P.S. 3.0 nVidia, ATI and cheating

Boomermage

n00b
Joined
Oct 21, 2003
Messages
55
Ok, first of all let me say I have no loyalty to either brand. What I have done in the past is force myself to buy whatever technology the reviewers say is best no matter how familiar/unfamiliar I am with the brand. I guess I don't believe the difference is subjective. It's either faster or it's not, it's either displaying what it's supposed to or its not, etc. This has worked for me and the only time i have been burned is when I buy something out of familiarity.

This doesn't work as well as it used to however because of manufacturers cheating. While there have been quite a few instances of this the thing that comes to mind is nVidias last product not being directx 9 compliant and the whole cheating mess.

It's not nVidia specifically that I'm worried about. My primary concern at this moment is ATI's leaked powerpoint presentation where the notes say the P.S. 3 performance on ATI's R420 will be poor. Of course on the other hand I am still worried about nVidia due to their history.

Luckily for me I'm not going to upgrade until PCI Express becomes standard then I think I'll build a new system. I hope the reviewers of both next generation products not only pay attention to performance but also look for cheating. I hope the next few months are ample time to uncover whether nVidia's or ATI's product are truly the best. I was lucky enough to not buy one of Geforce FX series and I would have been livid pissed if i did.

Personally I don't care who the maker is of my next card. I just don't want to drop 400 bucks then find out later I got ripped off.
 
link to powerpoint shot?

edit ps3.0 on the 420? I thought there was no ps3.0..

wtf?
 
God did you even read the slides? It says nothing about speed of PS3.0, it talks about specific parts of PS3.0 which could cause performance problems, presumably for everybody
 
Originally posted by creedAMD
link to powerpoint shot?

edit ps3.0 on the 420? I thought there was no ps3.0..

wtf?

exactly what i thought.
wheres that link at????
 
lol funny...
toms hardware says the same thing.
http://www20.tomshardware.com/graphic/20040414/geforce_6800-11.html
:rolleyes:

theres that PR at it again.

edit: heres the quote if your too lazy to go to toms lol
While NVIDIA is loudly and proudly advertising the new shader model, ATi is attempting to downplay it. A wonderful and quite humorous example of this tactic is a developer presentation titled "Save the Nanosecond" by ATIs Richard Huddy which was accidentally leaked on the internet. The trouble was, the presentation still sported some personal notes which made it clear that the presenter was trying to convince developers to stay away from Flow Control in PS3.0, as it incurs a very tangible performance hit. Quote:

"Steer people away from flow control in ps3.0 because we expect it to hurt badly. [Also it's the main extra feature on NV40 vs R420 so let's discourage people from using it until R5xx shows up with decent performance...]"

Internet forums everywhere are still tied up in all sorts of debates about how this statement should best be interpreted. One way of reading this quote would be that ATi's upcoming chips are either still too slow for this feature or simply aren't designed for it. Another would be that it won't be until the generation of cards following the one being launched now, that graphics accelerators will be able to cope with the complexity caused by this feature...
 
I would also like to point out ATI never disputed these comments. They merely said they were taken out of context and since they are about unannounced products, they can't comment on it.
"Thanks for the e-mail. Many of the comments in the speaker's notes are easily misinterpreted outside of the context of the spoken presentation. However, because some of the comments relate to unannounced products we will not be providing further information or clarification at this time. None of the information in the notes or in the presentation is material, so the proximity to our financial reporting isn't relevant.
 
Originally posted by obs
I would also like to point out ATI never disputed these comments. They merely said they were taken out of context and since they are about unannounced products, they can't comment on it.
:rolleyes: Thats real fucking convenient for them. Maybe this is why their killer X800-XT isn't suppose to come out til June.
 
Originally posted by CrimandEvil
:rolleyes: Thats real fucking convenient for them. Maybe this is why their killer X800-XT isn't suppose to come out til June.

So when's the last time you heard a company talk about rumors on products they didn't release?
 
You guys do realize that the majority of games using shader model 3.0 won't be out until 2006(as in post-Doom3/HL2 engine games), right? Okay, just checking....
 
Originally posted by SnakEyez187
So when's the last time you heard a company talk about rumors on products they didn't release?
Who said they had to talk about thier unreleased product? All they had to do was talk about the Shader technology:
"PS 3.0 does this, this, and that and all of that causes a performance hit on all current hardware." (Something like that)
I remember reading alot about ATI and Nvidia commenting on the importance of PS 2.0 before their products launched and now ATI doesn't want to? Come on! Honestly it does look like Nvidia has the edge here but I'm still keeping the jury out until June.

Fanboys are funny!:D
 
Originally posted by Silent.Sin
You guys do realize that the majority of games using shader model 3.0 won't be out until 2006(as in post-Doom3/HL2 engine games), right? Okay, just checking....
Farcry patch uses PS 3.0
 
I remember reading alot about ATI and Nvidia commenting on the importance of PS 2.0 before their products launched and now ATI doesn't want to?

Did they ever talk about speed? I can't remember, they always talked about featuresets and what is going to be possible, never anything about how fast/slow their cards are going to be when using it. If you aren't a developer I don't see any reason Ati shouldn't be sharing any tips on development with you. The slides were *leaked* meaning they weren't meant for the public and for good reason, do any of us have R420 or NV40 samples that developers get months before the card is released? Do any of us even know what they are talking about and why or why not its important, would we even care?
 
Yeah, damn near any game will be able to use them with a patch, but it will be awhile before they are making art based entirely on PS3.0/VS3.0 (Unreal Engine 3 might be the first huge title). What I'm saying is I wouldn't worry about inclusion of model 3.0 compliance right now, the performance with it won't be too great. Branching will greatly impact the NV40 in the same way it will the R420. These GPUs are just now becoming generalized computation units, they have a long way to go before they can match the finesse at which CPUs can handle conditional statements and branch prediction.

The R450(or whatever it is gonna get named) will probably just be a R420 core revision with full 3.0+ support and a speed bump, that will be out around the holiday season I bet. Hell we're only just now getting on to our second generation of 2.0 hardware, let the market be for a little while before you start complaining about an almost completely unused feature for the time being. I would rather be playing FarCry with 2.0 on an NV40 than 3.0 because the NV40 is a freaking beast at doing 2.0 calculations as I'm hoping the R420 will be too. If the same gradient of 2.0 on the NV38/R350 to 2.0 performance on the NV40 can be applied to NV40 3.0 compared to NV45 3.0 THEN we can start talking practical use of shader model 3.0 at reasonable speeds. Mmmmmm Doom3 pegged at its 60fps cap no matter what you throw at it *drool*.
 
Originally posted by Swat
ewwww the inquirer *shivers*

Holy shit, I totally forgot about the Inq.

Damnit, now I gotta track down all those Inq naysayers and shove the oh so classical 'they were right you were wrong' line in their faces.
 
I disagree with the premise to not worry about PS 3.0. Why would you even consider playing Far cry with PS 2.0 instead of 3.0 enabled if you get a decent frame rate with the better quality visuals. I can undersand compromise if we were talking about a midrange card but we're not. Directx 9.0c is out in a couple of months and I wouldn't even consider a card that didn't support PS 3.0 completely.

I just don't know which card it's gonna be yet. Luckily I won't be an early adopter so there should be time to figure out which card is best!
 
Originally posted by Vagrant Zero

Damnit, now I gotta track down all those Inq naysayers and shove the oh so classical 'they were right you were wrong' line in their faces.

Assuming their speculation is right, and it only affects one card not both, and it affects them in a way that's not meaningless.
 
Originally posted by SnakEyez187
Assuming their speculation is right, and it only affects one card not both, and it affects them in a way that's not meaningless.

Actually I meant their presumed NV40 specs, not their 'Nvida will pwn ATI' crap. That was clearly bullshit, but I rememer when Inq said NV40 will hit 12500 in 03 and people jumped on them for it. Turns out it was totally on the dot.
 
Originally posted by Vagrant Zero
Holy shit, I totally forgot about the Inq.

Damnit, now I gotta track down all those Inq naysayers and shove the oh so classical 'they were right you were wrong' line in their faces.
:confused:
 
That powerpoint says nothing about cheating. Assuming they would lower themselves to that is ignorant.
 
I think he's referring to ATI trying to scare off Devs from using certain PS3.0 functions til thier next gen cards (R5XX) comes out.
 
Originally posted by CrimandEvil
Farcry patch uses PS 3.0

that far cry was the only game the 6800u had less than anticipated performance.
 
Originally posted by jacuzz1
that far cry was the only game the 6800u had less than anticipated performance.
Yes but maybe you just blindly assumed that. All previews made the note that FC has some issues with the 6800U even when PS2.0 was used, but that it was probably due to drivers (or something like that).
 
Back
Top