Palm Pre vs Apple iPhone: Preview Comparison

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Palm definitely made a big splash at CES this year with their new smartphone, Pre. NetworkWorld took a look at the Pre and compared it with the iPhone, though it’s important to note that a lot of their observations are just that: observations. Palm has not released much detail about the Pre yet. I’m very interested in one, being a big Palm fan since my old Handspring days.

"It's not an iPhone killer, nor a BlackBerry killer, but it doesn't need to be," says Avi Greengart, research director, mobile devices, for Current Analysis, who spent about an hour actually using a Pre.
 
"It's not an iPhone killer, nor a BlackBerry killer, but it doesn't need to be,"

That sums it up quite well.
It doesn't outdo the best consumer device (iPhone) and doesn't come close to the best business device (Blackberry), so it's just "another phone".
 
Where other devices that incorporate touch (poorly like the Storm) this device, and the iPhone were desingned from the ground up around a completely new OS taking advantage of all the hardware working in synnergy not as a bolted on after thought.

The Bold has been at&t's fastest selling Blackberry and I'm sure when the numbers come in, it will have greatly outsold the Storm, because it improved upong everything and the Storm improves upon nothing really.

I'm glad for Palm the more competitors there are in the game the more the consumer benefits, it does look like they have a winner and I can't wait till they release a GSM version.
 
The Bold has been at&t's fastest selling Blackberry and I'm sure when the numbers come in, it will have greatly outsold the Storm, because it improved upong everything and the Storm improves upon nothing really.
Exactly. You can't just slap a touchscreen on an existing interface that wasn't made with that in mind.

The Bold PROVES that non-touch interfaces can be damn well made. It's my #1 phone right now, knocks out all competition in my opinion. Downside is the cost however.

I'm glad for Palm the more competitors there are in the game the more the consumer benefits, it does look like they have a winner and I can't wait till they release a GSM version.
We'll have to see. I haven't used a Pre yet, but if they say the OS has been re-designed, then it's got to be better than the prior Palm OS crap they make.

A big question is how this will work in a corporate or enterprise network. I still have yet to see anything come close to rivaling Blackberry in that arena.

Huge plus to the Pre is an actual keyboard. Some folks like the iPhone's, but in general the folks I see loving it are just web browsers, light texters and virtually no emailers. Touchscreens just don't work at that. That's one area the Storm is moving the right direction in though (about the only thing I like about the Storm).


We'll just have to see. In my opinion this is just "another phone". Might work great for small businesses without centralized management of devices, or consumers wanting email on their phones.
 
Wish they'd offer it on verizon - hopefully it'll come out before my "new every two" comes due.
 
Palm just went from having no compelling product and getting eaten alive by RIMM and the iPhone to having a product that people can at least point to as being one of the best responses to the iPhone that anyone's yet come up with.

RIMM has the absolute best smartphone with a physical keyboard with the Bold, but the Storm was a disaster on every level. The less responsive touchscreen, the ridiculous "button" you have to press for inputs, the laggy software and UI, its all absolutely terrible. It looks like Palm has nailed a touchscreen phone that is 100 times better, all while adding a ton of other features on top of it. The only place it apparantly lags behind the iPhone is in application development. Programming in HTML/CSS/Javascript won't get you the level of application that you get from something programmed in Objective-C. What I will say though is that the UI, for something done in HTML5, looks awfully responsive. Very cool.

So yeah, wow, Palm's back in the game. Whether this is a hiccup on a continued downward spiral or if they can carve out their own profitable niche alongside Apple and RIMM remains to be seen.
 
Oh, the downside I forgot to mention in the Pre is limited Exchange support (email only, while the iPhone has calendar, contacts, etc, also supported), and no BES, obviously. I'm curious to see if something like this is incorporated in the future, or if Palm will focus this squarely on the consumer.
 
Oh, the downside I forgot to mention in the Pre is limited Exchange support (email only, while the iPhone has calendar, contacts, etc, also supported), and no BES, obviously. I'm curious to see if something like this is incorporated in the future, or if Palm will focus this squarely on the consumer.

It supports Exchange ActiveSync which includes Calendar and Contact syncing. Not sure where you saw it did e-mail only. Palm has supported Calendar/Contact/E-mail over ActiveSync for quite some time now.
 
It supports Exchange ActiveSync which includes Calendar and Contact syncing. Not sure where you saw it did e-mail only. Palm has supported Calendar/Contact/E-mail over ActiveSync for quite some time now.

Not well though. The Palm OS has always sucked at their compatibility with Active Sync. I could count on one hand the number of Palm OS-based devices that I had no issues with.
 
"It's not an iPhone killer, nor a BlackBerry killer, but it doesn't need to be,"

That sums it up quite well.
It doesn't outdo the best consumer device (iPhone) and doesn't come close to the best business device (Blackberry), so it's just "another phone".

I haven't been particularly impressed with the iPhone even as a consumer device, and I'd be loath to call it the best consumer smartphone on the market. You've got an inferior 2MP camera, no way to change the battery, no expandable memory, horrible battery life, an unimpressive (and as I see it, baroque beyond the point of redemption) OS. I don't like the entirely touch-screen user interface either, especially when it comes to text entry. There are better options out there, as I see it.

The BlackBerry devices are a lot more difficult to displace from their position, but while they excel at business applications, they are limited in their scope. The Palm Pre is unlikely to give strong competition to the BlackBerry devices, but then, there are few phones that can.
 
Not well though. The Palm OS has always sucked at their compatibility with Active Sync. I could count on one hand the number of Palm OS-based devices that I had no issues with.

Have you supported the Centro or the 680? I have a couple in use because of some users who didn't want to switch to WinMo and can't complain. Even the two Treo 680's that won't die have almost no problem handling Exchange. The 680's have a funny quark with entering contacts in outlook and not registering the email field correctly but the workaround was fairly easy. And the Centro users haven't complained about anything yet(damn I know I just jinxed myself). Now the 650's problem was the version of versamail and I have thankfully retired all of them. I'm not saying I like the Palm OS - I personally use WinMo and just received a Samsung Epix(the jury is still out on the Epix).
 
Centro? No. I stopped buying them before that came out.

But the 680 still has the same issues that all my Palm OS devices did. They just suck at life. The OS itself is solid but the darn support with ActiveSync sucked.

The only devices that did work were the ones (700wx is the first model number I can think of off the top of my head) were Windows Mobile. But the issue with Windows Mobile was the opposite: unstable OS but great ActiveSync support.
 
Back
Top