Pandemic Options Include Crippling Home Modems

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
ComputerWorld says that the government, in cases of emergency, has the option of throttling your home internet connection or cutting off popular sites all together to ease congestion. You’d think the government would have more important stuff to do during a pandemic than throttling people’s net connections.

Although providers cannot identify users at the computer level to manage traffic from that point, two providers stated that if the residential Internet access network in a particular neighborhood was experiencing congestion, a provider could attempt to reduce congestion by reducing the amount of traffic that each user could send to and receive from his or her network. Such a reduction would require adjusting the configuration file within each customer's modem to temporarily reduce the maximum transmission speed that that modem was capable of performing-for example, by reducing its incoming capability from 7 Mbps to 1 Mbps.
 
I've known of this thanks to my disturbing obsession with doomer sites for quite a while now...
 
Personally I don't have a problem with this. However, with that said, it's a matter of time before someone else responds to this thread crying BIG BROTHER or bitching about how this will hurt the speed of their torrents.
 
Personally I don't have a problem with this. However, with that said, it's a matter of time before someone else responds to this thread crying BIG BROTHER or bitching about how this will hurt the speed of their torrents.

And what gives you the right to judge other people based on your ignorance and lack of experience of totalitarian regimes?
 
Of course no one will have a problem with this until their speed is cut to 1Mbps. Then what when they decide that they need even more bandwidth, so the cut everyone's speed down to 56k - they have opened the door so they can incrementally cut you off altogether.

Go on trusting Big Brother.
 
Also, I just happened to think.... I PAY FOR MY NET ACCESS. They better compensate for this encroachment on my paid service.

Of course, no one gives a crap that I don't get what I pay for. I'm already doing it with Social Security: big pay in and get far less back (maybe nothing)
 
There is no government plan to throttle the internet. They really do have better things to do. The General Accountability Office (GAO) announced the Homeland Security Department (DHS) should have a plan to do that, and Homeland Security responded with a smackdown of that idea:

. "DHS has not developed a strategy to address potential Internet congestion," the report said. It had also not even checked into whether the public or even other federal agencies would cooperate, GAO said. "The report gives the impression that there is potentially a single solution to Internet congestion that DHS could achieve if it were to develop an appropriate strategy," DHS's Jerald Levine retorted in a letter to the GAO.

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN2620750120091026?sp=true
 
Really it's only logical. Can you imagine all those people trying to update their facebook pages to "still sick" and twittering how snot green clashes with their clothes?
 
Had the stupid internet providers actually have on hand the bandwidth they promise to each of their customers, there wouldn't be an issue. Net neutrality or otherwise.

The conspiracy is letting them sell what they don't have, and everyone acting like its just ok and never come to that obvious conclusion.
 
I like how _AC_ put it on his post: I PAY FOR MY NET ACCESS.
If we don't like how a certain provider is slowing our access then we switch to another provider.
I can see how a provider might be slowing access for a few hours in a day during an upgrade or something but thats normal maintenance stuff.
We can always imagine the government slowing everything for us but it wouldn't happen. If it did then the united states would be just as bad as a place like China concerning the internet and people wouldn't stand for it.
 
"ignorance and lack of experience of totalitarian regimes?"

I should point out I have a Masters + 25 hours.

I hate to be the one to point this out, but you and about any other American also lacks this experience.

The US Government .. a regime?

Have you even googled "totalitarian" and "regimes?"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totalitarianism

On 2nd thought, don't even bother clicking that link, you will just find out you're a total nut job.

This isn't about you or your rights, this is about a pubic service that needs to be protected from being overwhelmed in a case of an extreme national emergency.

The human brain does the same exact thing when it's subjected to extreme stress, the brain becomes overloaded and will start shutting down background tasks. That's why people get tunnel vision or do not remember much after a traumatic event, or a lack of focus while you might be very upset or grieving.

Intel / AMD cpu's have this feature as well, too much heat and it throttle itself down and reduce cycles to protect itself.

Fanboys of sensationalism, anarchy, conspiracy, big brother, etc can all just relax now. Lets change the subject shall well. Area 51 perhaps?
 
Had the stupid internet providers actually have on hand the bandwidth they promise to each of their customers, there wouldn't be an issue. Net neutrality or otherwise.

The conspiracy is letting them sell what they don't have, and everyone acting like its just ok and never come to that obvious conclusion.


This post is full of win.:D
 
This isn't about you or your rights, this is about a pubic service that needs to be protected from being overwhelmed in a case of an extreme national emergency.

Spelling areas aside :), I agree with you 100%.

Anyone who thinks differently, tell me which important government or news web sites you were able to access on 9/11.
 
I should point out I have a Masters + 25 hours.


I have a cookie somewhere. A degree is not a measure of intelligence. If you had seven doctorate degrees, that would probably be worthy of a footnote in your argument. A random masters degree, and "25 hours" is, however, not.
 
Obviously in the case of a disaster, people need to be able to access emergency information. You, on the other hand, do not need to be accessing 4chan. If they feel they have some way of ensuring the Internet doesn't get bogged down, they should do it. That said, I don't think it's even feasible, as DHS said.
 
"ignorance and lack of experience of totalitarian regimes?"

I should point out I have a Masters + 25 hours.

I hate to be the one to point this out, but you and about any other American also lacks this experience.

The US Government .. a regime?

Have you even googled "totalitarian" and "regimes?"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totalitarianism

On 2nd thought, don't even bother clicking that link, you will just find out you're a total nut job.

This isn't about you or your rights, this is about a pubic service that needs to be protected from being overwhelmed in a case of an extreme national emergency.


first, id say that anyone posting thier experience or schooling level on the internet is about as believeable as the 'conspiracy' is to you. your best bet is to just make your point, becuase posting creditials wont change anyone's mind about your opinion.


secondly, assuming something about all americans is a bit wrong considering alot of americans came from countries with such regimes. plus, this country was founded around the idea of limited government, so its only natural we would be resistant to any additional government control.

finally, i think your missing the point. most people know we arent in a regime like say China, etc, but that doesnt mean our government doesnt overstep its bounds at times. so yeah, maybe some use exaggerated terms for your taste, but most just are against any action that might get us a step closer to such a regime.


but beyond all of those general points, this control the government has could be argued as a neccessary evil. I would prefer the government had no such access or control option, but it seems unavoidable in the current climate. but this arguement simply comes down to how much someone trusts the government to always be working in their best interest. so maybe right now they dont want to touch it, but it only takes one group of people to take advatange of it.
 
How would this affect users who are working from home during the pandemic? It threatens to bring corporations to their knees when they are depending on their employees to work (away from the office) via VPN.
 
Obviously during a real pandemic no one would oppose throttling Internet bandwidth if necessary to allow for emergency communications. Right now you may be worried about abstract privacy concerns, but if this every really became necessary, I certainly hope you wouldn't want the government to do nothing and let half the country die all in the name of libertarianism.

We could write laws right now prohibiting the government from regulating Internet use, but once again, any government of reasonable competency would, when faced with a true emergency, either repeal those laws or simply ignore them. If we discovered an asteroid was going to hit Earth, but enough time existed for us to alter its course with a nuclear warhead, would we refrain from doing so because international treaties prohibit placing weapons in space?
 
complaining about this would be like complaining that you had to wait at a red light because the ambulance unfairly got priority over you
 
If the pandemic kills enough people, then internet traffic would actually decrease. If half your neighborhood dies, mostly the kids under 25, then that's most your bandwidth hogs gone.

So... no problem!
 
This doesn't affect my 100MB FTTH home connection here in Tokyo. ;)
 
The internet is the only thing keeping me from spreading night time chaos in the real world. I think it is everyone's best interest if my connection has zero hiccups or throttling. :D
 
I don't see why they'd need to throttle the internet at all even if DHS did have the intention to do it.
I don't see the government relying on public internet connections for emergency communications. That's why we all have Digital TV now so they could dole out the frequencies to emergency services and auction off the rest to Verizon...
 
Personally I don't have a problem with this. However, with that said, it's a matter of time before someone else responds to this thread crying BIG BROTHER or bitching about how this will hurt the speed of their torrents.

It's not big brother, it's huge stupidity. If the network can handle traffic from 5-11pm, then it's ridiculous to think that that same network can't handle it if people are home sick.

Unless people who are sick sit at home torrenting all day, the flu is a non-issue.

One of the fears is that it might affect commerce. Lemme get this straight: almost half the country is home sick, but commerce will operate as usual, so long as those people just stay off the net?

Sorry, but these fears are unwarranted. One of the CBOs worries is VoIP and Gaming, which are both very low bandwidth apps.

H1N1 is something to worry about. internet usage due to H1N1 is not.
 
Back
Top