P4P800 dlx RAID controller speed

M

mfm

Guest
If I had two identical hard drives, say the WD 80GB ATA/8MB, and I had one drive on the primary IDE controller and the other on the primary RAID controller to use as a second disk (no actual RAID usage), would the two drives be seen by the system as having the same "speed"?

Edit: Removed page file / partition question.
 
I'm kind of wondering the same thing on my p4s800d-e deluxe. Heh, wouldnt it be funny to get like a 20 GB page file? lol.
 
To make this simple, I don't need the answer to the page file question. I will figure that out separately. I just need to know whether the same HDs on the primary IDE controller and primary RAID controller on the P4P800 Deluxe would operate at the roughly the same speed (transfer rate).
 
if you were to setup a raid, that's the way you should do it. putting both drives on the same channel will decrease your performance slightly.

if the drives are the same model, then a raid setup should be no problem (unless one of them dies down the road and you're screwed because you'll lose ALL your data - this is assuming you're using Raid0 (striping))

EDIT:

just re-read your post. why would you want to put one drive on the normal IDE and the other on the raid controller??? Doing that won't gain you any speed.
 
Originally posted by nst6563
just re-read your post. why would you want to put one drive on the normal IDE and the other on the raid controller??? Doing that won't gain you any speed.
I am not interested in a RAID setup. What I am interested in is adding a second drive to the system for backups, downloads, CD-R disk images, etc., without impeding the speed of the boot drive.

I am already using the secondary IDE channel for a DVD-ROM/CD-ROM and a CD-RW, so my choices are adding the drive as a slave on the primary IDE channel (which is usually considered a bad idea), putting one hard drive and one optical drive on each IDE channel (really considered a bad idea), or adding the second hard drive to the RAID controller (again, I am NOT interested in actual RAID usage).

Well, I guess there are other options, like using an IDE->SATA adapter (usually frowned upon), selling the IDE disk and purchasing an SATA hard drive, or purchasing an IDE controller card.
 
in that case, you wouldn't notice a speed difference. you have the right idea about what you're doing.

There's nothing wrong with a PATA -> SATA converter either. I'm using one and there are is no performance loss to speak of. In fact, it's my boot drive (maxtor 7200rpm 8mb) and seems to boot faster than the PATA config. Of course, that could just be perception too...because the benches I ran showed a less than 1% difference.
 
Originally posted by nst6563
There's nothing wrong with a PATA -> SATA converter either...
Really? I thought I read that this was not a very good idea. But it sounds like you opted for this over using the RAID controller for the 2nd drive, and it works for you.

So, in the absence of overwhelming criticism of this idea, do you happen to have a link showing what one of these PATA->SATA converters look like and cost? Thanks.
 
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=22-999-111&depa=0&section=1

some people say they notice a difference, some don't. I think it may just depend on the drive and the system. my maxtor is an ata133 drive, maybe that makes up for any performance loss that may occur? don't know.

all I know is that I tried both, benched both, and since there wasn't much of a difference, I opted for the smaller SATA cable vs the flat wide PATA cable.

I think the brand I have is a Kingmax, Kingwin, Kingston...one of those...I think it's a kingston though. most of them cost around $20 though.
 
Back
Top