PCI Express info?

nlz242

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 11, 2002
Messages
253
Noob question, but i was wondering:

Are 16x pci-e slots "physicaly" compatible with 1x cards (2x, 4x or anything below 16x)
if i had a pci-e raid card using a 4x slot (i know it doesnt existe right now), could i fit it in a 16x slot ?

i know most board today offer only around 20 lanes. But lets say we had board/chipset with plenty of lanes, would a board filled with 16x (or even 32x) slot could accomodate slower cards
 
I am fairly sure the answer is yes.

You can not put a 16x card in a 1x slot, but you could go the other way and put a 1x card in a 16x slot.

Why you would is a totally different question.

==>Lazn
 
Why? Today, it would be useless. But in a near future, where we would have multiple high X slots, it could become "standard" to do so
 
nlz242 said:
Why? Today, it would be useless. But in a near future, where we would have multiple high X slots, it could become "standard" to do so

Eventually this may be true.. but I doubt it will be any time soon.

Everyone harps on the advantage of PCI-E being a hub and spoke system, no shared bandwidth between slots like the old PCI was... But think about that.. if you look at your PCI slots all the "wires" on the motherboard go between the PCI slots, and only one end of them needs to go back to the chipset. Now look at a PCI-E motheboard, each PCI-E slot has to have it's "wires" go back to the chipset, meaning the chipset must have pins for every PCI-E pin, making it quite difficult to have lots and lots of PCI-E lanes. A 4x slot is literally made of 4 1x slots, so it takes 4 times the pins on the chipset to support vs a 1x slot, and it is harder to route all those "wires" on the motherboard.

==>Lazn
 
Lazn_Work, very interesting!!
I hadnt tought about it this way

But with modern techniques, we can fit much more layers than before. (Ie. when the 9700 came out, this was a "big" subject of discussion.)
+ The extreme amount of pins on modern cpu also require more routing...

But i do agree with what you said tho, that its unlikely to happen
 
nlz242 said:
Lazn_Work, very interesting!!
I hadnt tought about it this way

But with modern techniques, we can fit much more layers than before. (Ie. when the 9700 came out, this was a "big" subject of discussion.)
+ The extreme amount of pins on modern cpu also require more routing...

But i do agree with what you said tho, that its unlikely to happen

Oh it is still going to happen, it will just take longer... I also would not be suprized if it were AMD's that get ahead on this... Because A64's have the memory controller on the CPU, the northbridge suddenly becomes 372 pins (for DCDDR) simpler, that is a lot of pins for PCI-E. It doesn't solve the routing, but as you said we are getting more layers..

So it will happen, just not overnight.

==>Lazn
 
I have been wondering that same thing. well sort of.

I am considering getting a dell :( before you mock me, it costs 650 for a poweredge system that has ddr2, dual xeon with 64 bit ext(only one cpu at that price) it is essentially the same motherboard as on the workstation 670(which costs a hell of alot more) except it has onboard video and a 8x pci-e slot. I was curious if this could handle video cards. cause if so this could be one hell of a value for a dual cpu workstation(hell just a motherboard like this goes for about 500).
 
whoreable said:
I have been wondering that same thing. well sort of.

I am considering getting a dell :( before you mock me, it costs 650 for a poweredge system that has ddr2, dual xeon with 64 bit ext(only one cpu at that price) it is essentially the same motherboard as on the workstation 670(which costs a hell of alot more) except it has onboard video and a 8x pci-e slot. I was curious if this could handle video cards. cause if so this could be one hell of a value for a dual cpu workstation(hell just a motherboard like this goes for about 500).

Is the 8x PCI-e slot physically (not electrically) a 16x slot? If so, then yes. If it is shorter, then no you could not put a bigger card into a smaller slot.

==>Lazn
 
shaihulud said:
they are not interchangable. a 1x will not work in a 4x. however, with pcie there will be different ways to connect components. i suggest reading this: http://www.intel.com/technology/pciexpress/devnet/

Errm yes a 1x will work in a 4x or 16x slot. http://www.interfacebus.com/Design_Connector_PCI_Express.html
"A PCI express card is upward compatible, so a 1x card will fit in any card slot, a 4x card will fit into an 8 or 16x port and so on. The pinout follows: ..."

http://www.machinedesign.com/ASP/strArticleID/55541/strSite/MDSite/viewSelectedArticle.asp
"The serial nature of the PCI Express protocol will make it possible to plug smaller PCI Express cards into larger slots -- PCI Express circuits will be smart enough to discern that fewer lanes are connected, then configure themselves to handle what they find."

==>Lazn
 
Back
Top