PFSense: Router vs. Firewall

Ur_Mom

Fully [H]
Joined
May 15, 2006
Messages
20,918
I am wanting to deploy a PFSense firewall into my home network. However, I was wondering what the benefit would be if I were to put it in behind a Cisco 3600 router rather than having it do all the routing duties. It will be in a more than capable machine (A64 4400X2, 2 GB DDR2). It will be doing mostly firewall duties and running snort.

I've heard great things about the wonderful traffic shaping and QoS, but would I benefit from that in a home environment? I would like to give priority to streaming video, browsing and VoIP, and less to downloads. Would the Cisco be able to do good QoS? Or would I be better off just running the PFSense? The Cisco also connects to my home network lab (Cisco routers, switches, etc. for studying).

Also thinking about running VPN, if that matters a lot... Would like to securely connect to home network while traveling.
 
3600s are ancient and can easily be overwhelmed by modern broadband. That would not be my first choice.
 
To benefit from traffic shaping/QoS of PFSense..you want it to be your edge device. Putting another older router in front if it....you'd receive no benefit from PFSense?
 
Back
Top