PC newbie needs suggestions on a Conroe system

Black Morty Rackham

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jan 8, 2004
Messages
4,728
I'm not entirely sure this is the right part of the forum, since it concerns all the parts of the system. But since the one constant in it is the E6600, I figured this would be the place. If a moderator disagrees, I apologize in advance. Also, I did check out the first few pages of the Intel-specific forums (as well as a few other forums), but didn't really find the answers to my questions.

Long story short: I'm going to build a Conroe system, like everybody else. This is the first PC I'll ever buy, though not the first one I've assembled (I've done a fair share of tinkering). However, I've been out of the hardware loop for a while, so I figured I'd run the system specs by you guys, so you can tell me if it'll work well. The system will be used mainly as a 3D graphics workstation (Lightwave and modo are my main applications). I mostly do architectural visualization and such. No SLI/Crossfire. In fact, I won't really need all that much GPU performance at all. My old workstation had a Radeon 9800 Pro with 256 megs of VRAM, and it was the least of my issues. My main demand is CPU performance. Those global illumination renders really take a lot of time, and that's a big productivity killer. It will be overclocked as much as I can while maintaining perfect stability.

Here are the parts I had in mind:

Chassis/PSU: Antec Sonata 2
Is 450 watts enough? Is it a good power supply? I know how much trouble you can get by having a bad PSU, but this case is fairly cheap and supposedly quiet. I do NOT want side windows or anything like that. This is a spartan case, which is fine by me. According to this thread, a Sonata 2 should be fine, but I'd like a second opinion on that.

Mother board: ASUS P5W-DH
I heard it's a good mother board, and a good overclocker. It's pretty expensive though (I am on a rather limited budget). Are there cheaper options that are good?

CPU: Core 2 Duo E6600
The obvious choice, really. With overclocking, I can probably reach about the same speeds as I could with an E6700, and it's a lot cheaper.

Cooling: Sunbeam Tuniq Tower 120
Seems like a highly competent cooling unit, and it's not too expensive.

RAM: 2 x Kingston 1Gb DDR2 PC5300
What can I say? It's cheap. Supposedly, it's CL5, but to be honest, I'm not really sure what that means... :eek: Will it cause issues with overclocking? What RAM is recomended?

Video card: The eternal question: ATI or Nvidia? Any problems with either when it comes to motherboard compatibility and the like? Either way, it will probably be something in the $150 class, because that's all I can afford at the moment. I can always upgrade later. :)

Does this seem like a good system for a PC hardware/overclocking newbie?


Thanks in advance. :)



Edit: Now that I think about it, maybe I should have placed this in "General hardware"?
 
That's a terrible system!!!!! You should send it over to me right away so I can get it off your hands! :D

Seriously thought, it seems like a solid setup. Just make sure the Tower fits in your case cause that thing is HUGE!

Also probably go for some PC2 6400 for overclocking.
 
Pardon my ignorance, but why would PC6400 let me overclock more than PC5300?

And I haven't actually bought it yet, so I couldn't send it to you even if I wanted! Which I don't! ;)


Edit: The Tuniq Tower should probably fit in the Sonata 2. The case is 20.6 centimeters wide, and the tower is 15.5 centimeters tall. You have to subtract a few centimeters for the door and motherboard and whatnot, but I think it fits.
 
Because you're going to be overclocking through the FSB. So you want your RAM to scale with your FSB, and not hold you back.

E6600 has a 9x multiplier. Default is 266x9=2.4.

Example: If you're shooting for 400FSB which is 3.6ghz on that 6600 then that means you're RAM should be running at DDR2 800.

Because 1:1 ratio
FSB (400): RAM (400)
cpu frequency=400x9=3600mhz: DDR2=400x2=800mhz

RAM specs are a bit gimmicky. I mean theoretically DDR2 667 with tighter timings would basically be the same as DDR2 800 with slower timings because you can usually loosen timings and get a higher frequency.

However, you're getting 5-5-5 RAM, which doesn't seem to leave lots of room for overclock. So theoretically if you couldn't overclock that DDR2 667 you're looking at a cpu OC of about 3.00ghz and 333FSB.
 
Black Morty Rackham said:
Pardon my ignorance, but why would PC6400 let me overclock more than PC5300?
The conroe FSB is quad pumped (266.666 x 4 = 1066).

Your ram can limit your overclock. Best to show math examples.

Ok its DDR2, (double), so you divide by two, and the E6600 has a multiplier of 9.

DDR2-800 (aka PC2-6400) will allow you to reach 3.6Ghz on a E6600 ((800 / 2) * 9).
DDR2-667 (aka PC2-5400) will allow you to reach 3.0Ghz on a E6600 ((667 / 2) * 9).
DDR2-1066 (aka PC2-8500) will allow you to reach 4.7Ghz on a E6600 ((1066 / 2) * 9).

You get the idea.

(Of course in reality your ram may not be the bottleneck, other things like you boards max FSB will probably be reached first)
 
Ah, okay. Thanks! But does it mean I should try to get faster memory, or get memory that overclocks better? How about some PC6400 Corsair with 4-4-4-12 timings? It's a lot more expensive, but if it means I can reach ~4 GHz instead of ~3.5 GHz, it might just be worth it.
 
Please be a smart shopper and check Pricewatch and Froogle to compare prices. Shop at places that also combind shipping costs.
 
LOL. Thanks for clearing that up Donnie. :)

You don't necessarily need really tight timings for the DDR2 800 RAM unless you're reaching for DDR2 1000 speeds. If you're going for 4ghz then yeah you'll probably need to shell out the cash.

However, I think 3.6 is about where the 6600 tops out on air, so unless you're going for H20 or phase, keep that in mind.
 
http://anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=2797&p=3

They got an E6600 to 4 GHz using the Tuniq Tower. And yeah, 4 GHz would probably be ideal. Basically, I'm only building a computer because the Mac Pro is out of my budget. The closer I get to dual Woodcrest performance, the better. ;) With 2x4 GHz, that's a total of 8 GHz. Compared to the combined 10.64 GHz of dual 2.66 GHz Woodcrests, it's not half bad. At least not when you consider the fact that it only costs about 2/3rds as much. Also, if I build it myself, I'll be able to upgrade to the quad-core once it's out. Awesome.



And of course I'll find out which place is the cheapest! I checked E6600 prices earlier this week, and it varied between 2800 and 3300 SEK. That's a pretty substantial difference.
 
mayakindaguy said:
LOL. Thanks for clearing that up Donnie. :)

You don't necessarily need really tight timings for the DDR2 800 RAM unless you're reaching for DDR2 1000 speeds. If you're going for 4ghz then yeah you'll probably need to shell out the cash.

However, I think 3.6 is about where the 6600 tops out on air, so unless you're going for H20 or phase, keep that in mind.

The links didn't work so I deleted most of my post, sorry!
I'd go with;
Ninja Cooler
Cooler Master case Newegg has one on sale for just $45 last time I checked stay away from Lian Li.
I only Use Antec PSUs now and the TP2 550W is $76
Use any 667 RAM that shows 1.8 to 1.9V, i965 *SEEMs to use a 1.9V default setting. Good 1.9V 667 is just as good or even better than cheap DDR2-800 Problems with some DDR2-800 that might not work with nothing less than 2.1v is a problem for more than just Gigabyte BTW. In fact, mine didn't work with the GSkill DDR2-800 even at 2.3V. I'm having to RMA my GSkill and I've been warned that it can take at least two weeks or longer to get something works.
I went with an E6400 instead of the E6600.
Tight timmings are looking more like HYPE than anything else.

Again, sorry for the partial post!
 
Black Morty Rackham said:
http://anandtech.com/mb/showdoc.aspx?i=2797&p=3

They got an E6600 to 4 GHz using the Tuniq Tower. And yeah, 4 GHz would probably be ideal. Basically, I'm only building a computer because the Mac Pro is out of my budget. The closer I get to dual Woodcrest performance, the better. ;) With 2x4 GHz, that's a total of 8 GHz. Compared to the combined 10.64 GHz of dual 2.66 GHz Woodcrests, it's not half bad. At least not when you consider the fact that it only costs about 2/3rds as much. Also, if I build it myself, I'll be able to upgrade to the quad-core once it's out. Awesome.

And of course I'll find out which place is the cheapest! I checked E6600 prices earlier this week, and it varied between 2800 and 3300 SEK. That's a pretty substantial difference.

Video Cards: there are good sales on the 256MB 7900GT and X1800XLs, not bad deals on the X1900XL.
 
I'm in Sweden, so no Newegg for me. Specific "good deals" are pretty much irrelevant. But thanks, anyway! :)



Donnie27, how do I know which RAM is good, then?
 
Antec power supplys are nice... You shouldn't have any problems...

With video card I suggest you up it up to 1800xt... It's only $200 + 6 shipping on newegg...

Good price performance ration at the moment...

For $150 you will end up with 7600gt or x850xt....
 
I'd stay away from the Sonata. I have one but it's kinda cramped inside, especially if you're planning on overclocking and airflow is important. I'd recommend the P180, it's super cheap these days, under $100 at some places after a rebate.
 
psychot|K said:
I'd stay away from the Sonata. I have one but it's kinda cramped inside, especially if you're planning on overclocking and airflow is important. I'd recommend the P180, it's super cheap these days, under $100 at some places after a rebate.
Cheapest I could find in Sweden was $50 more than the Sonata, and that was without a PSU...
 
Black Morty Rackham said:
I'm in Sweden, so no Newegg for me. Specific "good deals" are pretty much irrelevant. But thanks, anyway! :)

Donnie27, how do I know which RAM is good, then?

I'm NOT in Sweden so I didn't give you links:)

Look for low voltage RAM that will prove more important than Speed and lower latency. Most i965 boards boot up with only 1.9V. Many of the Higher speed DDR2 RAM use 2.0 up to 2.3V. This is a big NO-NO.

I even used a lower voltage stick to get the system started and then installed the GSkill, it was unstable at 2.2V and I'm not taking chances with 2.3v long term.

If I were given a chance to start over, I would buy DDR2 800 1.9v, Conroe performs just as well with DDR2 667.

Do some shopping on your own. What's good here might suck over there price wise.
 
None of the swedish stores I've found show the voltage of the memory, unfortunately. Are all memory modules of the same model made the same? For example, Newegg does display the voltage. Could I just check Newegg, and buy the same exact type/brand, and expect the same voltage? I'm assuming this is the case. I found a bunch of 1 GB sticks on Newegg that supposedly ran at 1.8 volts, and I was able to find most of them in Sweden for fairly low prices. Would something like this or this work well?
 
Black Morty Rackham said:
None of the swedish stores I've found show the voltage of the memory, unfortunately. Are all memory modules of the same model made the same? For example, Newegg does display the voltage. Could I just check Newegg, and buy the same exact type/brand, and expect the same voltage? I'm assuming this is the case. I found a bunch of 1 GB sticks on Newegg that supposedly ran at 1.8 volts, and I was able to find most of them in Sweden for fairly low prices. Would something like this or this work well?

They should be the same.
 
I got another idea. The quad-core Kentsfield is due in something like six months, right? Well, I can't wait that long, but I can buy a low-end Core 2 Duo instead, and get away with a much cheaper system that should still offer at least five or six times the rendering performance of my iBook G4. When the Kentsfield is released, I'll upgrade the CPU and get a system that probably outperforms the Mac Pro I've been toying with the idea of playing.

Decisions, decisions...
 
Since price is a relatively large issue for me, I've pretty much decided to go with the following:

Sonata 2
P5W DH
E6400 or E6300
Something along the lines of a Radeon X1600 Pro

The reason I'll go with such a low-end processor, yet fairly high-end motherboard, is because I will upgrade it to the Kentsfield as soon as it is released. Now, my main concern is RAM. Really, what should I get? Will the PC4200 Kingston RAM overclock well? I'm guessing that since the FSB and memory run at the same frequency, I can basically overclock until either the RAM doesn't go higher, or the CPU doesn't go higher. Right? Well, how high does cheap RAM go, anyway?
 
Black Morty Rackham said:
I got another idea. The quad-core Kentsfield is due in something like six months, right? Well, I can't wait that long, but I can buy a low-end Core 2 Duo instead, and get away with a much cheaper system that should still offer at least five or six times the rendering performance of my iBook G4. When the Kentsfield is released, I'll upgrade the CPU and get a system that probably outperforms the Mac Pro I've been toying with the idea of playing.

Decisions, decisions...

I'm honestly not interested in Kentsfield. I agree, a better board is always a good choice.
 
3D rendering scales pretty much linearly with the number of cores. A 3 GHz Kentsfield is pretty much twice as fast as a 3 GHz Conroe for the stuff I do. I'm VERY interested in quadcores. ;)
 
Back
Top