OnLive Has Bit The Dust?

And the statement from the OnLive PR flak:

no comment on the news other than to say, the OnLive service is not shutting down.

AKA: We're selling off all the IP for someone else to run, and laying everyone off.


And to those blaming it on the founder who just left - that is of course possible, but don't jump to that conclusion, it was probably the VCs. Happened to the dot com I worked for over Y2K. The founders both got screwed just as bad as the employees. The VCs sold off all the IP, the founders got a tiny slice of cash, every other stockholder got exactly zero.
 
The rumor is circulating that OnLive will continue under a new brand and customers will not lose their games... This is sad for all those that have been layed off.
 
what they are doing is trying to get rid of some servers which they had contracts because they didn't need that many. They overestimated the amount of people that will be interested in onlive. They could not get rid of the servers without getting fined so they found some loophole where if another company buys their company. the contracts will all be invalid.
 
what they are doing is trying to get rid of some servers which they had contracts because they didn't need that many. They overestimated the amount of people that will be interested in onlive. They could not get rid of the servers without getting fined so they found some loophole where if another company buys their company. the contracts will all be invalid.

From what I've seen I think this was the crux of OnLive's problems and they seem to have found a creative way to solve it for now. That said, it does seem to not bode well for their future, the real problem OnLive has is what value they truly bring to the table. The service does reduce the initial cost of gaming but with a lot strings attached as well and it's a reoccurring cost to users and a subscription model is easier said than done. And it also has a distinct problem of making less, not more mobile because of the bandwidth necessary to run it.

Cloud economics and technology at this time have a lot of practicality issues ranging from performance but most importantly cost.
 
I honestly believe that significant OnLive style streaming of games, where your home appliance is just a thin client is inevitable.
To an extent OnLIve proved it was viable, just about (in that the service was actually up an running and people were using it), it's just a couple of years ahead of it's time.

I reckon the real reason for this (or at least the timing of it) is the next gen of console hardware being just around the corner, and they realised they'd need to make a massive capital investment to upgrade their server farms to render the newer generation of games, and the money just wasn't there, so they needed to change their model.

As others have suggested, I suspect they'll move towards licensing their technology out to others, rather than trying to run their own servers.

When the whole "Windows 8 is a catastrophe" thing was happening a few weeks back, one of the things that occurred to me was that streaming gaming bypasses all that type of crap, and I could totally see a company like Steam being very interested in a platform neutral delivery system.

One of the biggest costs in game development is porting and QAing your product across multiple platforms, and getting it validated by the first party platform holders, with streaming games you don't have to worry at all about what's sitting in your end users living room/study/bedroom, it just works, which cuts a huge overhead off your costs.

There is simply no way that the major publishers/developers are not interested in that, but most likely OnLIve/Gaikai-Sony have a bunch of core patents there that made it impossible to do anything, this change in OnLIve might open things up a little, especially if part of the change is that OnLive isn't as focused on being a platform in it's own right.

I would go further an say that I would not be even remotely surprised if we saw streaming type options make their way into Origin/Steam/Battlenet/Etc within the next 5 years.

At the very least I think they will use it for Demo/Starter type experiences, where you can play a limited cloud version of the game at a reduced cost, with an option to upgrade to the full "local" version or some crap like that.
 
Fake edit: Just to clarify, I think we are a long way from streaming cloud games replacing local hardware and software (as in, it won't happen until everyone has fibre internet :p), but I don't think we are that far away at all from it becoming a much more significant part of the gaming landscape in one form or another.
 
Fake edit: Just to clarify, I think we are a long way from streaming cloud games replacing local hardware and software (as in, it won't happen until everyone has fibre internet :p), but I don't think we are that far away at all from it becoming a much more significant part of the gaming landscape in one form or another.

Absolutely the cloud in all forms is significant. The issue is cost. The cloud has to be cheaper than current models before it's viable.
 
It was a good idea that took the wrong direction. Physical media will be phased out sooner or later as more & more developers are turning to digital distribution. It's starting from the bottom up as many of the best Indy developers are 100% digital distribution. It's a smart move from a business standpoint but many consumers don't like the idea of it. They'll just have to learn to accept it :).
 
The problem is hardware and bandwidth costs. You have continuous costs for something that you can't charge that much for access to. I have experience with a cloud-hosted web application and the costs are surprisingly high, businesses can afford them and it's often worth it for the ease of use and lack of infrastructure but for $29.99/month (which is about as much as OnLive can realistically charge) there isn't much cash left over after licensing, and hosting costs. This is why client-server systems make sense. Low-end equipment is factors of magnitude cheaper than enterprise-level stuff.
 
Wouldn't be surprised if Google didn't buy them. Why? At Fiber Space in Kansas City, one of the areas was the OnLive demo. Google and OnLive are partnering together to offer the service along side Googles Fiber service. Would be a great fit I think.
 
Wouldn't be surprised if Google didn't buy them. Why? At Fiber Space in Kansas City, one of the areas was the OnLive demo. Google and OnLive are partnering together to offer the service along side Googles Fiber service. Would be a great fit I think.
that would be an interesting and incredible move
 
Do you know even a single person who has online? It was a great concept that if you did not have money for a gaming PC you could buy a $100 device and play games online. You can get a gaming PC for as little as $800 today. And build one for about $650 if you know what you are doing. open box PC's are even cheaper. Just saying there are better options. If they laid off their entire staff they are going out of busines or being restructured or bought.
 
This was the ultimate in the app store model. Maybe even a little beyond the app store model. People put up with the app store model on smartphones because apps are $1-$4. Beyond that price, I don't think people will put up with it. A vast miscalculation by microsoft.

They were suppose to be on OUYA and with android app type prices etc, it may have worked. I half wonder if OUYA took their 8x larger than they asked for funding and bought this service. The vid I saw on OUYA had someone talking like Free to Play crippleware model was awesome and with android they believe the app store model as well. Onlive fits right in there with those.
 
Do you know even a single person who has online? It was a great concept that if you did not have money for a gaming PC you could buy a $100 device and play games online. You can get a gaming PC for as little as $800 today. And build one for about $650 if you know what you are doing. open box PC's are even cheaper. Just saying there are better options. If they laid off their entire staff they are going out of busines or being restructured or bought.

Any sub-400 dollar desktop with a ~50-100 dollar video card that won't push the poor little power supply too hard and you get a PC that can run most games at 1366x768. Its not exactly a screaming monster, but if all you don't need to have bragging rights in your forum sig, it'll probably run current console ports.
 
whats OnLive?

Funny I was wondering the same thing....

That comment may suggest why its going bye bye?
sorry but I find it odd that you could not have heard of onlive yet you post on a forum like this.


and even if you have truly never heard of it, I am sure you know there is a thing called google so you dont have to ask questions like that. then again that might be why you guys are out of the loop in the first place. :D
 
sorry but I find it odd that you could not have heard of onlive yet you post on a forum like this.

Not everyone here is interested in gaming. Some of us participate for other reasons or are interested in computer equipment because of the many other things it can do besides offer us amusement.
 
Wasn't a fan of the concept of OnLive in the first place, not entirely disappointed it failed
 
Not everyone here is interested in gaming. Some of us participate for other reasons or are interested in computer equipment because of the many other things it can do besides offer us amusement.
I was not referring to gaming but just to the fact that this site talks about tech in general. its just hard to fathom anybody that pays attention to tech sites not knowing what onlive is.
 
Joystiq claims via a source that OnLive's CEO only managed to attract 1600 subscribers. http://www.joystiq.com/2012/08/18/documenting-the-death-of-onlive-notes-from-the-companys-final/

Ouch.

What's pretty sad is the very many people, including some here, who were so positive about the service. Big surprise, even they probably didn't support it. The paid "marketers" at least could count the reasons (in their compensation dollars) for hyping it up. I'm only surprised OnLive floated that pig for years before it failed. It will virtually become impossible for OnLive to survive in the face of competition from game publishers offering similar services. Grave's dug, waiting for the corpse to fall in.
 
* ...OnLive's CEO mentioned the company only managed...
 
Onlive seems pretty laughable in retrospect. Anyone with a brain knew this would never work because internet connections are too laggy and unreliable in the real world. The broadband infrastructure for this kind of service doesn't exist, and probably won't exist in the foreseeable future.
 
Onlive seems pretty laughable in retrospect. Anyone with a brain knew this would never work because internet connections are too laggy and unreliable in the real world. The broadband infrastructure for this kind of service doesn't exist, and probably won't exist in the foreseeable future.

That's kinda what I meant on the first page of the thread. The whole business model seems built on an absurd idea.
 
I downloaded OnLive.

My Impressions:

The Good:
Account signup was very quick, easy and painless
Very small download with no adware/toolbars/crap that typically installed with programs now a days.
I like to ability to instantly see and watch other people playing live.
The streaming takes no time to start, I was playing Batman Arkham Asylum in less than 30 seconds.

The Bad:
There is a noticeably input lag which would make playing any twitch/reflex dependent game difficult/impossible.
The graphics quality is not good, its about as good as an XBox 360.

I stopped playing after about 5 minutes, its just not going to be an enjoyable experience with the input lag, I could stand the graphics but not the input lag.
 
I downloaded OnLive.

My Impressions:

The Good:
Account signup was very quick, easy and painless
Very small download with no adware/toolbars/crap that typically installed with programs now a days.
I like to ability to instantly see and watch other people playing live.
The streaming takes no time to start, I was playing Batman Arkham Asylum in less than 30 seconds.

The Bad:
There is a noticeably input lag which would make playing any twitch/reflex dependent game difficult/impossible.
The graphics quality is not good, its about as good as an XBox 360.

I stopped playing after about 5 minutes, its just not going to be an enjoyable experience with the input lag, I could stand the graphics but not the input lag.

Pretty much it. The disadvantages are just so annoying that it out weights any true advantage the service has. Maybe 10 years from now when the internet infrastructure is further improved it will be a more practical idea but the latency issue will always be there simply because of the principles of physics , light is the fastest thing we know off but silicon is where the greatest amount of lag takes place.
 
Back
Top