PC 3424P remove VLAN

RocketTech

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 7, 2009
Messages
2,359
Dunno if it's been a long day or I'm missing something- I'm trying to remove the default VLAN 1 from g4. I've created 3 VLANs, 10, 1000, 4010. Assigned all three to g4 with 'switchport trunk allowed vlan', confirmed with 'show interface switchport ethernet g4'. Set VLAN 10 as native for the trunk with 'switchport trunk native vlan 10' with result 'Port is Trunk in VLAN 10.' Attempted removal of VLAN 1 from g4 with 'switchport trunk allowed vlan remove 1' with result 'VLAN was not created by user.'

'show interface switchport ethernet g4' shows port mode as trunk and a member in 4 VLANS- 1,10,1000,4010

What am I doing wrong?
 
According to Google, this is a Dell switch right?
Can you go into the VLAN 1 interface and shut it down?

On the documentation, you can suspend the VLAN, have you tried that?

vlan vlan-id [name vlan-name] media ethernet [state {suspend | active}]
no vlan vlan-id [name | state]

vlan-id - ID of the configured VLAN. (Range: 1-4094, no leading zeroes)
name - Keyword to be followed by the VLAN name.
vlan-name - ASCII string 1 to 32 characters.
media ethernet - Ethernet media type.
state - Keyword to be followed by the VLAN state.
active - VLAN is operational.
suspend - VLAN is suspended. Suspended VLANs do not pass packets.

http://docs.us.dell.com/support/sys...l=en&s=dhs&~file=/network/5p788/clig/vlan.htm
 
Yeah. it's a Dell PowerConnect 3224P, same CLI as a regular 3224/3248. I have the documentation, I've RTFM, the manual leaves a little to be desired.
I can get vlan1 off of e1by using 'switchport access vlan 10' which simply sets port 1 to untagged on VLAN 10 instead of VLAN, essentially taking VLAN1 off of port 1. This is fine, but the same command won't work on port g4, i'm guessing because I set it to trunk.
I tried 'no vlan 1' with result 'Default VLAN cannot be removed by user.'
The documentation specifically states VLAN 1 cannot be suspended
 
I don't think you can remove vlan 1 on the layer 2 switches (3424,3448, 3524, 3548). I just looked at a few of our switches and the trunk ports have vlan 1 on all of them. I also get the same here.

Pretty sure you get what you get. We don't use vlan 1 for anything so it works
 
Not sure about Dell switches, but I know on Cisco Catalyst switches that you can at least shutdown VLAN 1.

VLAN 1 is present in all switches, because all ports are native to VLAN 1 by default. Even on little crap consumer switches from Best Buy.

I'm surprised though you can at least shut down the VLAN.
 
The confusing thing is it can be taken off an access port (untagged VLAN) but not off a tagged Trunk. Maybe it doesn't make a difference, I'll try just ignoring it.
Thanks for all the help!
 
Ok, I was able to remove VLAN1 from selected interfaces by first setting switchport mode to access and assigning a vlan, works on the trunk as well, but now you have an untagged VLAN on the trunk which may defeat the purpose.
Thanks again for the input.
 
an untagged vlan on the trunk is fine, so long as you can tag other vlans on the trunk as well.

I don't know anything about Dell switches, but I know HP and other switch manufacturers don't consider a "trunk" to be the same thing as Cisco does. HP Trunk and Cisco Trunk are two different beasts.
 
Back
Top