of environment: there is a distinct lack of spiders' webs. I don't mean the cottony gossamer used ONLY in creepy or old environments, I'm talking the kind of webs you see practically EVERYWHERE in real life, but are almost never found in game environments. There are a myriad of reasons WHY this is, including but not limited to the need for high-quality AA to sell the effect, the way spider webs cling to their environment... Essentially a LOT of work needs to be put in to make something like a Spider's web photo-realistic, and it is possible with today's hardware: but it is not practical given the amount of work involved and the amount of resources required to render. so you have two options: make a lower-quality web, which ruins the photo-realism, or do not include webs at all, and remove a bit of total realism...
 
Taken out of context I could've believed the car screenshot from the game was real so it's photorealistic enough to fool people.

I can see from the pic just by looking at the environment that it is fake though. There are lots of games that have great looking vehicles or characters but then the environment looks nowhere near as real. I'd prefer polycounts and detail divided evenly between the environment and characters rather than cramming all the detail in the characters.
 
^Exactly, taken out context it looks realistic, some nitpicking about about lack of mirror reflections or spider webs can be solved. What is definitely hampering the problems in games is that developers can not concentrate on the latest high-end hardware but mainly address lots of legcy stuff. There was also lack of tools allowing full utilization of modern resources (DX12 is addressing this). I would say in two generations (Pascal, Volta) photorealism will be entirely possible, especially with high-end 8-way SLI :D.
 
Back
Top