Photo Realistic Games, When?!?!?

In a way, we are seeing the effects of Moore's law in motion, albeit on a grander scale than just the raw transistor count alone. The rest of the industry will continue to grow in the wake of the latest cutting edge hardware.

Eventually all of our current technology will be replaced by something better; even things as firmly entrenched as an op-amp in an analog circuit. Check this out: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/02/070218135408.htm
 
Ill reply to this thread even though im not much of a gamer anymore and rarely keep up with video cards anymore.

Anyway...I gamed heavily for about 8yrs and always waited for these photo realistic graphics and so far all have disapointed.

First was

Hafl life 2 when the first screens were released we were all like WOW this game has almost life like graphics, then more and more screen shots came out and it started to disapoint, then you get ingame and it just doesnt look as good.

Then Doom 3 - Good game but looked way to cartoony

Then the highly anticapted Gears of War, Which is probably the closest yet as far as buildings and stuff but screen shots just always look better and more realistic, once you get ingame everything looks "like a game" for some reason.

Im not sure if its depth perception or what but i dont see it happening for at least another 10yrs now, In the past it was , "oh the source engine will do it" then it was the new unreal engine.

So far while actually playing a game Fight Night 3 is the closest to life like I have expereienced, Ive had people come over and think its a real fight on tv :D
 
Ill reply to this thread even though im not much of a gamer anymore and rarely keep up with video cards anymore.

Anyway...I gamed heavily for about 8yrs and always waited for these photo realistic graphics and so far all have disapointed.

First was

Hafl life 2 when the first screens were released we were all like WOW this game has almost life like graphics, then more and more screen shots came out and it started to disapoint, then you get ingame and it just doesnt look as good.

Then Doom 3 - Good game but looked way to cartoony

Then the highly anticapted Gears of War, Which is probably the closest yet as far as buildings and stuff but screen shots just always look better and more realistic, once you get ingame everything looks "like a game" for some reason.

Im not sure if its depth perception or what but i dont see it happening for at least another 10yrs now, In the past it was , "oh the source engine will do it" then it was the new unreal engine.

So far while actually playing a game Fight Night 3 is the closest to life like I have expereienced, Ive had people come over and think its a real fight on tv :D

Gears of war textures are to low-res imo
 
Photo realistic? I dunno, but....just watched some of the Alan Wake trailers and they look quite impressive. We're headed in the right direction.

As for the op's original question: Why worry about when your ideal game will come out? There's plenty of games to enjoy until that time comes for you. Maybe by that time you'll just be a brain in a jar, playing in some realization of a "matrix" style virtual environment.
 
2010 photo realistic. Than the focus will go to more lively environments. Like physics/object orientated(like cramming millions of NPCs with AI into citys on games).
 
[2dP]MightyMatt;1030662287 said:
DVDs were too expensive when they first came out, about the same as blu-ray prices, but in two years when blu-ray is below $100, then maybe they will be a hit?

Btw, I think this thread has been jacked

you're an accessory!

In a year HD-DVD will have run away with the show even more than it already has. I've been following HD-DVD and blu-ray on a week to week basis and that's my opinion.
 
photo realism is really more than just features and graphical power. Art direction plays a big part. For some reason, a lot of games take on a very cartoonish theme.
 
Isn't it a mistake to focus on resolution here? I don't know what the resolution of a motion picture frame is but I do know that movies on my HDTV look a helluva lot better than games at higher resolution on my Dell wide screen...to me the problem is that animation, ai, lighting effects and AA fall short...one thing I learned from gaming on an HDTV is that games with strong implementation of these features can look awsome at the lower resolutions....and are we really talking about photorealism or cinematic? Even motion pictures fall way short of photorealism...take a motion picture still and hold it next to any good 35mm photo.
 

did your e-penis grow? thats the most ridiculous bunch of false propaganda I've ever seen.. and.. nice to see your getting your info from a ps3/bluray website :rolleyes:

consult the planet, not 18yr old gamers. The players are what matters, not the dvd's being sold. 98% of dvd sales will be from consumers not owning a ps3, and currently about ~78% of players being sold are HD-DVD format.

http://blogs.marketwatch.com/barnako/2007/02/hddvd_vs_bluray.html
 
did your e-penis grow? thats the most ridiculous bunch of false propaganda I've ever seen.. and.. nice to see your getting your info from a ps3/bluray website :rolleyes:

consult the planet, not 18yr old gamers. The players are what matters, not the dvd's being sold. 98% of dvd sales will be from consumers not owning a ps3, and currently about ~78% of players being sold are HD-DVD format.

http://blogs.marketwatch.com/barnako/2007/02/hddvd_vs_bluray.html

Actually, my e-penis is so large, it can't grow anymore. But really, that link you just posted didn't say squat about anything you just said. Sure, 98% of DVD sales will be from consumers not owning a PS3, except for the fact that this has nothing to do with DVD. The PS3 is just as much a Blu-ray movie player as it is a video game system. So please tell me, if you had a PS3, would you still buy DVDs if you could get the same movie on Blu-ray? Hell no. So regardless of what you may think, the PS3 is definitely boosting Blu-ray's sales, and the fact that nobody ever includes the PS3 in the # of Blu-ray players being sold doesn't bother me, because that doesn't matter. Don't you know that companies make all their money off software, not hardware, at least in the early stages of it's life?

Blu-ray has already caught up to HD-DVD sales and surpassed them, and it launched AFTER HD-DVD. Hmm, yea, HD-DVD is REALLY kicking some tail :rolleyes:
 
another bad thing, which also comes as the comment of cartoonish stuff.
world of warcraft. it is one of the most popular PC games out to date.
It requires a TI84+ to run, blizzard is making alot of money off of it.
Other companies are seeing this and reducing the graphical standards of thier games lately...
 
Actually, my e-penis is so large, it can't grow anymore. But really, that link you just posted didn't say squat about anything you just said. Sure, 98% of DVD sales will be from consumers not owning a PS3, except for the fact that this has nothing to do with DVD. The PS3 is just as much a Blu-ray movie player as it is a video game system. So please tell me, if you had a PS3, would you still buy DVDs if you could get the same movie on Blu-ray? Hell no. So regardless of what you may think, the PS3 is definitely boosting Blu-ray's sales, and the fact that nobody ever includes the PS3 in the # of Blu-ray players being sold doesn't bother me, because that doesn't matter. Don't you know that companies make all their money off software, not hardware, at least in the early stages of it's life?

Blu-ray has already caught up to HD-DVD sales and surpassed them, and it launched AFTER HD-DVD. Hmm, yea, HD-DVD is REALLY kicking some tail :rolleyes:

your just flat out wrong unfortunately, your a product of PS3 Hype..you do realize the MINORITY of PS3 owners even own an HDTV (lol!) And only a percentage of them will even buy blu-ray dvd's... that is why they are most frequently omitted from DVD-Player sales. I believe blu-ray will exist to prop the sony game industry only, and it's video applications will fizzle out.. it's overpriced, the compression codec is overcomplicated and cumbersome, and the players are way overpriced and slower than the HD-DVD counterparts. I won't argue though.. just wait and see what happens.
 
Never. Even after we get the technology, we still won't have the art work down. Movies are a good example of this. You can always tell when it's CG.
 
your just flat out wrong unfortunately, your a product of PS3 Hype..you do realize the MINORITY of PS3 owners even own an HDTV (lol!) And only a percentage of them will even buy blu-ray dvd's... that is why they are most frequently omitted from DVD-Player sales. I believe blu-ray will exist to prop the sony game industry only, and it's video applications will fizzle out.. it's overpriced, the compression codec is overcomplicated and cumbersome, and the players are way overpriced and slower than the HD-DVD counterparts. I won't argue though.. just wait and see what happens.

So, let me get this straight...

You have all these crazy ideas in your head with absolutely nothing to back them up, and you say I'm just a product of the "PS3 hype." Sounds to me like you're just an idiot. :rolleyes:

FYI, I don't own, nor want a PS3, but I do want HD movies, so I'll probably pick up a PS3 eventually because I'm sure a few worthy games will be released, plus it'll play Blu-ray movies, which might I add, every major movie studio except for one (Universal) is backing. HD-DVD has nothing going for it, Blu-ray has more content, more players out, has better specs, and FYI is waaay more popular in Japan (you know, that country where it's uncommon to NOT own an HDTV?).

Basically, I don't see why anyone would even want to buy HD-DVD, unless of course Universal makes all of your favorite movies (though you also get some from Paramount as well, but those are also on Blu-ray). Basically, Blu-ray is better in every way except for it doesn't have Universal's support. Yea, it's going to tank...
 
So video cards continue to get faster, better and more expensive, so much time do we have to wait to see some breath-taking photo realistic games out there eh? i´m running out of dough here ! :p

posted in the wrong forum before :eek:

Grab a football, go outside & play.
Nothing beats reality for games !
 
Grab a football, go outside & play.
Nothing beats reality for games !

I don't know, I'd rather play CSS with a bunch of camping whores than those douche bags who hang out at arcades and camp up laser tag, lol. I know you didn't mean it in this way, but that reminded me of the time I did that...those fuckers...:mad:
 
In reality? Probably 20-30 years, if things go as well as they have in the past 10. Photo realistic is alot harder than it seems, especially in normal gameplay not cut scenes from the movie aspect of a game.
 
yes yes, the idea is in normal play but still the cut scene movies have been improving, for example have any body seen the opening movie in Warhammer - Mark of Chaos, i mean the main character there is very well made, very good graphics it reminds me of the fight scene between Neo and agent Smith in Matrix Revolutions, when neo punches Smith and u could see the rain drops and how Smith´s face is moved by the punch, well that face was Computer Rendered and at that time it was the most photo-realistic stuff money could buy.
 
Games will never be exactly photo-realistic. Real life objects have unlimited polygons and a computer will never be able to render that.
 
well just enough to fool the eye! wait till the Quantum GPU !!
 
I'm just going to hold onto my Pentium 4 and 6800 till they start to mass produce holidecks for the average consumer. No, I'm not at all a Star Trek fan, but it would be cool ;)
 
We already have borderline photorealism in games like GT:HD, which is going to improve even further in GT5...

Pics from this very forum:

c2a3c6606c.jpg

gtcar.jpg

wow3.jpg


I posted these on another forum and a handful of people actually doubted their authenticity.

Then again, it's just cars on a track, so it's pretty easy to make realistic looking. People on the other hand... that's gonna be tough. Todays shader technology fails to be photorealistic because of that "plastic coating" look...
 
One thing i'm surprised nobody has mentioned is that the pictures and screens can look great, but often while playing a game the jaggies can creep out, the flickers, etc, making the realism even less.
 
Oh yeah, in motion is a whole different story.

But in terms of photo-realism, photo does mean still shot, right? ;)
 
I can't wait for the day that models move like real people. Imagine a solider in a FPS game like MOHAA move, crawl crouch and act like a real person. None of this super speed crap you see in most games like UT or quake. This would change PC gaming over night!
 
I think in 5-10 years and maybe sooner it will be like watching a hd movie, but you control the action:cool:
 
Are the people quoting "5 years" and talking about needing "massive advances in technology" actually looking at the Crysis shots that were posted? I dont see how anyone can say we are "years and years and years" away from "photo realism" and start arguing about which level of theoretical future Star Trek technology we would need to "get there" when Crysis, which is due out this year, looks like that and runs on todays best hardware.

Safe bet for technology prognostication is bet short. I remember when that FF movie came out (thanks for posting those shots - they are VERY relevant), people who thought they knew/understood more about technology than they actually did were going on and on about how that level of image could "never" exist in a game in real time blah blah blah. Now, a reasonably short time later, and there are games that effectively look a LOT better than the FF movie.
 
Crysis looks really close, but its still far off.


Are the people quoting "5 years" and talking about needing "massive advances in technology" actually looking at the Crysis shots that were posted? I dont see how anyone can say we are "years and years and years" away from "photo realism" and start arguing about which level of theoretical future Star Trek technology we would need to "get there" when Crysis, which is due out this year, looks like that and runs on todays best hardware.

Safe bet for technology prognostication is bet short. I remember when that FF movie came out (thanks for posting those shots - they are VERY relevant), people who thought they knew/understood more about technology than they actually did were going on and on about how that level of image could "never" exist in a game in real time blah blah blah. Now, a reasonably short time later, and there are games that effectively look a LOT better than the FF movie.
 
I don't know I would say in the five to ten years range. Like most people have already mentioned we need a lot more space on video cards for the larger textures and we would also need to have video cards that can do a huge insane number of poly's and prevent antialiasing. But who knows I remember when Max Payne came out and I thought it was so realistic and photo realistic and now look at it and I could just laugh.
 
We already have borderline photorealism in games like GT:HD, which is going to improve even further in GT5...

Pics from this very forum:

c2a3c6606c.jpg

gtcar.jpg

wow3.jpg


I posted these on another forum and a handful of people actually doubted their authenticity.

Then again, it's just cars on a track, so it's pretty easy to make realistic looking. People on the other hand... that's gonna be tough. Todays shader technology fails to be photorealistic because of that "plastic coating" look...

lol 1 track with 1 car.
 
Games will never be exactly photo-realistic. Real life objects have unlimited polygons and a computer will never be able to render that.
First of all, I'm pretty sure raytracing can represent a true curved surface.
Aside from that, a person can only perceive so many polygons. You don't need an infinite number to fool the human eye.

Yes it will, eventually. Quantum computers will easily do it.
I really hope that was a joke... The chances of a computer ever being able to process an infinite amount of anything are... slim, to say the least :D .

I remember when that FF movie came out (thanks for posting those shots - they are VERY relevant) ... Now, a reasonably short time later, and there are games that effectively look a LOT better than the FF movie.
To be fair, that first shot was at about 100x100 resolution, and the second one looks like it's in 16-bit colour. No argument that the CG in that movie isn't as impressive as it once was, but those shots don't quite do it justice. I've definitely got to disagree that any games have surpassed it at this point.

Anyway, I think we're still a long way from photorealism in games, when you consider that movies aren't even there yet. Subtle effects and peripheral elements they can often get away with, but I don't think any fully CG scene I've ever seen has even come close.
 
I don't think we'll ever see a "photo-realistic" game, in the sense that a game, although as realistic as it can be, is still a game and it has other objectives, other than looking "real".

I didn't read the whole thread, but I'm sure Holograms were already mentioned. Only with them, we'll achieve true realism.
 
Video card technology is movie to fast. or maybe its the games.
Sick of 300 doller video cards lasting only 2 years tops.

They have to stop changing so much junk. This sort of stuff makes consoles look so good and worth every penny.
 
Back
Top