P4 or AthlonFX?

CPU?

  • Athlon 64 FX 53 939

    Votes: 41 89.1%
  • Pentium 4 560 3.6GHz LGA775

    Votes: 5 10.9%

  • Total voters
    46

lrdbelial

n00b
Joined
Feb 11, 2003
Messages
8
Right now Im otrn between getting a Pentium 4 560 3.6GHz LGA775 or an Athlon 64 FX 53 939. Gaming is my primary focus. Right now Im leaning towards the Athlon becuase I see higher benchmarks for games and I can use my current DDR400 memory as apposed to buy another 1.5GB of DDR2. Any suggestions?

Also if you vote for the Athlon should I go nForce3 or VIA chipset?
 
im an intel guy but between those 2, id go with the athlon for gaming.
 
amd, and the price/performance of that versus an opteron 150 and some registered memory is fooey. look at (single) opteron boards. or dual if you feel like it ;)

right now on newegg a fx53 is $885, and a opteron 150 is $638. you can get 1gb of memory for the difference. getting 2 opteron 244's is the same price. 2cpus will help in many games, in ut2k4 sound is on a seperate thread (and therefore cpu) and improves performance 20% over a single.
enough ranting. get a fx53, but consider your other options in this price range.
 
unhappy_mage said:
amd, and the price/performance of that versus an opteron 150 and some registered memory is fooey. look at (single) opteron boards. or dual if you feel like it ;)

right now on newegg a fx53 is $885, and a opteron 150 is $638. you can get 1gb of memory for the difference. getting 2 opteron 244's is the same price. 2cpus will help in many games, in ut2k4 sound is on a seperate thread (and therefore cpu) and improves performance 20% over a single.
enough ranting. get a fx53, but consider your other options in this price range.


yeah like buying me one :D
 
I would go AMD but there's no (little to none) performance difference between the A64 and the FX processors, I'd get the A64 3000+ instead.
 
CrimandEvil said:
I would go AMD but there's no (little to none) performance difference between the A64 and the FX processors, I'd get the A64 3000+ instead.


Correct me if I am wrong but doesn't the FX-53 939 perform even better than the 3800+
 
The FX does outform the 3800+ by a small margin but the price doesn't justify the speed. The major upside is that the FX comes unlocked (I think).
 
I'd get the FX. Every benchmark I have seen shows it performing better then the p4.
Also I would go with the nforce3 chipset.
 
for gaming yes, but the p4 would do better in apps like 3d,video editing,compositing etc, but id still go with the amd
 
Back
Top