Open Source: The Model Is Broken

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
BusinessWeek is opening a can of worms today with their latest guest editorial stating the open-source business model is broken. The article was penned by Stuart Cohen, CEO of the Open Source Development Labs.

For anyone who hasn't been paying attention to the software industry lately, I have some bad news. The open-source business model is broken.
 
Open-source isn't always about profits or money. Some people just don't get that.
 
Open-source isn't always about profits or money. Some people just don't get that.

And that's why the model is broken. As long as people maintain this romantic view of open-source being about "Free" software and thumbing their nose at the "man", it will fail. At the end of the day, people who invest their time and talent to bring you that free software still have mortgage payments, car payments, utility bills, grocery bills, and want to take a vacation to a sunny beach every once in a while.
 
He's just pissed he doesn't have a $100mil golden parachute. So when his company fails he's broke.
 
And that's why the model is broken. As long as people maintain this romantic view of open-source being about "Free" software and thumbing their nose at the "man", it will fail. At the end of the day, people who invest their time and talent to bring you that free software still have mortgage payments, car payments, utility bills, grocery bills, and want to take a vacation to a sunny beach every once in a while.

A-men to that!
The gravy train can only go so far. It will eventually run out!
 
Open-source code is generally great code, not requiring much support

I call BS on this statement. Any Open Source program that I have ever used has had just as many bugs as any other program. Firefox isn't 100% bug free or 100% error free. Open Office isn't. The zimbra mail server software isn't. Linux in of itself isn't 100% bug free.

Just about all software is going to have some bug or glitch that needs fixed. Not only that but I would claim that a need for new functionality falls under support also. And I don't see any program being able to never need any new functionality added to it as things change over time.

Not only that but i have seen a lot of open source programs fall to the side or just not get updated very often to fix the problems. Then I have seen sone that get updated almost weeky and break something new ever time causing you to have to spend a great deal of time trying to keep up with them and trying to find a release that works how you need it to work and has only broken parts that you won't need to use while you wait for the next semi stable release of the software.

Overall I have to agree with JethroXP. People want to view opensource as the way to stick it to the man. I use to get into agruements with people about this when I was in college working on my CS degree. I have nothing against people producing free software or open source software, however I myself like being able to pay my bills and put food on the table. If you want to work a 8 - 5 M-F job then spend another 40+ hours a week working on a program then great. However over time this will fail. I myself have switched a few times from some open source solution to a paid solution as I got much better results from the paid solution as they know to keep people they have to do a good job with their products. I've seen too many open source products that try to keep the mindset that you will use their product no matter how buggy or limited it might be just so that you can stick it to the man and not pay for software.
 
Open source is the bane of current computing.

1) Nobody goes to school for years and does shit for free. That's what you do during school...and profs and the university reap the rewards. Check out policy on intellectual property if you don't believe me at your school.
2) Open source fanboys say "you can do anything on linux you can do with Windows". I call bullshit. OpenOffice and Gimp can't do half as much in twice the time as Office or Photoshop...and they look like shit.
3) Lack of standards. Until I can hand a disk out to a buddy and have him run it/install it on his linux box at home, then linux is useless other than a hobbyists toy.
4) Tech support for the major one or two real linux distributions is expensive and hiring someone to actually come and fix the problem is usually hopeless. (ie your cluster isn't working right on big files, but small ones are just fine - who's gonna know what to do? One person made one post five years ago about turning on noac in your NFS settings and no MPI docs mention that anywhere!) That's experience that isn't in the public domain...it's at places like LANL)
5) Linux will not run on everything because of lack of driver and hardware support. Power settings? My 3hr battery in my Sony laptop lasts a nice 1.25-1.5 hours under linux...or I can't even run RedHat on it because it mysteriously locks up(I think it's the SATA driver so far) or how about running 64bit flavors on my Q6700/NF780iLT/SLI 8800 machine...locks up on boot. Hrmm...Windows Vista 64bit runs great!

Linux was built during an era when the hardware guys blamed the software guys and the software guys blamed the hardware guys. It's always something with these kooks. I can fully support a linux, Unix, Mac or Windows environment, but I know when the day is done that I can accomplish more tasks in less time on a Windows based network of PC's than any of the others. That leaves me less stressed at the end of the day and I can move on the next project without distraction..making me and anyone on the system more productive at a lesser cost in the long run than the others.
 
Give the software for free, and provide support for $$$
THAT is the OSS model and if it doesn't work wtf are Novel and RH making $$$ from it then ??

someone needs to go back to business school me thinks
 
I posted this on the business week comments section for that article. I as a business owner cannot make the money with a windows based product that I can with a Linux based product. I may not develop any software for Linux but I support those that do by donating a portion of the sales back to the software product I used. The problem as I see it for some of the recent comments from posters prior to me is that not enough of the companies are donating back to the developers of such software. This would be the only reason you would not be able to make your mortgage payments per say.

Now, software that is not GPL but that is used on Linux as pay to use basis is also very good in my opnion. They just get there donation up front is how I see it. I have no issues putting a proprietary program on Linux as long as it gets the job done for my customer.
Linux, for a small IT company that services almost the entire city we are in and various customers around the state solidifies us with good stable products that the customers appreciate and return to us for further hardware and/or software needs. Honestly since I have not found many companies in my state that support Linux or even Mac's it is almost a vendor lock in for our customers. This for my company and the people that work here are almost guaranteed a paycheck every week. This also trickles down to those that develop software for Linux in a donation or an up front fee for those that have a pay to use program.

I work at a local shop with two other people. All three of us own the company. Our bread and butter comes mainly from Linux based revenue. DVR's, Linux based servers, even starting some Linux based client machine have all done really well for us. All of our router setups are also Linux based. If Linux as a service was not a viable source of revenue then I am pretty sure I would know about it. I believe companies that have a hard time making money off of it are the ones that sink to much into one effort or one product. Linux is about versatility and usability. You must use all aspects of it in my opinion. If you find a good product that does good for you donate back. Tax write offs are grand. Companies that use Linux in my opinion must follow that course so the people that actually develop the software can be supported as well. Without them we would not have such great products to sell to our computer illiterate customers.
 
I posted this on the business week comments section for that article. I as a business owner cannot make the money with a windows based product that I can with a Linux based product. I may not develop any software for Linux but I support those that do by donating a portion of the sales back to the software product I used. The problem as I see it for some of the recent comments from posters prior to me is that not enough of the companies are donating back to the developers of such software. This would be the only reason you would not be able to make your mortgage payments per say.

Now, software that is not GPL but that is used on Linux as pay to use basis is also very good in my opnion. They just get there donation up front is how I see it. I have no issues putting a proprietary program on Linux as long as it gets the job done for my customer.
Linux, for a small IT company that services almost the entire city we are in and various customers around the state solidifies us with good stable products that the customers appreciate and return to us for further hardware and/or software needs. Honestly since I have not found many companies in my state that support Linux or even Mac's it is almost a vendor lock in for our customers. This for my company and the people that work here are almost guaranteed a paycheck every week. This also trickles down to those that develop software for Linux in a donation or an up front fee for those that have a pay to use program.

I work at a local shop with two other people. All three of us own the company. Our bread and butter comes mainly from Linux based revenue. DVR's, Linux based servers, even starting some Linux based client machine have all done really well for us. All of our router setups are also Linux based. If Linux as a service was not a viable source of revenue then I am pretty sure I would know about it. I believe companies that have a hard time making money off of it are the ones that sink to much into one effort or one product. Linux is about versatility and usability. You must use all aspects of it in my opinion. If you find a good product that does good for you donate back. Tax write offs are grand. Companies that use Linux in my opinion must follow that course so the people that actually develop the software can be supported as well. Without them we would not have such great products to sell to our computer illiterate customers.


You are very well intentioned, and I'm glad that your business is doing well, but even you have to realize that what you are advocating is an Ivory Tower. Given the choice, most users will take what is free without a single thought of donating back to the developers. Most people don't have the presence of mind to understand that by only taking, and never giving, they are contributing to the downfall of that from which they are benefiting.
 
Open source is the bane of current computing.

2) Open source fanboys say "you can do anything on linux you can do with Windows". I call bullshit. OpenOffice and Gimp can't do half as much in twice the time as Office or Photoshop...and they look like shit.


Exactly, I have been experimenting with designing and building a CarPC and i have been testing 2 front ends, roadrunner and centrafuse. Roadrunner is the open source and although i have to say it is a fairly amazing project, it is lacking a lot of the ease of use and polish you get with the closed source centrafuse. For these reasons when i have the project built ill be shelling out the $150 for centrafuse over the free opensource roadrunner.

One big problem with many open source projects come down to one of 2 things from my experiance. Too many cooks in the kitchen which leads to several groups within the project trying to pull it in different directions resulting in the product becoming dilluted with features or just completly non functional due to lack of a unified effort. The second camp is that the GUI comes second to functionality. Although i agree that functionality is a key point, the GUI should be considered as important as this is the front end that the users is going to be exposed to every time they use your product.

Now its true that with the right group working on the project you can overcome these limitations, Xbox Media Center is a perfect example, and im my oppinion a product that should be used as inspiration by microsoft for how a game console should be designed. But these seem to be the exception to the rule
 
The problem most people have with the Business model of FOSS is that it is entirely different than Boxed purchased software. It's also different in that the benefits to the developers may not be directly the same as from commercial software.

For instance: A developer may contribute their time and code to a "free" project, yet learn and gain significant experience that they then take to paid clients in customization and other related paid endeavors for the software. They may also get a job based on their proven skills and abilities in an entirely different area--but the "free" software was their training ground. This is similar to the internship model that gets pushed for people who have low experience in the job world--do something "free" and suddenly have the experience and skills that a paying job will accept. For some reason though people have a hard time seeing how these things are the same.

As for companies--just because one way of making money isn't working doesn't mean there's NO way of making money--you just need to see the different way. Customization and dedicated development are extremely viable ways of making money off FOSS, and the wide range of companies who develop plugins and other customization of many open source packages show this to be true. Can a huge multi-national company exist with this model? Maybe not, but a plethora of smaller companies can and do.
 
You are very well intentioned, and I'm glad that your business is doing well, but even you have to realize that what you are advocating is an Ivory Tower. Given the choice, most users will take what is free without a single thought of donating back to the developers. Most people don't have the presence of mind to understand that by only taking, and never giving, they are contributing to the downfall of that from which they are benefiting.

I fully understand that the developers are getting screwed in a sense. But, if the developer went into creating software for Linux without some way to get compensated who's fault is that?
It sure isn't Linux or GPL or the FOSS setup. The sad thing is for FOSS to work the way a software engineer or developer wants is that they need to have some business sense about them as well. They need to look at their options so they can reap the rewards from what they sow.
As an example. http://www.kanzelsberger.com/pixel/?page_id=8
Pixel is like Gimp or photoshop. The developer basically has his software sitting out there for free. You are only paying him for the updates to the current version. This was his goal so he could continue to support his software. He is trying to implement his business mind with his development work. For most programmers that need the money from their work something like this should be in place at a bare minimum in my opinion.
I might follow an Ivory Tower outlook in a sense by actually supporting the people that write code that's GPL but that again is my perogitive. And yes these developers are having there hands gnawed away by unapreciative users and business's. A smart business though will donate to these people and support them especially if the software the person or person's is producing is valuable to them. If not they are shooting them selves in the foot without them even knowing it.

A GPL developer just can't expect to make the money that someone in a proprietary environment can. But, this is why I showed Pixel as an example. This in my opinion is where developers need to be and start heading with their thoughts of what they are going to do for the future to protect themselves. You can never depend on a company that house's developers for the fact that lets say....

Microsoft has hired a person back in 1985. They were an astounding programmer and basically lifted the company into it's current limelight or at least helped with it. Now today he gets laid off. Was the money back them helping him now? Maybe if he saved enough or invested enough of it so he has a money tree waiting for him to pick from. Most likely this isn't the case. This developer is now no different than any other person coming out of college or even high school depending on the young person's abilities. The only thing this developer has now is that he can say he worked for MS and has 23yrs of experience. It doesn't readily make him a better programmer than someone straight out of college.

He can either try and get another job making software or trying his hand at getting him self setup in a way he can make money off of his own creation or ideas. The difference here is that most likely he is locked into around a set pay rate working for someone where as he has the potential to make more or less money on his own. It's more of a comfort factor.

I started my business with the intention of making money. Was I guaranteed any money? no. Was I looking for handouts? no . I was willing to take the risk to make more money than I would by working for someone else. When I first started I barely made enough to eat. But now that I have a name in my local city and state things are much more smooth for me in terms of cash flow.

/rant

Sorry for the long post. But people that think FOSS "is" broken need to wake up. They need to understand what they are getting into before jumping in. They need to make sure they have a backup plan to make sure that they can survive, if that is their intention.
 
I posted this on the business week comments section for that article. I as a business owner cannot make the money with a windows based product that I can with a Linux based product. I may not develop any software for Linux but I support those that do by donating a portion of the sales back to the software product I used. The problem as I see it for some of the recent comments from posters prior to me is that not enough of the companies are donating back to the developers of such software. This would be the only reason you would not be able to make your mortgage payments per say.

Now, software that is not GPL but that is used on Linux as pay to use basis is also very good in my opnion. They just get there donation up front is how I see it. I have no issues putting a proprietary program on Linux as long as it gets the job done for my customer.
Linux, for a small IT company that services almost the entire city we are in and various customers around the state solidifies us with good stable products that the customers appreciate and return to us for further hardware and/or software needs. Honestly since I have not found many companies in my state that support Linux or even Mac's it is almost a vendor lock in for our customers. This for my company and the people that work here are almost guaranteed a paycheck every week. This also trickles down to those that develop software for Linux in a donation or an up front fee for those that have a pay to use program.

I work at a local shop with two other people. All three of us own the company. Our bread and butter comes mainly from Linux based revenue. DVR's, Linux based servers, even starting some Linux based client machine have all done really well for us. All of our router setups are also Linux based. If Linux as a service was not a viable source of revenue then I am pretty sure I would know about it. I believe companies that have a hard time making money off of it are the ones that sink to much into one effort or one product. Linux is about versatility and usability. You must use all aspects of it in my opinion. If you find a good product that does good for you donate back. Tax write offs are grand. Companies that use Linux in my opinion must follow that course so the people that actually develop the software can be supported as well. Without them we would not have such great products to sell to our computer illiterate customers.

You are very well intentioned, and I'm glad that your business is doing well, but even you have to realize that what you are advocating is an Ivory Tower. Given the choice, most users will take what is free without a single thought of donating back to the developers. Most people don't have the presence of mind to understand that by only taking, and never giving, they are contributing to the downfall of that from which they are benefiting.

I have to agree with JethroXP here. Sure if everyone that used the software donated what they thought was a generous amount of money for it then sure it would help them get money. But as JethroXP stated, that isn't going to happen. A lot of people are going to be using it because it is free and not dontate a dime. You are going to have people that have the standpoint of "if I wanted to pay for software then I would have purchased some. I'm using free opensourced software because it is free." Assuming that everyone that uses free software is going to donate a fair amount of meney to the developer is like assuming that nobody is going to pirate another piece of software or music every again.

I will be honest and admit that I have never donated any money to anyone for any open source program I have ever used. If I wanted to spend money I would buy a comerical product. That doesn't mean that I don't understand where you are coming from, but as JethroXP said you are advocating an Ivory Tower. I'm not going to donate money to make myself feel better and to help some body keep working on his project as 1) I'm just not that nice of a person 2) I haven't seen any I feel are worth the money. Normally when I need to do something I'll start with the free / cheap solutions and work my way up. And for the stuff I have ended up using free open sourced programs for I have to cut back on what I am looking for and just be content with what I can get. Never have I found the perfect program, normally I am lucky if I come close. I'm the type of person that if I am going to have to pay $30 for a program, i'll go ahead and pay $80 for the commerically made product that meets more of my needs and I know will be of better quality. Thats not to say that in all cases the commerical app will be better or that all open source projects are junk. But In my opinion of what i have came accross for my needs it has been that way more often than not. Just like Loki008 and godfetish were talking about.


The problem most people have with the Business model of FOSS is that it is entirely different than Boxed purchased software. It's also different in that the benefits to the developers may not be directly the same as from commercial software.

For instance: A developer may contribute their time and code to a "free" project, yet learn and gain significant experience that they then take to paid clients in customization and other related paid endeavors for the software. They may also get a job based on their proven skills and abilities in an entirely different area--but the "free" software was their training ground. This is similar to the internship model that gets pushed for people who have low experience in the job world--do something "free" and suddenly have the experience and skills that a paying job will accept. For some reason though people have a hard time seeing how these things are the same.

As for companies--just because one way of making money isn't working doesn't mean there's NO way of making money--you just need to see the different way. Customization and dedicated development are extremely viable ways of making money off FOSS, and the wide range of companies who develop plugins and other customization of many open source packages show this to be true. Can a huge multi-national company exist with this model? Maybe not, but a plethora of smaller companies can and do.

So you are saying that if you work for some large scale company on some major commerical program that wouldn't help you in future jobs? I can see it now "Well I see here that you work for Microsoft on Windows and Office, you worked for Initut on Quick Books and you worked at adobe on photoshop and flash. I'm sorry but I don't think you are really qualified for our team. Maybe when you work on a few more smaller open source projects you will be ready for a job like this." :rolleyes:

What you are saying is correct though, you have to be able to adapt and change the way that you make money. That is what Red Hat did, they stopped offering just support and starting having a paid version of their OS. They started selling you a solution not just support.
 
And that's why the model is broken. As long as people maintain this romantic view of open-source being about "Free" software and thumbing their nose at the "man", it will fail. At the end of the day, people who invest their time and talent to bring you that free software still have mortgage payments, car payments, utility bills, grocery bills, and want to take a vacation to a sunny beach every once in a while.

Really? Its going to fail? Since when? Open source has been doing just fine, and has been around longer than Microsoft has. Indeed, open source has been around just about as long as computers have been. Clearly it isn't going anywhere. I think you underestimate just how much development is done for selfish reasons. For example, a developer might want a program that has feature XYZ. Said program doesn't exist, so he makes it (because *he* wants it). Since the goal was never to make money off of that program, he opens up the source. Hell, that is the process through which the Linux kernel itself was born. The intent is/was never to make money, but rather to scratch a programming itch.

Hell, sometimes money doesn't even help open source projects. See: http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/archives/001158.html

I think this quote sums it up nicely:
Open Source is to Traditional Software as Terror Cells are to Large Standing Armies – if you gave a terrorist group a fighter jet, they wouldn't know what to do with it. Open source teams, and culture, have been developed such that they're almost money-agnostic. Open source projects run on time, not money. So, the way to convert that currency is through bounties and funded internships. Unfortunately, setting those up takes time, and since that's the element that's in short supply, we're back to square one.

Even for companies, the point isn't always to make money off of the software. Take Google, for example. They were responsible for about 1% of the Linux kernel changes. They don't sell Linux or hardware, but they do use Linux for their servers. By making it better, they make the software that they use better, which in turn helps their business. Likewise, companies like IBM help improve Linux so that it runs better on their hardware, which matters to the clients.
 
"Lunix" is "free" (I have a few versions of Red Hat and Ubuntu*), windows cost $$ (*same), yet I have 1 "PC" that runs Linux/Ubuntu. Why? because it(winXP) just works(99.9% of the time). I can game on XP, I can surf the web on XP, and I can watch movies on my PC, as I like to. Linux? Just forget it, that must be a hobby to be dealt with. Linux or Ubuntu takes so much fiddling with to use. I know, therefore I don't(use linux), lol.
 
article is full of fail....

if you want to make money writing software, write something that is unique, innovative, fills a niche, and works well, if you do these things, I guarantee you will make money.
 
You can never depend on a company that house's developers for the fact that lets say....

Microsoft has hired a person back in 1985. They were an astounding programmer and basically lifted the company into it's current limelight or at least helped with it. Now today he gets laid off. Was the money back them helping him now? Maybe if he saved enough or invested enough of it so he has a money tree waiting for him to pick from. Most likely this isn't the case. This developer is now no different than any other person coming out of college or even high school depending on the young person's abilities. The only thing this developer has now is that he can say he worked for MS and has 23yrs of experience. It doesn't readily make him a better programmer than someone straight out of college.

He can either try and get another job making software or trying his hand at getting him self setup in a way he can make money off of his own creation or ideas. The difference here is that most likely he is locked into around a set pay rate working for someone where as he has the potential to make more or less money on his own. It's more of a comfort factor.

Sorry, I chuckled out loud when I read this. Any developer hired at Microsoft in 1985, particularly an astounding one who has been actively writing code for the past 23 years is already a multi-millionaire. Microsoft hasn't ever laid off developers. Someone writing code for 23 years at MS would not, even if fired, find themselves suddenly competing with fresh college grads for a job, that is simply rediculous. I thought you were making really good points up until this part.
 
...snip
Microsoft has hired a person back in 1985. They were an astounding programmer and basically lifted the company into it's current limelight or at least helped with it. Now today he gets laid off. Was the money back them helping him now? Maybe if he saved enough or invested enough of it so he has a money tree waiting for him to pick from. Most likely this isn't the case. This developer is now no different than any other person coming out of college or even high school depending on the young person's abilities. The only thing this developer has now is that he can say he worked for MS and has 23yrs of experience. It doesn't readily make him a better programmer than someone straight out of college.

He can either try and get another job making software or trying his hand at getting him self setup in a way he can make money off of his own creation or ideas. The difference here is that most likely he is locked into around a set pay rate working for someone where as he has the potential to make more or less money on his own. It's more of a comfort factor.

...snip

I'm sorry but this right here is just plain wrong. Any developer that MS hired in 1985 is 1.)now gone from MS and is holding a senior management/executive position in another company and is making more than anybody here in this forum or 2) the only way they get to stay in MS for 23 years is that they are now in an executive position leading major projects. This line "The only thing this developer has now is that he can say he worked for MS and has 23yrs of experience. It doesn't readily make him a better programmer than someone straight out of college." is just dumb as far as I'm concerned.
 
Back
Top