Pentium M-4 in a desktop

Hippie

n00b
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
49
Would it work to put my pentium m-4 processor in a desktop? I've got an abit IS7 with 865PE chipset.
 
It should work. I stuck my old P4-M 2GHz in a cheap ECS board and it ran without problems for testing before I sold it (and later the whole laptop with a new CPU).

One problem could be microcode updates if the BIOS doesn't have those for the P4-M. Not a huge deal.
 
Well I called abit(my board manufacturer) and they said it would NOT work, but i think they're full of crap. Not only that, but that they didn't even make a board that would work. They said something about it being unable to get the CPUID, but would that even matter?
 
I had a P4 1.6 Ghz mobile and also ran it in a cheap ECS 848P-A motherboard. In my case the board only recognized it as a 1.2 Ghz processor. The reason for this is the speed step technology built into the processor. I was able to overclock the chip to over 2.4 Ghz with Mushkin PC3200 Ram.


Here's a link:

http://www.vr-zone.com/guides/Intel/P4M/

Novensu
 
Hey thanks for that link. I think ill just plug it in and see what happens. Worst case, it doesnt boot, right? However, is it even much of an upgrade? My current processor is a 2.4 northwood, 533MHz fsb, 512 L2. The new one is a 3.2E prescott, 1024M L2 and 533MHz fsb. Thanks again for the help.
 
Ok, so ive plugged it in, its looking alright i suppose, but it doesnt seem to be working as well as it should. I think its that whole speedstep thing, anyone know how to disable it?
thanks
 
If you can't disable the speed step you can probably use it, theres a program (I can't remember the name right now, it's CPUID or something like that) that can adjust your multiplier and voltage on the fly depending on the load.
 
I have CPU-Z, and it will detect all that kind of stuff, but is it even possible to disable or use speed step with software? I would think any kind of program that did that would be in the BIOS.
 
It is my understanding that the multipler is locked due to the fact the motherboard does not recognize the speedstep technology. I was only able to push the FSB to make up for the multiplier.

Novensu
 
Is it just me, or is this thing seriously underperforming?
Screen.JPG


Sorry about the huge picture
 
CPU-Z reports the clock speed at what it would/should be without speedstep.

But because your BIOS dosn't support speedstep, the CPU runs at the lowest multiplier that speedstep allows, even though it reports differently.

So your MB thinks that the CPU is running at 4GHZ, when in reality it is running at something much lower, from the benchmarks it looks like around 2.6GHZ. (so a multiplier of 9 I would guess)

Here is a link to someone else with the same problem, he finally gave up and got a desktop CPU: http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?t=39193&page=1&pp=25

==>Lazn
 
Know of any motherboards that would support this chip? If the multiplier was ACTUALLY running at 14, I would imagine this chip would kick some solid ass.
 
Hippie said:
Know of any motherboards that would support this chip? If the multiplier was ACTUALLY running at 14, I would imagine this chip would kick some solid ass.

Unfortunatly, no I don't.

People have gone as far as trying motherboards with SIS chipsets that are used both Mobile and Desktop boards with no luck.

I have not studied the pinout of the P4, but I wonder if it could be wire hacked to a higher muliplier..

==>Lazn
 
OK here it is.. I dug it up. I'm using CrystalCPUID on my other rig with a mobile Barton 2500+ The program loads on startup, I have it set to run in the tray. It changes multiplier & voltage on the fly from within Windows. I'd post a screeny but I couldn't???
 
Well thanks for the CrystalCPUID tip, but unfortunatly that only works on select AMD's. However, one thing that I noticed with CrystalCPUID, is that it was able to detect the Speedstep technology present in the chip. This lead me to beleive that I could disable speedstep in windows without disabling it in BIOS. This also shows that my BIOS IS able to detect it. There's got to be someway to disable it... My new trick is im going to update to Windows XP SP2, and see if that changes anything.... Thanks for all your help.
 
Yeah, so updating to SP2 didn't do a damn thing except for crapped up my system. so i got rid of it, still looking for a magic program or technique to turn speedstep off. Perhaps if i purchased a new motherboard, abit IC7 possibly, it would default to the higher multiplier?
 
already tried that one, it says its running on performance, but its no different. thanks though
 
Hippie said:
Well I called abit(my board manufacturer) and they said it would NOT work, but i think they're full of crap. Not only that, but that they didn't even make a board that would work. They said something about it being unable to get the CPUID, but would that even matter?

They may have been thinking of the Pentium M not the Pentium 4 M. The Pentium 4 M should if it's pin compatible, but the Pentium M (Banias and Dothan) will not.
 
The never ending multipler problem LOL

I still have my P4M 1.6 with no solution :(
 
if its Dothan's you're all talking about, then they wont work on i865/i875 desktop boards. Although they have the same number of pins as a regular P4, the pin layout is alot different and as such named s479 to avoid confusion.

DFI has released the 855GME-MGF micro-ATX desktop board based on the i855 chipset, its this kind of mainboard you will need if you wish to run Pentium-M processors on the desktop.

The board supports upto 533mhz FSB, so the latest Dothans can be used on it, but memory is restricted to DDR333 (PC2700).

on the other hand, ive seen a 1.5Ghz Dothan clocked to 2.435Ghz on stock cooling, which gives a nice 34sec SuperPI 1M. so imagine the newer 2Ghz dothans on a prommie :eek:

So basically shove some DDR400 (PC3200) in this thing and pump up the FSB to reach some ideal speeds

Also this board has a PCIe 16x slot, ideal for the latest 6800 Ultra's or X800 XT-PE's ;)

Hope thats given you lot some insight into this dark area of running Mobile chips in a desktop.

Treble :D
 
Hippie said:
Well I called abit(my board manufacturer) and they said it would NOT work, but i think they're full of crap. Not only that, but that they didn't even make a board that would work. They said something about it being unable to get the CPUID, but would that even matter?
It isn't what it was built for, so of course they'll tell you it won't work.

99% of the manufacturers out there do not help tweakers and such.

Welcome to the wonderful world of hardware.

and for the record, I've had CPUz give me faulty fsb and multiplier value's, however it has always detected the correct clock speed.
 
I've had my P4-M 1.8 (C1, Northwood-based) running successfully at 4.2Ghz for quite a few months, now! The speedstep multiplier on my IC7 seems entirely dependant on either voltage or CPU load.
 
I guess I should have posted my system specs a while ago:
3.2Ghz P4-M, 1024L2 cache
Chaintech Apogee GeForce 6800 128Mb AGP
1 Gig Kingston ValueRam PC3200
Dual Western Digital 80GB w/ 8Mb cache, not in RAID
Abit IS7 w/ i865PE chipset

i was under the impression that the Dothan was the Mobile processor only, not the P4-M.
In any case, I think im just gonna have to get a new mobo to get this thing working at the rated multiplier, I was looking at the new i855 chipset boards from DFI and AOpen, but these boards are a little expensive(250$), only support AGP 4x, and DDR333. Not to mention that it says its meant for a 479 slot(would a 478 work?). So im at a loss. I dont necessarily need to control speestep, if I can find a motherboard that would default the multiplier to something other than the lowest setting, thats fine with me. but i only have like 100$ to do it with. :(

Too bad too, this chip would have kicked some ass.
 
Hippie said:
I guess I should have posted my system specs a while ago:
3.2Ghz P4-M, 1024L2 cache
Chaintech Apogee GeForce 6800 128Mb AGP
1 Gig Kingston ValueRam PC3200
Dual Western Digital 80GB w/ 8Mb cache, not in RAID
Abit IS7 w/ i865PE chipset

i was under the impression that the Dothan was the Mobile processor only, not the P4-M.
In any case, I think im just gonna have to get a new mobo to get this thing working at the rated multiplier, I was looking at the new i855 chipset boards from DFI and AOpen, but these boards are a little expensive(250$), only support AGP 4x, and DDR333. Not to mention that it says its meant for a 479 slot(would a 478 work?). So im at a loss. I dont necessarily need to control speestep, if I can find a motherboard that would default the multiplier to something other than the lowest setting, thats fine with me. but i only have like 100$ to do it with. :(

Too bad too, this chip would have kicked some ass.
Get the IC7, works great for me! That, or you could use the $100 to take the re-stocking hit, and get a Desktop CPU.
And no, the Dothan and Pentium 4's are different electronically, aside from the pin-out.
 
Schpanky: does it actually utilize the speedstep? So if you're playing a game or using something, the multiplier runs at full tilt? or do you just have it overclocked so much that the multiplier is irrelevant? Could you post a screen shot? thanks
 
Windows controls the speedstep multiplier based on the load being put on the CPU as well as what sort of power scheme you have set. Its possible that it will have no effect for obvious incompatibility reasons, but try going into your power options and changing the current scheme to "Home/Office Desk," "Always On," or "Minimal Power Management." Try all 3. Rerun some benchmarks.

Also might want to try some simple "real" benchmarks rather than synthetic ones, just to see if the actual performance difference is as dramatic as sandra tells you.

One more thing. If you right click on My Computer and hit Properties, what speed is displayed? On my laptop it reports the max speed as well as the actual speed, correctly, however cpu-z also reports the correct speed so it's no guarantee for you.
 
So I tried editing my power options, and benchmarking, with no success. When I right click on my computer and do properties, it displays the rated speed (3.2GHz) and the "real" speed that I overclocked it too(4.07GHz), which is incorrect. I have found that in my BIOS, it displays a second clock speed, in softmenu, it has "estimated CPU speed" or something like that, and it reads 2.4 GHz. This is unhelpful though, as its kind of obvious its not running at 4.07 GHz(though it probably could).

At this point I think my best choice would be to go with another motherboard, or overclock the bejesus out of this thing, as my temp is only at 32 idle, and 38 under load, and my RAM is actually underclocked.

Any suggestions on what motherboard to check out? i know someone mentioned the IC7, but did the IC7 actually default it to the higher multiplier? thanks everyone.
 
Nope, motherboard shows 4.07GHz. There is a space where it shows the estimated speed. That says its at 2.38GHz, which i believe is true. but thats it.
 
you say your rams underclocked right now

p4s are very memory bandwidth hungry, so this is probably also hurting your performance(assuming you ram is not faster than pc3200).

The thing with speed step is it only ever raises the cpu to its full speed when its required. So when your doing everyday desktop stuff on the computer it makes sense that it would not goto the full 4ghz only 2.4ghz instead. Try running a graphically intensive game and alt-tabbing and then checking your cpu speed.
 
OK, there is a lot of bad information here. Let me try to straighten it out.

The P4M and the PM (Dothan) are two totally different chips. The new 855GME chipset board only supports the PM. Even though the pinouts appear the same/similar, they are electrically different.

Whenever you put a mobile chip in a desktop, it will default to the lowest speedstep multiplier. For the northwood chips, the multiplier was 12. I don't know what the prescott core mobile chips default to. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO CHANGE THE MULTIPLIER ON A DESKTOP BOARD TO USE THE CORRECT MULTIPLIER. There is no software and no pin trick. The chipset/bios just aren't compatible. The chips work well, but you just have to use a really high FSB.

Mobile celerons make very nice desktop CPUs. They do not support speedstep, so you can keep your multiplier, plus they have twice the cache of a desktop celeron.
 
BigBadBiologist said:
OK, there is a lot of bad information here. Let me try to straighten it out.

The P4M and the PM (Dothan) are two totally different chips. The new 855GME chipset board only supports the PM. Even though the pinouts appear the same/similar, they are electrically different.

Whenever you put a mobile chip in a desktop, it will default to the lowest speedstep multiplier. For the northwood chips, the multiplier was 12. I don't know what the prescott core mobile chips default to. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO CHANGE THE MULTIPLIER ON A DESKTOP BOARD TO USE THE CORRECT MULTIPLIER. There is no software and no pin trick. The chipset/bios just aren't compatible. The chips work well, but you just have to use a really high FSB.

Mobile celerons make very nice desktop CPUs. They do not support speedstep, so you can keep your multiplier, plus they have twice the cache of a desktop celeron.
One clarification. The Pentium M is electrically and signally compatible, just pin incompatible. The entire pinout has been offset diagonally by one pin from the P4. Making an adaptor would not be an impossible project.
 
You say its impossible to change the multiplier in any way? What sources do you have that support this? I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just curious, as i've spent a good deal of time trying to do this. Thanks.
 
I've read a lot of stuff including the intel spec sheets on the P4 and P4M CPUs. I've played around a lot with (Northwood) P4M and P4M Celeron CPUs on lots of different motherboards and chipsets. I speak from data that's out there and from experience.
 
Back
Top