Password Encryption Protected Under Fifth Amendment

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
In what will probably be hailed as a landmark case, a Federal Appeals court has ruled that a child pornography suspect is protected from providing information that would allow decryption of computer files under the Fifth Amendment.

“The government’s attempt to force this man to decrypt his data put him in the Catch-22 the 5th Amendment was designed to prevent - having to choose between self-incrimination or risking contempt of court”
 
I want to see this issue go all the way to the top. SCOTUS has not ruled on any of these cases yet, and there are several going on. I agree with this particular ruling though.

I always felt the other way around was equivalent to saying "Okay, the Fifth Amendment doesn't allow us to force you to tell us where the body is, but we can force you to go dig it up for us."

Government always trying to get away with things in high tech that they couldn't get away with in low tech.
 
Truecrypt FTW people. Keep your stuff safe, keep yourself safe. For no cost, in money, or system speed, whatsoever....
 
Regardless if guilty - etc.. etc... I don't give a fuck. I care about my rights - and this is one of those that I will fight to the death with. With that said, fuck you. Fuck the government. Fuck everyone. I work for myself. I live for myself.
 
Ars has a better writeup that involves more cases (their article also doesn't seem to keep screaming "child pornography justifies the suspension of the fifth amendment" so much).

Basically, the issue comes down to whether specific knowledge of the contents of the hard drive is already known; mere suspicion isn't enough to suspend a person's right to the fifth.
 
Ars has a better writeup...

Agreed. I read the Ars page on Friday. I just read the ZDnet one. I actually go out of my way to avoid their site these days. There's one writer there that's been there for years, but her lack of tech knowledge makes her sound like an idiot. I cringe every time I actually click on a link to their page and she pops up. I hate giving them traffic.

Oops. Tangent. Neat ars article. ya.
 
Sweet, so now it's not simply a matter of vocabulary when describing your computer which dictates a 5th amendment violation or not?
 
Something is being left out here. The rulling was in regards to "fishing for evidence".

-- In the case of, "they see you have an encrypted laptop and want you to decrypt", you can tell them to go outside an play a game of go eff themselves..

-- However, in the case of they saw you had a picture of your neighbor banging a little girl, it is no longer fishing..but just validating something they already know is there.

There is still a fairly wide gray line and I would like to see the USSC narrow it a bit. Still to easy to force you into the secod example than the first by word alone.
 
The huge catch here is that the 5th only covers you if they don't have other evidence indicating you have illegal stuff on your laptop. The border agent case was legit because that dumbass who got caught admitted to having stuff on his laptop.

As usual, the best course of action is to remain silent and NEVER talk to the police in these cases. Remaining silent and withholding the password is NOT probable cause. If you're stupid and incriminate yourself, you're on your own.
 
Yep. See this video. A defense attorney telling you why you should never ever talk to the police, 30 minutes in an experienced cop gives the same advice.

1) True, don't talk to the cops. But, this advice I want only my friends to hear. Crooks talking is the most effective way to keep crooks off the street.

2) Not 100% true. Even the cop, in spite of shilling for the Defense Attorney who spoke first, in the video admitted "there are a couple people I let walk away [from the interrogation room] because they were innocent." Most cops aren't out to nail innocent people. If you are innocent and you have something compelling to say, you can save yourself a lot of grief by doing some talking. Also, if you're not suspect, you don't want to turn yourself into a suspect by looking like you're hiding something.
 
Wow, this kind of honesty was unexpected from the judicial system...let's see if it sticks!
 
I always thought that physical evidence wasn't included under the 5th. The self incrimination clause wasn't really violated because the person in question did not testify against themselves. That's what that clause protects you again. Providing evidence and testifying against yourself are 2 different things. I guess because a password was required, it wasn't completely physical evidence. It gray as gray gets but this in no way is black or white. Dah well, being a law abiding citizen, these are things you don't have to worry about..lol
 
Something is being left out here. The rulling was in regards to "fishing for evidence".

-- In the case of, "they see you have an encrypted laptop and want you to decrypt", you can tell them to go outside an play a game of go eff themselves..

-- However, in the case of they saw you had a picture of your neighbor banging a little girl, it is no longer fishing..but just validating something they already know is there.

There is still a fairly wide gray line and I would like to see the USSC narrow it a bit. Still to easy to force you into the secod example than the first by word alone.
So, if someone saw you own a gun, and you are a suspect in a shooting, must you divulge the location of the gun?
 
Something is being left out here. The rulling was in regards to "fishing for evidence".

-- In the case of, "they see you have an encrypted laptop and want you to decrypt", you can tell them to go outside an play a game of go eff themselves..

-- However, in the case of they saw you had a picture of your neighbor banging a little girl, it is no longer fishing..but just validating something they already know is there.

You can still plead the fifth, it just won't do you any good since they already got evidence.
 
So, if someone saw you own a gun, and you are a suspect in a shooting, must you divulge the location of the gun?

No..that isn't what I posted. I said "they saw it" (e.g. the police), then yes, you would. In case you just said, it falls into the first case of "fishing" which you have no legal obligation to assist in.
 
To clarify then. If my neighbor swears she saw me shoot her cat, I would be required to hand over the weapon?
 
I always thought that physical evidence wasn't included under the 5th. The self incrimination clause wasn't really violated because the person in question did not testify against themselves. That's what that clause protects you again. Providing evidence and testifying against yourself are 2 different things. I guess because a password was required, it wasn't completely physical evidence. It gray as gray gets but this in no way is black or white. Dah well, being a law abiding citizen, these are things you don't have to worry about..lol

Providing evidence IS testifying against yourself, and it's extremely dangerous to think otherwise. Consider the case where no such evidence exists:
"Provide it or be held indefinitely for contempt of court!"
"But it doesn't exist!"
"Then say imprisoned forever without a trial!"

This can happen in the case of passwords: How can they differentiate someone who forgot/lost their password from someone who is lying? They can't. It is simply NOT the defendant's responsibility to help prosecute themselves.
 
No..that isn't what I posted. I said "they saw it" (e.g. the police), then yes, you would. In case you just said, it falls into the first case of "fishing" which you have no legal obligation to assist in.

By, "they saw it" do you mean, "they know you're guilty?" The purpose of the trial is often to validate or dispute that entire premise.
 
As usual, the best course of action is to remain silent and NEVER talk to the police in these cases. Remaining silent and withholding the password is NOT probable cause. If you're stupid and incriminate yourself, you're on your own.

Well of course if you do have child pornography on your computer, then by all means talk away, there's nothing they can do against you ;)
 
Providing evidence IS testifying against yourself, and it's extremely dangerous to think otherwise. Consider the case where no such evidence exists:
"Provide it or be held indefinitely for contempt of court!"
"But it doesn't exist!"
"Then say imprisoned forever without a trial!"

This can happen in the case of passwords: How can they differentiate someone who forgot/lost their password from someone who is lying? They can't. It is simply NOT the defendant's responsibility to help prosecute themselves.

I'm looking at this on a broader scope. If a warrant is obtained and you open your home or car in compliance, you aren't testifying on yourself. If while getting searched, you break down and admit guilt, you have just waived your rights and testified against yourself. That is a difference.

You are also merging two different cases. The Colorado woman said she forgot her password. IIRC, the guy plead the 5th because he more than likely has kiddy porn on his computer but the 5th protects him against the assumption. lol. No matter how you feel, if you know the Constitution, you know this is gray.
 
*stay imprisoned.

Gosh, an edit button would really be useful.

lol...you aren't lying about that edit button.

I didn't know anyone of them was in jail but you can't be imprisoned forever without a formal trial...lol..
 
I'm looking at this on a broader scope. If a warrant is obtained and you open your home or car in compliance, you aren't testifying on yourself. If while getting searched, you break down and admit guilt, you have just waived your rights and testified against yourself. That is a difference.
If a warrant is obtained, it's only a matter of courtesy (and not wanting to pay repair costs) that you open your door. What the warrant does is bypass the need for your cooperation entirely, and it gives the cops the go-ahead to bust down your door if you refuse. That's quite different from actively coercing your cooperation in the matter of providing evidence or testimony (and keeping you locked up if you refuse), which is a Fifth Amendment violation.

You are also merging two different cases. The Colorado woman said she forgot her password. IIRC, the guy plead the 5th because he more than likely has kiddy porn on his computer but the 5th protects him against the assumption. lol. No matter how you feel, if you know the Constitution, you know this is gray.
I would say that if you know your Constitution, you know that both of those cases are more alike than different. :p

lol...you aren't lying about that edit button.

I didn't know anyone of them was in jail but you can't be imprisoned forever without a formal trial...lol..

Did the edit button used to be wildly abused on front page stories, or is it just an annoying precaution against such abuse?

Anyway...
Constitutionally, I agree. These contempt of court incidents have the potential to test those boundaries if they're pushed hard enough though, which is why they're invalid on their face.

(Of course, the NDAA is throwing trials out entirely for certain classes of accusations, and I don't doubt that imprisonment without trial will be expanded to cover a wider array of real or imagined offenses over time...but that's a different issue.)
 
I always thought that physical evidence wasn't included under the 5th. The self incrimination clause wasn't really violated because the person in question did not testify against themselves.

That's the way I lean. A password is like a key, not like testifying against yourself. With sufficient computing power, the police could break their way in without being given the password/key. I don't really see a 5th Amendment difference between those pictures of naked boys being in a locked box or on an encrypted drive.

Physical evidence is moving to the computer. Correspondence, financial records, etc. all use to be secured by nothing but a metal lock, if that. All this stuff has moved to a computer and it's increasingly being encrypted. 5th Amendment protection of passwords could put an end to most of the physical evidence that once could be found in the possession of the accused.
 
That's the way I lean. A password is like a key, not like testifying against yourself. With sufficient computing power, the police could break their way in without being given the password/key. I don't really see a 5th Amendment difference between those pictures of naked boys being in a locked box or on an encrypted drive.

Physical evidence is moving to the computer. Correspondence, financial records, etc. all use to be secured by nothing but a metal lock, if that. All this stuff has moved to a computer and it's increasingly being encrypted. 5th Amendment protection of passwords could put an end to most of the physical evidence that once could be found in the possession of the accused.

In another case on this issue, the court basically pointed out the fact that the Supreme Court defined a difference between a locked box and a combination safe. I.E. that you can be compelled to open a locked box, but you cannot be compelled to use a combination that you may or may not know.

Some details from the court in the case this article is about:

The question at hand is whether or not decrypting the contents of a laptop drive is testimony or simply the transfer of existent information. The court acknowledges that the drive’s files are not testimony of themselves, but writes “What is at issue is whether the act of production may have some testimonial quality sufficient to trigger Fifth Amendment protection when the production explicitly or implicitly conveys some statement of fact.” (emphasis original)

By decrypting the drives, Doe is admitting “his knowledge of the existence and location of potentially incriminating files; of his possession, control, and access to the encrypted portions of the drives; and of his capability to decrypt the files.” The court dismisses the argument that the contents of Doe’s hard drives are a foregone conclusion, noting that “Nothing… reveals that the Government knew whether any files exist or the location of those files on the hard drives; what’s more, nothing in the record illustrates that the Government knew with reasonable particularity that Doe was even capable of accessing the encrypted portions of the drives.

In other words, they believe that, like the Supreme Court ruled on combination locks, there is an implicit admission of guilt with decryption that isn't the same as "Hey stick this key in this lock and turn it for us please."
 
1) If you are innocent and you have something compelling to say, you can save yourself a lot of grief by doing some talking. Also, if you're not suspect, you don't want to turn yourself into a suspect by looking like you're hiding something.

Nah. I would NEVER talk to the cops about anything. I don't care if my next door neighbor got murdered. It doesn't matter if you know yourself to be innocent or not. You say one thing that so much as piques their interest and you can instantly find yourself as a suspect. It could be about anything and not necessarily about my neighbor being murdered.

Cop: So did you hear any odd noise from your neighbor's house?
Me: Nah, I was out getting gas in my car.

Little do you know there was a gas station that got knocked over that same night and by pure chance you and your car match that suspect's descriptions. Whether or not it was you that knocked over the gas station doesn't matter. Congratulations. You just fucked yourself.

I don't worry about looking like a suspect by keeping silent. If the cops want to throw me in jail they better bring the evidence. I'm not doing their work for them.

For the record I don't hate cops. I just need to look out for my self.

The only time you should ever talk to the cops is in the event of self defense. You will need to paint the guy you just shot in the Walmart parking lot as the aggressor and yourself as a victim. Even then you shouldn't actually say you shot the guy. Just something like "He was armed and I was scared for my life. I want my lawyer before I say anything more". That's a whole different animal though.
 
I want to see this issue go all the way to the top. SCOTUS has not ruled on any of these cases yet, and there are several going on. I agree with this particular ruling though.

It will. There are contradictory rulings which means the supreme court has no choice but to hear and rule on it when it is brought to them. It'll get to them eventually (remember high level appeals are a slow process, for many reasons).

Whenever you get contradictory circuit court rulings, you can guarantee a SC ruling is in the future. That is one of their functions is to keep the law unified.
 
Just something like "He was armed and I was scared for my life. I want my lawyer before I say anything more". That's a whole different animal though.

Police and Prosecutors have successfully argued that if you cooperate in any way, you have given up your right to silence.

You just better not hope you have some hotshot young DA looking to make a name for himself. He can't prosecute the corpse, but he sure as hell can prosecute you.
 
Police and Prosecutors have successfully argued that if you cooperate in any way, you have given up your right to silence.

Sigh. No, that is not how it works. There is no magic point at which you give up your right to remain silent. You always have it. It means just that: You can clam up and not say anything and that refusal to answer a question cannot be used.

However if you volunteer information, they can use it, even if you later decide you wish to remain silent. There are no "taksies backsies" in playground terms. Once you've said something, they are allowed to make use of it.

But it is not a case of you say something and they say "Ahh, you cooperated! You now have to answer all our questions!"

If you believe it is, you need to learn the law better.
 
Keep him in custody until it is unlocked. Create a distributed computing app that is specific to this task and have a few million people contribute to cracking it, if its nothing let him go, if its loaded with bad stuff hopefully it'll lead to more arrests.
 
Something is being left out here. The rulling was in regards to "fishing for evidence".

-- In the case of, "they see you have an encrypted laptop and want you to decrypt", you can tell them to go outside an play a game of go eff themselves..

-- However, in the case of they saw you had a picture of your neighbor banging a little girl, it is no longer fishing..but just validating something they already know is there.

There is still a fairly wide gray line and I would like to see the USSC narrow it a bit. Still to easy to force you into the secod example than the first by word alone.

yes and I am semi OK with forcing you to decrypt when they know whats on there.

but they should be able to go fishing
 
Something is being left out here. The rulling was in regards to "fishing for evidence".

-- In the case of, "they see you have an encrypted laptop and want you to decrypt", you can tell them to go outside an play a game of go eff themselves..

-- However, in the case of they saw you had a picture of your neighbor banging a little girl, it is no longer fishing..but just validating something they already know is there.

There is still a fairly wide gray line and I would like to see the USSC narrow it a bit. Still to easy to force you into the secod example than the first by word alone.

Yes, the fishing part is the key differentiator. This will likely end up at the SCOTUS at some point, I hope this stands.
 
Back
Top