Opinions on SN95G5

TheGeneral

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
393
Ive been wanting a shuttle for a while now, and i think i may go with the SN95G5, i would be taking the X800XT, Audigy 2 ZS, NEC-2500A, 1GB PC3200 and 80GB drive outta my current comp and get the SN95G5 w/ a Winchester 3500+. Would power be an issue? Anyone here have experience with em yet?
 
I'm thinking about the same box. Anywho, it shouldn't be a problem, if you read Kyle's review on the SN95G5, they used a X800 XT, Raptor drives, and much more, according to the review, it was stable as a rock.
 
there are many reviews on the power issue. No you will not have a problem. my SN95G5 and 3500 have been a wicked upgrade from a P4 3 gig etc...
 
it's as fast as a conventional desktop, quiter, has all the features I want (besides soundstorm :mad: ) and it almost fits in my glovebox :p

spinach
 
Just did a Google search of SN95 reviews and I couldn't find anything bad. Shuttle has a pretty good rep, but nary a bad word is still unusually good.

However, other forums do list issues, mostly BIOS related and something about a mid-generation processor that AMD doesn't seem to be making anymore. Haven't done an exhaustive read, but this still seems like a rather solid machine.

Anybody find any showstoppers for this model? I wanna buy one too...
 
well, after some reading i decided that i will be purchasing this setup. cant wait to see how these new Winchester 3500+'s run.
 
Ive been wanting to get a SN95G5 too, but $320 is a bit too expensive for me right now and I would have to get a new processor. So I'm looking at about a $600 upgrade for a shuttle barebones system and a AMD64 3500+ (Winchester) :(

Someone wanna donate me some money :D
 
I too am looking for an SN95 around xmas but my intention was to run an overclocked 3200+ in it, but after closer examination of kyle's review, he noted overclocking problems as well as problems with samsung optical drives (newegg has a dual layer samsung for 57 bucks right now).....
Other sites reported no problems overclocking, is it possible hardocp just recieved a bum sample or an early production model?
 
SFF's and overclocking aren't synonymous. with proper temps you might be able to push it some but don't expect leaps and bounds in OC'ing. you really read more than just [H]'s review if you haven't already

g'luk, the system rox!
 
i've read over at sfftech that people are overclocking some with success. i am going to try once i get my system checked out at stock. my psu +3.3 and +5 rails are only reading 3.18 and 4.75 in the bios right now :(

i have a 3200+ winny as well.
 
Has anyone seen a link to a review showing the noise differences between, say, the XFX 6600GT and any (eVGA?) 6800\6800GT?

I'm building a SN95G5 and just can't decide whether the noise\heat\power difference is going to be big enough to take a hit to performance. I don't really need the fastest card possible, but it wouldn't hurt :)

Hav0k
 
don't want to crash the party, but did you also read all the threads at sudhian about the f'ed up BIOS, lack of response from shuttle, temp and fan problems? I was very excited about this case when I bought it, but wound up RMA'ing it because it WOULD NOT operate the fans correctly, no matter what BIOS it had or what program i tried to control it with.

i'm not saying don't buy it, but there are a few odd issues that are more than few and far between. i would love another one but am afraid to order and have the same problem...
 
Had mine for a couple weeks and it's been absolutely golden, probably the best PC I've ever owned. Strange, eh? Oh well, to the victor goes the spoils...
 
version 2.0 of the motherboard is out and from what ive been reading the only time people have a problem w/ fans now is when using Cool n" Quiet, which i wont be doing. Ill have everything monday, and im sure i wont be able to wait till the weekend to get everything built
 
denaps said:
don't want to crash the party, but did you also read all the threads at sudhian about the f'ed up BIOS, lack of response from shuttle, temp and fan problems? I was very excited about this case when I bought it, but wound up RMA'ing it because it WOULD NOT operate the fans correctly, no matter what BIOS it had or what program i tried to control it with.

i'm not saying don't buy it, but there are a few odd issues that are more than few and far between. i would love another one but am afraid to order and have the same problem...
absolutely! read so much and all the bitching in sudhian before I bought mine but I still did! the mobo benchez sold me but I wanted a a64 sff for LAN ease. whoopie these guys are such keeners that they need the exact temps etc. I understand thier frustration and the few people that had isolated, bigger issues but I was always left thinking that I couldn't side with each thread I read. I was on sudhain for days on end and came to think that most on there are a bunch of unprofessional whiners! so what if shuttle has not responded, put some faith in the system and wait as they are addressing it. issue should be expected with buying anything new anyway. whatever, but that's my .02! the SN95G5 rox!

whatcha think RMA is? use it! shit does happen....
 
Mine is working great.

I did have it report the wrong temperature but updating the BIOS fixed that

-PSU working fine with my setup (see sig)

-Smartfan works though it's very conservative with the fans settings. Barely reaches more than 1600RPM full load. Well that keeps CPU at about 48-50C so it's OK I guess.

-Cool and Quiet works resulting in 800-900RPM fan speed when the system is idle - it's as quiet as a Dell ;) The only thing that is kind of loud is the videocard as the fan ramps up when GPU is working

-It won't overclock much. Tried for 210x11 and it crashed running Prime95. Think the problem is my 2-year old Twinmos RAM though. I get fairly decent timings at 200 Mhz but anything more seems to cause problems.
 
I haven't gotten the HD or video card I'm giong to stick in my SN95G5 yet, but I stuck in an old Voodoo3 3k just to make sure the ram\cpu\etc I had installed were working properly.

Using just the thermal paste Shuttle includes, if I sit and idle in the bios screen, I idle around 40-42 with smartfan on, if I max out the fan, it drops to 20 - 22. I know there are issues regarding proper temp readings, so it's hard to say if these are ACTUAL temps, but based on the size of the CPU temp drop based on the fan speed increase, would it be safe to say the Shuttle thermal paste is working ok? I ordered some Arctic Silver 5 to stick on there if I ever felt the temp was getting too hot or if I wanted to overclock...but has anyone else idled in BIOS? What was your CPU temp?
 
got mine up and running, the thing is AMAZINGLY fast, w/ smart fan on and moderate usage my temps are around 44c, thats with the fan only running at about 800RPM, when it kicks up when gaming temps go down a lil more, i havent had a single problem so far, im really loving this thing
 
yeah i've had mine for a week and I absolutely love it. VERY QUEIT. he was right on the temps but i'm modding another smart fan into the top so mine should go down here soon
 
i finally got mine working nicely (after going through 5 pairs of ram), even with an little overclock.

i'm happy :)
 
I've had mine for 2 weeks or so. Love it...

CPU Temps are 36 idle, 45 full load, which tells me that it has room to OC if I ever decide to do that. It SCREAMS on HL2Demo (just tried it last night).

The hottest and loudest part of my system is the 6800, loaded temps on that are around 56C.

SN95G5 FN95V2.0
Athlon 3500+ 64bit 939 90nm Winchester
BFG Geforce 6800 OC 128mb
2x512MB Corsair TWINX 8-3-3-6 (had some BSOD's at faster timing, so I set it at auto for now)
1 x 120GB seagate
1 x 200GB seagate
Plextor 708A DVD-RW
 
www.sfftech.com

If you check the forums there are many with nothing but problems... there is also a Version 2 out so if you're looking for one, that would be my advice. I am split between the SN95GH and the SB77G5 myself...
 
I decided not to take a chance with Shuttle this time, just to many hiccups with the SN95G, so I ordered an entirely new ATX Athlon 64 system to last me awhile. Maybe next time Shuttle.
 
Xaeos said:
www.sfftech.com

If you check the forums there are many with nothing but problems....
BA! people will bitch cause they can. research, then buy or stay away from new hardware. most did not in any of the nastier threads. the SN95 kicks ass! nothing but a beauty setup and killer frame rates in all games
 
G'ßöö said:
BA! people will bitch cause they can. research, then buy or stay away from new hardware. most did not in any of the nastier threads. the SN95 kicks ass! nothing but a beauty setup and killer frame rates in all games

You CONSISTENTLY refuse to accept the fact that this machine has been problems for many buyers. I do plenty of research before buying machines. Lack of research has nothing to do with the fact that a good sized batch of these machines is faulty. I'm glad you like yours, and wish mine didn't suck so badly like many others, but you can't deny the fact that there are problems so quit YOUR bitching about reporting valid problems.
 
denaps said:
You CONSISTENTLY refuse to accept the fact that this machine has been problems for many buyers. I do plenty of research before buying machines. Lack of research has nothing to do with the fact that a good sized batch of these machines is faulty. I'm glad you like yours, and wish mine didn't suck so badly like many others, but you can't deny the fact that there are problems so quit YOUR bitching about reporting valid problems.

any system bought in large numbers will have problems, the new 2.0 revision seems to have fixed some issues, most problems people are having is with Cool n' Quiet. just remember, theres always gonna be a large number of threads about people having problems, simply because those that have working systems are too busing enjoying them. I for one <3 my SN95G5. the only thing still holding me back is my somewhat crappy memory and 7200RPM hd, both of which will soon be remedied with faster replacements.
 
denaps said:
You CONSISTENTLY refuse to accept the fact that this machine has been problems for many buyers. I do plenty of research before buying machines. Lack of research has nothing to do with the fact that a good sized batch of these machines is faulty. I'm glad you like yours, and wish mine didn't suck so badly like many others, but you can't deny the fact that there are problems so quit YOUR bitching about reporting valid problems.
LOL....so unworthy of a rebuttle :p


call another waaaaaambulance!
 
G'ßöö said:
LOL....so unworthy of a rebuttle :p


call another waaaaaambulance!

hey boss, i am not whining or looking for an argument. just saying that if people have problems with a machine, they shouldn't be told to shut their mouths and stop whining because they post them to a COMPUTER HARDWARE FORUM. don't you agree?
 
actually i agree saying the SN95G5 is buggy.

the fact that version 1.0, then 1.1, then 1.2, then 1.3 and now 2.0 came out in like a few months doesn't speak well...

however lots of ppl have them working, and they probably don't visit forums. sfftech.com does have a high number of ppl with issues but they likely went there bcause they had issues. u dont go on the forum to tell everyone everything is okay!

i can understand why someone wouldn't want to get one, but now that mine works (after head ache with ram compatibility) i'm content with it. the size is just cute ;)

shuttle.jpg
 
hey employee... absolutely! whatcha think a forum is? but let's not be too naive

at no time did I tell someone to shut it
at no time did I CONSISTENTLY refuse there are issues with it

I cood go on and on with info and rebuttles but why it's all around and no need to reguritate it, but go ahead

I still love ya :eek:
 
Okay, for those that have a perfectly (otherwise) working SN95G5, could anyone tell me about the ram compatability issues?

What is it finicky about exactly? I have 1gig (2x512) worth of PC3500 RAM in my current system that I am thinking of moving to whatever SFF I build.
 
You probably won't have much problems there with that memory.

I've got the Corsair TWINX 1GB and had a few problems getting the timings to work at the fastest speeds (I had 1 BSOD and 1 reboot at 2 2 2 6), so I just let the shuttle decide them for me and I haven't had a problem since.
 
Back
Top