P4 2.8 with 512kb cache or 1mb

freddursth8

Weaksauce
Joined
Jan 8, 2004
Messages
116
What would be the best processor to get, the P4 2.8C w/ 512kb cache or the p4 2.8e w/ 1mb cache? The 2.8e is only 11 bucks more on newegg, but will it overheat more??? Whatdoya think?? Thanks!
 
The E is the Prescott. You will want to find out if your board supports them, and if your case can handle the heat.
 
If you'll be overclocking, stick with the c. And yeah, see if your board can even support it...that's one power hungry (and hot) chip there.

Remember how when the 3.06GHz P4 came out, everyone was commenting on how hot and power-hungry it was?:D
 
So the heat IS more significant with the 2.8e??? By how much more? Some reviews say the difference in temperaturs is a lot, others say its not. I dont know which ones to trust. Also, in what ways do you know how much heat your case can handle. I know, I know... I suck. lol.

Also, I went to the site for my board. I think it does support the prescott chip, but it is kinda unclear: http://www.intel.com/design/motherbd/lc/lc_proc.htm#Note

I dont know if they are referring to my specific board or intel boards in general. Anyway, thanks again guys.
 
3.4Ghz Prescott requires around 103w compared to a 3.4Ghz Northwood and 89w. They are definitely hotter and i would suggest waiting for LGA 775 versions because with new boards and the new socket alot of the heat issue should be corrected.

I just bought a 3.0c Northwood so i would sugest a 2.8c or 3.0c for right now. They are both great overclockers.
 
Originally posted by freddursth8
Isnt the 3.2c gonna be just as hot as the 2.8e???

Dunno, but it'll woop the 2.8es ass.

The Prescotts right now are slower than the same clocked P4c processor if I understand correctly.
 
Originally posted by emorphien
Dunno, but it'll woop the 2.8es ass.

The Prescotts right now are slower than the same clocked P4c processor if I understand correctly.

Prescott had to have an increase in pipeline stages in order to continue ramping higher. You wont see the benefits of this till it hits 4Ghz and higher. It was the same way with the Northwoods. They sucked every bit as much as Prescott does right now if not more and yet it wasn't long till they were beating the Athlon XP and Pentium III in nearly every benchmark and by large margins.

According to several articles i've read on this, deeper pipelines are better for data-intensive applications like games and multimedia than productivity software. This would somewhat suggest that Intel is focusing on gaming and multimedia right now. Of course a 1Ghz machine is fast enough for productivity software.
 
Originally posted by emorphien
Dunno, but it'll woop the 2.8es ass.

The Prescotts right now are slower than the same clocked P4c processor if I understand correctly.
True. Plus I've heard that 3.2C are supposed to be the best chips for getting to 4GHz, not only because they are initially clocked so high, but because Intel 'cherry picked' the best samples for their flagship model.
 
But the question still remains.... will the P4 3.2c give out too much heat? Especially for an mATX case?:(
 
Originally posted by freddursth8
But the question still remains.... will the P4 3.2c give out too much heat? Especially for an mATX case?:(
the heat will be about the same as any other 'c' processor
 
I think it puts 89W of heat out. As long as you have adequate case cooling, I think you should be fine. The major OEMs are starting to stuff Prescotts in their boxes, so if those tight little things can handle it, any m-ATX should be able to.
 
I'm not sure if this has already been mentioned but,

The 2.4C is a chip with hyperthreading enabled where the 2.8 doesn't have hyperthreading enabled. 1MB of cache would be nice, but if you have a lot of processes running at once like a lot of do then hyperthreading is nice.
 
Originally posted by Private Citizen
I'm not sure if this has already been mentioned but,

The 2.4C is a chip with hyperthreading enabled where the 2.8 doesn't have hyperthreading enabled. 1MB of cache would be nice, but if you have a lot of processes running at once like a lot of do then hyperthreading is nice.

The 2.8c Northwood and 2.8e Prescott on 800MHz FSB both have Hyper Threading. Only the 2.8a Prescott and 2.8b Northwood on 533MHz FSB dont.
 
Back
Top