OnStar Halts High-Speed Chase

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The thing that impressed me the most with this story about OnStar disabling a vehicle to end a high speed chase, is that it took less than 16 minutes to capture the bad guys this way.

The 2009 Chevrolet Tahoe roared away with officers in pursuit, but shortly after the suspect made a right turn, operators at General Motors Co.'s OnStar service sent a command that electronically disabled the gas pedal and the SUV gradually came to a halt.
 
Silly bad guy. It's been advertised on television for several months now that if you have OnStar in a newer vehicles, it can be used to hamper theft and getaways.
 
California media outlets will soon sue OnStar....their ratings will tank without the 52 high speed chases a week. ;)
 
Personally I don't like the idea that someone could disable my vehicle remotely. Regardless if you trust your government or not ... there is no such thing as a totally secure network.
 
This will cause me to never buy a vehicle equiped with it. Forgive me for wearing a tin hat on this one, but am I the only one who thinks if this thing is as secure as a voting machine it's a very bad idea? You can tell me all the white lies about "we promise to use it only with your permision" and "you have to authorize" bs. The telecoms weren't suppose to let the feds wire tap US citizens either and I think we've all seen how that played out.
 
They can do anything they want with On-Star, it literally is a hook into the entire vehicle network. Monitor anything, do anything. There are hundreds of points of data they can monitor and dozens of commands they can send. (Turn off fuel pump, turn off engine, unlock the doors) whatever they want. Im suprised it took 16 minutes. Most of that time was probably spend with police talking to onstar on the phone trying to identify the proper vehicle and prove they were law enforcement.
 
Personally I don't like the idea that someone could disable my vehicle remotely. Regardless if you trust your government or not ... there is no such thing as a totally secure network.

Well, it isn't like anybody is forced to buy a vehicle with OnStar. In fact it is an add on even to the vehicles that come with it - an addon you don't have to pay the extra money to have.

It certainly helped return this guy's property, and vehicle in undamaged condition and caught a violent criminal. Although how many people 'hang out' with their cousins in empty parking lots at 3AM doing nothing? Since Jose says the cops didn't give back some of his cash maybe they think he was doing something too?
 
This will cause me to never buy a vehicle equiped with it. Forgive me for wearing a tin hat on this one, but am I the only one who thinks if this thing is as secure as a voting machine it's a very bad idea? You can tell me all the white lies about "we promise to use it only with your permision" and "you have to authorize" bs. The telecoms weren't suppose to let the feds wire tap US citizens either and I think we've all seen how that played out.

Just like credit cards and network security, it's always a sliding scale between convenience and lockdown.
 
It didn't take long for the obligatory "Government owns you!" responses did it?

Onstar is not a Government device. It's a device that the owner of that Tahoe elected to have included in the car so it wouldn't vanish forever. It's an option, not a requirement. I'll gladly have it on my next car.

And, as the usual response to conspiracy theorists goes "If you aren't doing anything illegal you have nothing to worry about." Don't go taking your own car on a high speed chase and you won't run into any trouble.

All this fear of technology is mind-boggling.
 
It didn't take long for the obligatory "Government owns you!" responses did it?

Onstar is not a Government device. It's a device that the owner of that Tahoe elected to have included in the car so it wouldn't vanish forever. It's an option, not a requirement. I'll gladly have it on my next car.

And, as the usual response to conspiracy theorists goes "If you aren't doing anything illegal you have nothing to worry about." Don't go taking your own car on a high speed chase and you won't run into any trouble.

All this fear of technology is mind-boggling.

It's not a fear of technology, it the fear of the shackling that technology potentially brings to it. To not be fearful or at least suspect is to be stupid.
 
It's not a fear of technology, it the fear of the shackling that technology potentially brings to it. To not be fearful or at least suspect is to be stupid.

Or to be fearful is paranoid. Everyone's jumping at shadows these days. :rolleyes:
 
Hehe, makes me think of a new type of wardriving. How long before a clever hacker finds a way to access these via a laptop, and starts turning random people's brakes off? I don't think it's possible yet, and I'm not up to speed with onstar systems anyway but, kind of scary to think about no?
 
It didn't take long for the obligatory "Government owns you!" responses did it?

Onstar is not a Government device. It's a device that the owner of that Tahoe elected to have included in the car so it wouldn't vanish forever. It's an option, not a requirement. I'll gladly have it on my next car.

And, as the usual response to conspiracy theorists goes "If you aren't doing anything illegal you have nothing to worry about." Don't go taking your own car on a high speed chase and you won't run into any trouble.

All this fear of technology is mind-boggling.

We already see this sorta thing already. You use a telephone? It's not run by the government, but they can listen onto your conversations at any moment. So, who's to say the government can't get their hands on OnStar and disable your engine when they see it being necessary?

What I do with my car is my business. I pay for it, both car insurance and all the other typical expenses. If anything, OnStar should give me the magic button to disable my car, and not the police. God knows it's much faster then going through their customer service. I don't wanna have to call them to press it.
 
Or to be fearful is paranoid. Everyone's jumping at shadows these days. :rolleyes:

Well, I think it was best said by a comment on the news site. "The benefits are real, as seen today. The negatives are hypotheticals that people think 'might' happen."
 
Its only a matter of time before skynet purchases onstar and then uses remote controlled SUVs to enslave humanity.
 
I just have to remember to unplug it next time I decide to go on a high speed chase.
 
Its only a matter of time before skynet purchases onstar and then uses remote controlled SUVs to enslave humanity.

Good, humanity should be enslaved. With the amount of stupid people walking the Earth, coupled with all those left who are paranoid and think they should be walking around with innate freedoms, I'm glad "Big Brother" was able to shut off the vehicle. All those crying foul are usually those who have something to hide or are intent on doing harm. If you want an aspect of your local government to change, guess what, write a letter to your congressman and quit whining
 
Well, it isn't like anybody is forced to buy a vehicle with OnStar. In fact it is an add on even to the vehicles that come with it - an addon you don't have to pay the extra money to have.

Not yet.

But consider that we're forced by law to wear a seatbelt, and forced by law to carry auto insurance. How long will it be before we are forced by law to "carry" OnStar. If they can force us to buy insurance, and wear a seatbelt, why cant they force us to buy OnStar in the interest of "public safety"?
 
Well, I think it was best said by a comment on the news site. "The benefits are real, as seen today. The negatives are hypotheticals that people think 'might' happen."

Yeah and warrentless wiretaps on US citizens were illegal and hypotheticals too until they were exposed. So far ONE, let me repeat that ONE time this is actually been used to stop a chase. Seeing how it is installed on tens (or is it hundereds?) of thousands of vehicles, the technology hasn't even payed for it's self yet. Yet we've ADDED a security problem to vehicles every where.

Let's assume for a min there is a bug in the code. Not even anyone being malicious, just a bug in the code and all these equipped vehicles suddenly stop working for a day. Just one day. What do you think the lost productivity would be? How many millions would be lost? All for what? So far we have only seen 1 chase actually stopped. Now lets think about what would happen if someone actually got control of this. Economically, it would be a horrific disaster.
 
Not yet.

But consider that we're forced by law to wear a seatbelt, and forced by law to carry auto insurance. How long will it be before we are forced by law to "carry" OnStar. If they can force us to buy insurance, and wear a seatbelt, why cant they force us to buy OnStar in the interest of "public safety"?
They can. Given the fact that driving on public roads is a privilege and not a right. If you don't like it, then you can simply exercise your freedom of choice and quit driving.
 
I'd love to get similar equipment installed and just connect a wireless phone. It could charge as I drive and if the vehicle goes missing I can kill it myself and retrieve the location for the cops. No monthly service fee or trusting in the well-proven-to-be-highly-unreliable goodwill of my fellow man, be it politician, police officer, or bored OnStar operator.
 
If you're concerned about big brother, then this story, from all the way back in 2003, will really set you off.
 
What if it was the owner that was fleeing from the cops in that SUV? Does the police (i.e., gov.'t) have the authority to contact OnStar and tell them to disable the vehicle? If so, that's scary. :eek:
 
Or to be fearful is paranoid. Everyone's jumping at shadows these days. :rolleyes:

Fearfulness is not paranoia nor is it vice versa. I simply meant that a healthy dose of caution and suspicion towards what your government does is a good thing. That should be the duty of a free people. The argument of "well, if you have nothing to hide." is a canard. It's not about having anything to hide that should prevent my government from intruding any further into my life, it's the fact that they think they can whether I have anything to hide or not. If I have nothing to hide and therefore I shouldn't fear my government, then for me to have that naive view of citizen/government interaction should keep them at bay right? My privacy is mine. While it isn't specifically mentioned in the Constitution, it is however implied in decades of precedent law. I'm not jumping at shadows, but I would rather have my government fear me to keep them honest instead of the other way around.
 
Fearfulness is not paranoia nor is it vice versa. I simply meant that a healthy dose of caution and suspicion towards what your government does is a good thing. That should be the duty of a free people. The argument of "well, if you have nothing to hide." is a canard. It's not about having anything to hide that should prevent my government from intruding any further into my life, it's the fact that they think they can whether I have anything to hide or not. If I have nothing to hide and therefore I shouldn't fear my government, then for me to have that naive view of citizen/government interaction should keep them at bay right? My privacy is mine. While it isn't specifically mentioned in the Constitution, it is however implied in decades of precedent law. I'm not jumping at shadows, but I would rather have my government fear me to keep them honest instead of the other way around.

There are so many technology and devices that can be controlled remotely. Laptops, phones, street cameras, RFID chips, your cable television, your electricity and water and gas, food being shipped to supermarkets can be tampered, etc etc etc etc etc

Why the hell are people so wary of OnStar? Why the hell are people always inventing new worries when new devices come out, when it's going to be the same as everything I've listed in the last paragraph?

The government doesn't give a shit.
 
They can. Given the fact that driving on public roads is a privilege and not a right. If you don't like it, then you can simply exercise your freedom of choice and quit driving.

Can i stop paying for the public roads and highways in my taxes then?
 
If you're concerned about big brother, then this story, from all the way back in 2003, will really set you off.

Huh, so much for hypothetical. This is the same guys that did warrentless wiretapping so why am I surprised?
 
They can. Given the fact that driving on public roads is a privilege and not a right. If you don't like it, then you can simply exercise your freedom of choice and quit driving.

So what came first, the laws for the roads or the roads? Wait... You mean we used to be able to drive on the roads before there was a law of the roads to dictate what we could and could not do.

Freedom is the right to act according to ones will without being held up by the power of others. From a philosophical point of view, it can be defined as the capacity to determine your own choices. It can be defined negatively as an absence of subordination, servitude and constraint.

In case you forgot.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I always find it funny how people always think something is great because the government said so. To bad the government thinks war, inflation, and genocide for some is okay. I bet we won't see a law prohibiting any of those though.

Just saying but I guess mandatory On-Star is okay though(how many new cars don't have them built-in?). I mean who cares about the mistakes that will cost countless lives from the use of this tech, but hey it stopped one bad guy. So let's spy on all the people with a new car and promote this technology with one bad guy in a stolen car. yay

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So qdemn7, is living a privilege or a right?

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The government doesn't give a shit.

So the more capable in monitoring us they become, the less they care! Weird to say the least.
 
On Star is totally useless if a true auto thief knows what he is doing. My sister had her 2007 Onstar equipped Trailblazer SS stolen and when the cops contacted OnStar 15 minutes later they were not able to get a signal at all.

My neighbor says that the good thiefs know where the unit is located and remove it within minutes of stealing the vehicle. The alarm that was installed was uselsss as well.
 
The government has a proven track record for abuse of power ... from Japanese Americans during WW2 to as recently as Gun Sieges in the wake of Hurricane Katrina ... it is healthy to not blindly and trustingly to grant more power to the government.

That said, I am more worried about hackers gaining control of OS and thus access to my vehicle. Being broken down randomly in the middle of no where or, worse, where someone else wants me to be ... is sort of scary. As I said, there is no such thing as a perfectly secure network.
 
On Star is totally useless if a true auto thief knows what he is doing. My sister had her 2007 Onstar equipped Trailblazer SS stolen and when the cops contacted OnStar 15 minutes later they were not able to get a signal at all.

My neighbor says that the good thiefs know where the unit is located and remove it within minutes of stealing the vehicle. The alarm that was installed was uselsss as well.

I'd think they could find a way to hide it so it would take a long time to remove, but a modified cell phone jammer would probably block the signal and render it unusable. Point being - yeah, you'll stop a determined thief, but it might reduce the number of more amateur ones.
 
Sorry, amend 'you'll stop a determined thief' to 'you'll never stop a determined thief'
 
There are so many technology and devices that can be controlled remotely. Laptops, phones, street cameras, RFID chips, your cable television, your electricity and water and gas, food being shipped to supermarkets can be tampered, etc etc etc etc etc

Why the hell are people so wary of OnStar? Why the hell are people always inventing new worries when new devices come out, when it's going to be the same as everything I've listed in the last paragraph?

The government doesn't give a shit.

This is true and this is what I was saying before, it's not the fear of the technology, but rather what the technology is capable of doing. Any of these devices could come under the auspices of control from your government or some other nefarious/dubious entity. You can perceive that worry no? It's not that I'm scared, it's that I have to make the assumption that negative aspect of technology is always there, lying in wait. Most people are oblivious, guys like us are not and in that knowledge comes the caution. That's all I'm saying.
 
Can i stop paying for the public roads and highways in my taxes then?

You can, but you would be paying a higher price for that decision. Even so, the regulatory infrastructure by which those taxes are extracted from you do not leave it up to you to say no. It's done automatically as a method of implied consent.
 
What benefit would the government derive from being able to shut down your car at any time?

In the event that you are breaking the law, I don't see that your freedoms are being restricted if your car is shut down while you are fleeing from law enforcement.

What I would be more concerned about is the bank that lent you the money to purchase the car then disabling it if you're late on a payment. Anyone have a contract on one of these?
 
Fear big brother, but until it starts happening, who cares? I see nothing wrong with this.
 
Not related to story at hand, but does anyone know if Onstar still calls the police and fire if you don't have an active subscription? They have those commercials on how it calls in the event of an accident. If no subscription, do they just let you sit there and die? Just curious, SO has it in her car, no clear answer on teh google.
 
Back
Top