Open side panel, fan blowing inside computer 24/7...feasible?

tjmaxwell

Gawd
Joined
Jul 13, 2004
Messages
549
Hi all,

I have an SLI rig that's running really hot (FX-55: 70-75C under load). It's also a fairly loud rig as you might expect with two GeForce 6800GTs. Anyway, my desk is currently up against the back wall in my basement. On the other side of the wall is our laundry/storage room. Rather than spend a ton of money on expensive heatsinks/fans or a watercooling setup, I was thinking of putting the machine in the storage room, leaving the side panel off, and having a table fan blow on it 24/7. I tried putting a fan on the floor blowing on my computer for about 10 minutes last night, and all the temps dropped like 15C almost immediately. Not only would this cool the machine much better, but it would also eliminate the fan noise. This would also be very easy for me to set up, but I'd probably end up leaving the machine on all the time.

So, the obvious question is whether or not there are any implications with this setup. As long as I was careful to blow out dust on a regular basis, are there any other problems with a setup like this?
 
Id guess it would be ok, a buddy of mine had one of those box fans blowing on his pc for 2 years straight. He never shut it down.
 
I wouldnt put that sucker in the laundry/storage room. Have you seen the amount of lint pulled out of the dryer? Each time you change that sucker, you cant help but have the stuff fly, and that is going to cake up fans and HS's like a mofo.

I'd think about a better air-cooling solution that makes use of a filter before placing it in an environment as electronic-unfriendly as a laundry area.

It will work, I'd seriously advise checking/cleaning it every week at minimum.
 
Hmm...good point. I didn't think of that. But the room is about 20 feet wide and the washer and dryer are on one end of the room and the computer would be on the opposite end. That should make somewhat of a difference. As for your suggestion of cooling with a filter, is there a particular product you recommend? Do you have a link? Thanks.
 
I would not recommend using the box fan for an extended period of time. You're likely to run into problems with EMI. Possibly damage your system. A better solution would be to just mod a few 12cm fans into the bottom part of your side panel or something.
 
don't put any regular house hold fan too close to your open case. a fan is a spinning magnet, it'll fuck up your hard drives and erase all your mp3's and goat porn.
 
How far away would it need to be? Is there a certain type of fan you can buy that won't generate any electromagnetic problems?
 
you spent a lot of money on a rig that is not worth experimenting with. dont damage it, save up some money and get some liquid cooling.
 
Kaizer said:
Id guess it would be ok, a buddy of mine had one of those box fans blowing on his pc for 2 years straight. He never shut it down.

QFT...I work with some folks that do this. It works well, I have done it some on a short term basis, before I went to water cooling.
 
When people are crashing in games and the PC is rebooting I generally suggest that option. As a temporary solution of coarse. It's not something that I would keep as a permanent solution. THe biggest reason is that the larger fan is also going to blow more crap into the PC. Not to mention if you have little kids or pets it is deffinately a dangerous situation.

I would go with modding the side of the case and add a couple of 120mm fans. Replaceable or reusable filters would be a good idea in that room as well. You should add those to all fans pumping air into the case. A cheap solution would be cheese cloth, you can get huge swaths of it relatively cheap and they can be attached directly to a fan grill. Just cut to fit.

Another thing to think about with the laundry room is the possiblity of fluctuating heat from the dryer. When that is operating it would increase the ambient room temp. which could also explain the higher temps currently in your PC. Fortunately though you are in a basement which is generally a cooler location than anywhere else in the house.
 
If you are operating a computer in a really inhospitable environment here is something you can do. Turn all the fans around so they are blowing into the case and put filters over the outside of them. I'm sure you can work out a way to set the filter up (duct tape anyone?). What this will do is keep debris from entering the case through any small openings, as the air will be pushed out through all the cracks. Be sure to check your filters regularly. It does offer more limited cooling as the hot PSU will blow into the case, but if your alternatives are a hotter case or fans stopping altogether due to a glut of lint I think the choice is clear. :)
 
its a really ghetto solution to a problem that would be solved by proper ventilation. servers run quad xeons and more without overheating because they're well made.
 
not taking it anywhere? screw it. dont listen to uppity purists here, I have ran a window fan against the case to handle the hot summer weather for 5 months a crack. Go for it and it will be fine.
 
You spent alot of money on the video cards alone. Another 200 for a watercooling setup isn't much, but could save you much.
 
M1ster_R0gers said:
not taking it anywhere? screw it. dont listen to uppity purists here, I have ran a window fan against the case to handle the hot summer weather for 5 months a crack. Go for it and it will be fine.

I agree - apart from the issue of magnetism you could easily do it, tjmaxwell.
I always had an idea that if you modded a case to fit a laundry exhaust fan to blow large amounts of air in you would be set no matter what system you put in. I don't think it would be feasible, but thats the kind of solution you are looking at (large fan, cool computer)
 
Well, I'm not sure what I should do now. My CPU temperature readings according to Asus Probe do show 75C under load, but my CPU readings in Everest Home Edition show about 50C under load. There is another temperature that Everest is detecting (Aux) that is matching up termperature-wise with that of Asus Probe so I'm not sure which one to believe. My video cards are idling at about 52C and go slightly above 60 under gaming load. These seem normal, if not slightly cooler than I've seen from similar cards. For some odd reason though, my video drivers are sensing ambient temperatures at about 80C, which cannot be accurate. Basically, my temperatures are so whacked that I'm not sure what to believe. I do know that my machine has been very stable so far, though I haven't tried gaming for over an hour at a time. I've run Prime95 for a couple hours with no errors too.

The company I bought the computer from has offered to take back the Zalman HSF and replace it with one of my choosing. Based on advice here and elsewhere, I was leaning towards getting a Thermalright XP-120 along with a SilenX 120mm fan. I, of course, need to buy the new heatsink and fan myself, and the company will refund me the value of the Zalman. Still the Thermalright/SilenX combination is about $90 shipped, and if my CPU temps really aren't as high as I'm thinking, I don't know if it's worth it to go through the hassle. I also have been seriously considering getting a couple of NV Silencer 5s to install on my video cards. They don't seem to be running that hot though, so that's probably pointless. That would also void my warranty.

I just thought the household fan idea would be an easy and very effective solution to my problem. I wasn't aware of all the implications though. It may be a "ghetto" setup, but it would cool very well and rid my setup of fan noise (which is fairly substantial at this point). I don't worry about the dryer since it's 20 feet away from where the computer would be, but I guess more dust and junk could get in there regardless. I also know absolutely nothing about setting up a watercooling system or doing my own case mods, so I don't think I should try to tackle those things. Not to mention I don't really have any time or money to devote to this kind of thing. Ugh...I don't know what to do.
 
I am assuming BossNoodleKaboodle wrote this in response to my post about what in the idustry is known as a positive pressure ventilation system
its a really ghetto solution to a problem that would be solved by proper ventilation

What you are referring to as a "ghetto solution" is actually a well known and accepted solution for operating computers in harsh environments. The ATX 1.0 specification actually called for positive pressure ventilation systems and ATX 2.0 still allows for it. Here is section 3.3.7 of the ATX 2.01 specification


It [the processor] may be cooled from either the fan located in the power supply, an active heat sink (fan attached to the processor), or normal airflowthrough the chassis.
Please note that a processor cooled by a "fan located in the power supply" is a by definition a positive airflow system.

Scott Mueller had this to say about the subject in his book Upgrading and Repairing PC's10'th Edition (which is highly recommended reading)
...if you held a lit cigarette in front of your floppy drive on a normal system the smoke would be sucked in through the front of the drive and could contaminate the heads. On an ATX system with reverse flow cooling, the smoke would be blown away from the drive because the only air intake would be the single fan vent on the power supply at the rear.

The following are links to industrial positive airflow cases.

CGI Computer Wares

Systel USA

ESIS

As far as BossNoodleKaboodle's comment that "servers run quad xeons and more without overheating because they're well made." has absolutely no place in this discussion as the environment we are talking about is one that is inhospitable to computers, and is not the 60 degree climate controlled server room that you would find most Quad Xeons running in. But even in a server room dust is a problem and positive pressure ventilation system can be beneficial.
 
Ugh...I don't know what to do.
Don't worry about it. plenty of people run their computers in exactly the configuration you were describing, room fan on it and case off. What matters is the airflow is getting onto the processor. Just leave the upstairs door open (hot air rises) and open any windows you can. Anyways I would be worried more about heavy gasses killing you in the basement than I would be about your computer... :D
 
its true that you'll never see a quad xeon system running in a dirty room with a fan blowing on its open case. you'll see them in clean AIR CONDITIONED ROOMS with closed cases. if you're in an inhospitible environment, why not get a ruggedized computer instead of blowing hot, dirty air over it with an open case and a room fan?
 
I appreciate everyone's advice on this matter. Chances are though, I probably won't be going the household fan route.

I ran the Prime95 "blend" torture test overnight last night with the side panel on and had no errors. My CPU was reporting 57C which is only about 2 degrees higher than my standard idle temps. When I do the test that utilizes the CPU 100% all the time, it would get up in the low 70s. Again, this is according to Asus Probe and I'm not sure if it's right. I also played HL2 for an hour last night and temps again got slightly above 70, but no locks or hiccups. I'm pretty sure that some of the temperature readings are inaccurate. If they were that hot, the machine should be shutting down on it's own according to what I've read. As stated, my ambient temps are reporting very high, but there's no way they could be accurate either. Ambient temperatures higher than the CPU core temp? That would be impossible. Anyway, I'll probably buy an XP-120 with a SilenX fan and see how that does. It just seems like a poor investment if I'm not even sure there's a problem.
 
I dont consider it a problem. Sure you might be in the 70 degree club, but arent the proccies rated at like 95-100+? someones gotta have the spec sheet.

Ok, so the room wont be the best place to OC with those temps, but who the hell cares? Your system is stable at those temps, right?

I wouldnt run it without a side, too much crap gets in there. Run it as normal until you get your usual place worked out.

When my old 1.0 ghz would overheat, you would hear the BIOS alarm start to go crazy, and games would start to chug. Yeah, I ditched the side of my case in that instance, but when it got under control, I put it right back on. You're not getting temp alarms, so why worry? :D
 
tjmaxwell said:
Hi all,

I have an SLI rig that's running really hot (FX-55: 70-75C under load). It's also a fairly loud rig as you might expect with two GeForce 6800GTs.
So, the obvious question is whether or not there are any implications with this setup. As long as I was careful to blow out dust on a regular basis, are there any other problems with a setup like this?


Jeez man just get a real heatsink/fan and it will fix your problem right up.

get a thermalright or a zalman.
 
I used a fan for a little while to keep my cheetahs cool.
pc_fan.jpg
 
>WP< $lipKnot said:
Jeez man just get a real heatsink/fan and it will fix your problem right up.

get a thermalright or a zalman.

I have a Zalman 7000 series cooler.
 
st4rk said:
don't put any regular house hold fan too close to your open case. a fan is a spinning magnet, it'll fuck up your hard drives and erase all your mp3's and goat porn.


Thats teh BS... I saw a article some where about magnet's and Hd's... I'll see if i can find it.
 
tjmaxwell said:
I have a Zalman 7000 series cooler.

Get a gigantic Thermalright cooler with a good fan then. Zalman 7000 series is not nearly as good of a cooler. I would go with a Thermalright myself but I am not overclocking much.

Also are you using arctic silver 5? If so how much did you use? I have found through several applications in several different machines that only a tiny bit helps heat transfer better. I used about the size of half of a grain of rice. Here are my temps for a 3.4 northwood overclocked to 3.6. 38 degrees at Idle and 50 at full load.
 
Back
Top