Photo prints from a laser printer

DellAxim

Gawd
Joined
Feb 14, 2003
Messages
999
I'm thinking about buying a laser printer, but I know absolutely nothing about them. Will a good color laser printer be able to print 8x10 photos as well as a dedicated photo printer? What is the minimum resolution needed for good quality prints?

Also, I know most ink cartridges list page yeilds at 5% coverage. What does 5% coverage really look like? I assume printing photos means 100% coverage, so if I divide the yeild by 20, will that tell me how many photos I can print with that ink?
 
For Photos, hands down, you are better off with an inkjet.

As for the second part, not sure what the 5% coverage yeild means.
 
they say a sheet of text, double spaced with standard margins and standard font is about 6-8 percent coverage.

as far as photos, stick with inkjet. get a cheap laser for text, and a photo inkjet.
 
Well, the thing is I'm going to be printing hundreds of 8x10s...maybe as high as 1000/year. As far as I can tell the dedicated photo printers seem to be ~$1.50-2.50 per 8x10, but if my yeild calculations are close I think most lasers are way under a buck.

When I say laser printer, I mean in the $500-1000 range. Cost per print is my main concern, but it has to be good quality too.
 
For printing photos, buy a photo printer.

A laser printer WILL NOT print photos very well. Even a higher resolution one will not print skin tones properly, due to the way the toners are layered onto the paper one at a time.

A photo printer has 5 inks. There is a light cyan and light magenta that are used sepcifically for printing skin tones more realisticly.

As was said before, buy 2 printers. A good photo-only printer, and a cheaper color laser.

Photo-only printers print onto photo paper only, or sometimes onto rolls of photo paper.
 
Buy a photo printer for photos. Hands down.

Buy a laser printer for text. It is better 99.9% of the time.


I have an HP LaserJet 1300 (B&W) and a Epson Stylus Photo 2200 (prints on 13 inch wide media).

The way toner works makes it horrible to reproduce photo-realistic colors. The dithering is obvious and repulsive. Especially in B&W. My inkjet printer does awesome B&W prints, and awesome color prints...you can't see the gradient transitions because it is so smooth. But with the laserjet...woe be the person who tries. You also can't really run the heavy photo-paper through a laserjet...it doesn't work.

Toner does alright for solid simple/primary colors. My laserjet owns the inkjet in speed for text. And for solid blacks it looks great. For greys and other complex tones the laserjet leaves a very obvious pattern that is bothersome. The inkjet doesn't do that at all.

You also need to consider the quality of the components in the printer. If I get high-coverage pages with my laserjet printer I begin to notice some specs in the page, and upon further investigation I realize these areas almost never have toner coverage. Or patterns develop overtime and I need to knock the toner around a bit. This doesn't really happen with inkjet once you clean and align the printer heads.

Remember:
Laser - text
Ink - photos
 
5% coverage is a standard business letter.

-Larry

DellAxim said:
I'm thinking about buying a laser printer, but I know absolutely nothing about them. Will a good color laser printer be able to print 8x10 photos as well as a dedicated photo printer? What is the minimum resolution needed for good quality prints?

Also, I know most ink cartridges list page yeilds at 5% coverage. What does 5% coverage really look like? I assume printing photos means 100% coverage, so if I divide the yeild by 20, will that tell me how many photos I can print with that ink?
 
Could be cheaper to use some printing service in internet for that number of photos..

Lasers are bad.. but I have used Xerox (formerly Tektronix made) WAX-printers, some years ago, and photo-quality was very nice (almost up to inkjet, nice glossy wax surface)!
Phaser 8500 is about 900$ I think. Have not used that model myself though.
 
I think you approach InkJet costs with Wax Thermal though.

Anyone needing to print that many pictures is in for one hell of a Bill either way :)

If going inkjet, I'd definitely go with one of the 7-color canons. Print costs don't get any cheaper I don't believe.

-Larry
 
Back
Top